Banter FOOTY Banter! - Who will be better in 2026? Carlton or Collingwood Part 8

[Fadge]

NIck Daicos will get his chance to explore the open market when his next contract is due (2027 ?), so what do you think he will ask for, and will Collingwood pony up ?

Why does he have to wait until his next contract is due?

Curnow didn't.

And do you think Daicos will hold Collingwood to ransom by saying 'such and such a club are offering me $20 million over 5 years, so I'm not staying at Collingwood for a cent less...'

 

[Fadge]

And yet you continue to avoid the question I asked.

The question was answered - every player can demand more in the open market, but strong clubs retain their players for less.

 

[Fadge]

So over the last 24 hours, we've learnt that Curnow And TDK weren't amongst Carlton's best players, and Callaghan would have 'acted differently' if the offer from St. Kilda was the same as TDK was offered....

LOLOLOL.

 

[Zevon]

Merry Christmas Blues and Pies folk.

Hopefully 2026 brings you every footy supporter’s dream… either a flag, or maybe getting to play Sydney in the Grand Final… which are basically the same thing now that I stop and think about it.

 

[jezzajay]

Really?

Curnow and TDK aren't amongst your 'best players'?

Where on your list would you have ranked them?

Because I had them amongst your top 6. As would all rational and logical observers.

Charlie was a couple of years ago yes.
He has slid big time for me. Wish him well but I’d be surprised to see him back to ‘his best’ form again. Time will tell.
TDK would be just in our top ten. Hasn’t been consistent enough.
Silvagni not close to our best.
Our best are still at the club.

 

[Fadge]

Charlie was a couple of years ago yes.
He has slid big time for me. Wish him well but I’d be surprised to see him back to ‘his best’ form again. Time will tell.
TDK would be just in our top ten. Hasn’t been consistent enough.
Silvagni not close to our best.
Our best are still at the club.

There's some coping mechanism right there....

 

[jezzajay]

There's some coping mechanism right there....

Good for you.

 

[Fadge]

Good for you.

Your coping is good for me?

How is that?

 

[Andrewgtv05]

Current decade - 2021 to present - Collingwood
2011 to 2020 - Richmond
2001 to 2010 - Collingwood
......

Have you forgotten about Brisbane?

 

[jooce8891]

"Word is"
View attachment 2498493

just loves it at tiger land great sauces

 

[Fadge]

Have you forgotten about Brisbane?

You need to understand 'context of discussion'.

There were three teams being discussed, and Brisbane weren't one of them....

But unsurprising that Robo gives the post the thumbs up.

 

[Fadge]

Charlie was a couple of years ago yes.
He has slid big time for me. Wish him well but I’d be surprised to see him back to ‘his best’ form again. Time will tell.

I'll back him to have career best seasons with the likes of Gulden, Heeney and Campbell hitting him up, compared to the likes of Cripps, Acres and Walsh...

 

[Worm4]

I'll back him to have career best seasons with the likes of Gulden, Heeney and Campbell hitting him up, compared to the likes of Cripps, Acres and Walsh...

You proven to be shit at punting so back him as much as you like.

 

[Fadge]

OMFG.

Got another one for you, guys!

Old mate Robo has just likened Collingwood 'Carrying Pendlebury to the games record' to Carlton carrying Murphy to his 300.

Just when you thought you'd heard it all, along comes Robo!

 

[Robertio]

OMFG.

Got another one for you, guys!

Old mate Robo has just likened Collingwood 'Carrying Pendlebury to the games record' to Carlton carrying Murphy to his 300.

Just when you thought you'd heard it all, along comes Robo!

Now read my post again and you'll find i didn't likened the two situations at all, Christmas in Nuffington must be a weird place, but now that you've mentioned it the 2 situations will be exactly the same.

 

[Worm4]

Now read my post again and you'll find i didn't likened the two situations at all, Christmas in Nuffington must be a weird place, but now that you've mentioned it the 2 situations will be exactly the same.

Hardly surprising - attention seeking troll making up stories and parading as sandra sully in a different thread searching for extra likes.

 

[Robertio]

Hardly surprising - attention seeking troll making up stories and parading as sandra sully in a different thread searching for extra likes.

He has to learn that they're two different threads but thinking is not a priority in Nuffington.

 

[Fadge]

Now read my post again and you'll find i didn't likened the two situations at all, Christmas in Nuffington must be a weird place, but now that you've mentioned it the 2 situations will be exactly the same.

LOLOLOLOL.

This is Robo not likening our respective teams 'carrying' Pendlebury and Murphy to the games record and the 300 milestone respectively...

 

[Fadge]

He has to learn that they're two different threads but thinking is not a priority in Nuffington.

So what you post in one thread is not to be referenced in another thread and taken as fact?

 

[doppleganger]

LOLOLOLOL.

This is Robo not likening our respective teams 'carrying' Pendlebury and Murphy to the games record and the 300 milestone respectively...

View attachment 2501971

Poor form by Robo.

Marc Murphy the Shizens original chosen one!!

 

[Robertio]

LOLOLOLOL.

This is Robo not likening our respective teams 'carrying' Pendlebury and Murphy to the games record and the 300 milestone respectively...

View attachment 2501971

Where did i likened them, i simply posed the question if they would carry him, another flex that bombed for you.

 

[Robertio]

Poor form by Robo.

Marc Murphy the Shizens original chosen one!!

You missed as well, these nuffies are having a shocker.

 

[Robertio]

You settle in babe I'll go and do the cat shit xx

 

[Fadge]

Poor form by Robo.

Marc Murphy the Shizens original chosen one!!

Collingwood are a professional organisation who will be expecting to contend for a premiership in 2026, and Pendlebury is a proud player who will only reach the games record if he gets there on his merits.

Yet another key difference between Collingwood and Carlton.

 

[Robertio]

Collingwood are a professional organisation who will be expecting to contend for a premiership in 2026, and Pendlebury is a proud player who will only reach the games record if he gets there on his merits.

Yet another key difference between Collingwood and Carlton.

As i said it will be an interesting watch.