Oppo Camp Non Eagles AFL discussion thread II

[FKASC]

Look at the quality that's come back to Perth though: Bennell, Matera and Wilson (who's decent but a dip shit). Did I miss anyone?

Also we did get Tunbridge.

Lobb and McCarthy

But yeah it’s more an issue of the good WA kids staying interstate whilst the good Vic and SA players have bailed home

Edit - or the good WA kids have gone to Melbourne

 

[RookiePick]

[B]Josh Garlepp[/B]‏ @[B]JoshGarlepp[/B] 31m31 minutes ago
More
Coach Ross Lyon speaking at the club’s season launch says the group he has at @freodockers can bring the Dockers their first premiership. @FOXFOOTY @FOXSportsNews

Peel will be disappointed Freo are no longer considering their wins as Premierships. All that wasted press of Players in Dockers guernseys holding the WAFL cup.

 

[Bender_]

Lobb and McCarthy

But yeah it’s more an issue of the good WA kids staying interstate whilst the good Vic and SA players have bailed home

Edit - or the good WA kids have gone to Melbourne

True Lobb, still might’ve preferred him over Hickey, but don't think he's got the heart to play ruck that much.

 

[FKASC]

True Lobb, still might’ve preferred him over Hickey, but don't think he's got the heart to play ruck that much.

Yeah he’s a bit rubbish in the ruck. Not really sure he’s going to work out for freo under Lyon, but v early days.

 

[Keys]

Look at the quality that's come back to Perth though: Bennell, Matera and Wilson (who's decent but a dip shit). Did I miss anyone?

Also we did get Tunbridge.

And McCarthy lol

 

[HoneyBadger35]

True Lobb, still might’ve preferred him over Hickey, but don't think he's got the heart to play ruck that much.

Lobb is better than Hickey in general, and I don’t think it’s at all close.

However, purely as a ruckman, and on the budget we had to spend on our third choice ruckman, Hickey is a no brainer.

Can’t be spending money on guys on Lobb’s level when there’s the Gov, Gaff, Shuey, Yeo, Sheps of the world to pay.

 

[Bender_]

Lobb is better than Hickey in general, and I don’t think it’s at all close.

However, purely as a ruckman, and on the budget we had to spend on our third choice ruckman, Hickey is a no brainer.

Can’t be spending money on guys on Lobb’s level when there’s the Gov, Gaff, Shuey, Yeo, Sheps of the world to pay.

Yeah there's definitely bigger picture stuff to consider when recruiting.

 

[Keys]

Trade for Hickey - Downgrade pick 39 to pick 61 (Cameron) who we would’ve taken with 39 anyway as the draft panned out. We also swapped our 2019 4th round pick for St Kildas

Trade for Lobb - picks 11 and 19 for Lobb, 14,43 and 47. That trade cost Fremantle the opportunity to draft Jordan Clark

Hickey is probably on about half as much as Lobb salary wise

Lobb was a much better fit at Fremantle than he would have been for us and it’s no surprise we didn’t chase him too hard

 

[06Premiers]

Also love how the Fremantle board refer to us as the ‘Scum’ and Gaff as ‘GaFF’. Must’ve used all their collective intelligence to come up with those.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Pls explain the Gaff one?

 

[TY24]

Pls explain the Gaff one?

Go and Get, I'm sure you can work out what the F stands for

 

[DanWCE]

Go and Get, I'm sure you can work out what the F stands for

You made a typo.. Should have been GaGF

 

[TY24]

You made a typo.. Should have been GaGF

Ah yes, cheers for that

 

[06Premiers]

Ok, so the moral of the story is the Freo board is trash?

 

[30stm]

From one of BF members post...

If the Suns ever go belly up ..I think it may be good for everyone that a 3rd wa side was introduced. WC is bordering T-Rex status atm.. they have a huge stadium in wa now .. and its almost unhealthy to have such a unbalance control in that state. Maybe its to late...

 

[Mickey Rae]

From one of BF members post...

If the Suns ever go belly up ..I think it may be good for everyone that a 3rd wa side was introduced. WC is bordering T-Rex status atm.. they have a huge stadium in wa now .. and its almost unhealthy to have such a unbalance control in that state. Maybe its to late...

View attachment 633675

If a third side was introduced from WA about half the lavenders supporter base would move camps.

 

[Bender_]

If a third side was introduced from WA about half the lavenders supporter base would move camps.

Wouldn't be the first time.

 

[Mickey Rae]

Wouldn't be the first time.

Exactly...

 

[Ishmael_]

From one of BF members post...

If the Suns ever go belly up ..I think it may be good for everyone that a 3rd wa side was introduced. WC is bordering T-Rex status atm.. they have a huge stadium in wa now .. and its almost unhealthy to have such a unbalance control in that state. Maybe its to late...

View attachment 633675

I'd love to see this post illustrated as some bizarro Terry Gilliam animation.

The connections they're making are next level bonkers.

 

[DJMac]

Ok, so the moral of the story is the Freo board is trash?

One difference I noticed is the types of thread content:

From our board - “are-we-better-in-2018-than-in-2015”

From the Freo board - “comparing the rebuilds 2007-2012 vs 2016-present”

 

[MIKE85]

Haha, comparing the rebuilds!! The rebuilds that have amounted to nothing! They should really have a look at our off season rebuild from getting smashed in a semi to winning the flag

 

[RookiePick]

It's concerning to hear how many Freo fans are still putting their eggs in the Sandi and Fyfe basket.

Sandi is a geriatric who is worth zero around the ground these days and Fyfe...always seems to be labouring under an injury cloud.

I fear before too long they will have fallen into the vague and slightly hollow pre-season optimism that Sainter fans seem to have become expert in.

 

[Dazzler9]

It's concerning delightful to hear how many Freo fans are still putting their eggs in the Sandi and Fyfe basket.

Sandi is a geriatric who is worth zero around the ground these days and Fyfe...always seems to be labouring under an injury cloud.

I fear gleefully predict before too long they will have fallen into the vague and slightly hollow pre-season optimism that Sainter fans seem to have become expert in.

FTFY

 

[woosha24]

From one of BF members post...

If the Suns ever go belly up ..I think it may be good for everyone that a 3rd wa side was introduced. WC is bordering T-Rex status atm.. they have a huge stadium in wa now .. and its almost unhealthy to have such a unbalance control in that state. Maybe its to late...

View attachment 633675

Freo were introduced in the 90s to curb the rampaging Eagles. It didn't stop us, and the purps ongoing culture of sh*tness and failure is both a blight on the game and a testament to their roots.

Now people wanna do it again?

So whats the plan? Keep creating WA sides until the Eagles stop being good?

F*cken numpties...

 

[HoneyBadger35]

Not having Sandilands is one of the go to excuses already popping up on their board.

If you sign a 76 year old broken husk of a giant, you have to expect to not get 22 games a year from him.

He’s played 26 of their last 66 games. When you sign a guy coming off 39% availability in the three years prior, you have to know he’ll miss some time. Stop factoring him into your team, and just acknowledge that having him occasionally might be a nice cherry on top for a handful of games per year.

Poor bugger must just want to be able to rest.

 

[HoneyBadger35]

Freo were introduced in the 90s to curb the rampaging Eagles. It didn't stop us, and the purps ongoing culture of sh*tness and failure is both a blight on the game and a testament to their roots.

Now people wanna do it again?

So whats the plan? Keep creating WA sides until the Eagles stop being good?

F*cken numpties...

The richest club in football with one of the largest supporter bases and a stranglehold on their market may stutter if we introduce a fledgling competitor.

Seems wise as hell, let’s give it a go.