2018 Defenders

[Yoda_]

Lot of love for Savage on here. Are people comfortable going with Laird as r1 and get two value options plus with good depth option rookie backs

Thats increasingly likely my defence option.

Laird, Hibberd, Savage, Bonner, Naughton, Doedee, Murray, Finlayson

 

[adam10]

Who you trying to convince?

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

I’m sharing my thoughts Pete.

 

[Axly]

Currently very tempted by Marchbank.
Great JLT performance.

Anyone else considering?

 

[buttox]

Currently very tempted by Marchbank.
Great JLT performance.

Anyone else considering?

Yup d3 for me.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Not good for Yeo owners ......looks like the Coach has been studying from Ross Lyons playbook .....going to be a jack of all trades ......buy at your peril

Simmo really is a *****


Love you Simmo

 

[Keg on legs]

Yup d3 for me.

My d4 at the moment

Will be the likely casualty if i need cash to bring danger back tho

 

[rumoursofwinter]

Sicily is a trap!

I don't know why. It's just the vibe. Actually, i think teams will tease him and he will lose the plot.

He gone. I suddenly like jj but can't fit him in my team?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Simmo really is a ********


Love you Simmo

We know he's a good bloke ......is he a good Coach ? .....genuine ? of a supporter

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Currently very tempted by Marchbank.
Great JLT performance.

Anyone else considering?

Could be a good pick .....but frankly not enough evidence of a change in role, for me to choose

 

[Mitchell54]

Can someone convince me that Bonner is a good choice.
What are you expecting from him

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Can someone convince me that Bonner is a good choice.
What are you expecting from him

Nope .....Rookie, outside receiver ......questionable JS

 

[rumoursofwinter]

I really like Bonner. He's a line breaker. He should be a good player for Port for ten years. I had him in my side for a while mainly because i like him. I just don't see the need for him in super coach at his price. He isn't contested. He's been a decent sanfl scorer without being massive. I think Lycett and Christensen have more upside at the price.

 

[Mitchell54]

What are the good defensive option under 540K

 

[Goats]

Currently very tempted by Marchbank.
Great JLT performance.

Anyone else considering?

Yep strongly considering for D3.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I really like Bonner. He's a line breaker. He should be a good player for Port for ten years. I had him in my side for a while mainly because i like him. I just don't see the need for him in super coach at his price. He isn't contested. He's been a decent sanfl scorer without being massive. I think Lycett and Christensen have more upside at the price.

Agree he's a real find & will be a good AFL player ......but that's often different to being a good SC player

 

[Mitchell54]

Currently very tempted by Marchbank.
Great JLT performance.

Anyone else considering?

 

[Riviat]

Yep strongly considering for D3.

Going to see how Sic goes in the first few rounds before deciding whether i should go Marchbank or not. If MB has the Doch role and starts going large and looks like earning lots of coin, there'll be a sidegrade on the table before Rd3.

 

[Yoda_]

What are the good defensive option under 540K

Savage, Lloyd, B.Ellis

 

[Yoda_]

Agree he's a real find & will be a good AFL player ......but that's often different to being a good SC player

Will end up the new Birchall. A reliable 74 - 86 average for 10 years with the odd average of 90+.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Will end up the new Birchall. A reliable 74 - 86 average for 10 years with the odd average of 90+.

That's a good comparison ......he'll be a future SC pick maybe, price depending

 

[Yoda_]

Can someone convince me that Bonner is a good choice.
What are you expecting from him

He's currently in my side..

Not many defensive options between $400,000 > rookie priced.

 

[Yoda_]

That's a good comparison ......he'll be a future SC pick maybe, price depending

What is his break even? can't seem to find it anywhere. If he can garner me $100,000, I'd be happy. With current evidence, will outscore all the current rookies and have some sort of job security.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

We know he's a good bloke ......is he a good Coach ? .....genuine ? of a supporter

Meh he's about a good a coach as me

 

[WaynesWorld19]

What is his break even? can't seem to find it anywhere. If he can garner me $100,000, I'd be happy. With current evidence, will outscore all the current rookies and have some sort of job security.

If i had the choice & i'm desperately trying to find a way ......Brayshaw is so underpriced as a DEF option .....i seem to get within 50K of getting him, but fall short

Bonner averaged 78 in his 2 games last year .......47 BE
Brayshaw averaged 72 in his 5 games last year ....58 BE .....better JS ??

 

[Mitchell54]

What is his break even? can't seem to find it anywhere. If he can garner me $100,000, I'd be happy. With current evidence, will outscore all the current rookies and have some sort of job security.

He’s got a B/E of 47