2011 Brownlow Medal Discussion

[blues4flag]

Murphy on 6 votes, Judd on 0.

Great start to Murphy. Had him down for 5 votes after two rounds - very good start. Judd was no monty for any but in line for the 1 in both games.

 

[Tanks_Alot]

Ha they played Walker's mark 3 times and Krakeour's mark of the year which is supposed to be better gets played only twice.

I guess the people who put the highlights package together know more than that clueless panel

 

[dumb]

i put some $ on murphy leading the team count at 4.25

 

[ESKIE]

Pendlebury at this stage I reckon.

 

[BLUES9898]

Good spread of players getting vote

 

[Bronze]

I feel really dirty saying this but I want Pendlebury to win as I'll pocket $1200.

 

[dumb]

robinson about to steal murphy/judd votes for the next few rounds

 

[Chism]

Cant help but think Mitch will have a Red X next to his name for the next decade when looking at the Brownlow scoreboard!!

 

[blues4flag]

Robinson very surprising 3 votes vs Melbourne. Thought he was a chance for the 1 but Murphy and Judd were clearly our best.

 

[blues4flag]

They confusing Scotland for Murphy? Scotland nowhere near the best whereas Murph was a deadset certainty vs the Lions.

 

[blues4flag]

Who's that sitting next to Murphy?

 

[Bronze]

Who's that sitting next to Murphy?

His brother.

 

[portaz]

Who's that sitting next to Murphy?

Its his older brother Leigh...

 

[AndyLucimitis]

Looks like Dane Swan will win. Well deserved.


Wonder if the Collingwood supporters will still think the Brownlow is a joke ???

 

[portaz]

How in the world does judd be raging favourite for practically the whole year and be so far behind... Suppose it evens up last years shock win...

Swan will surely win it...

 

[ClassyCarlton]

It has been good to see Robinson being recognised by the umps
Not that he will come close to winning and he was suspended, but nice he is getting noticed

 

[Bronze]

Clearly the umpires think that Judd's report card was marked lightly last year. Conversely Swan. Judd has missed votes on some games he was definetly in the best few.
Looks like Swan has this one.....sssshhhhhhhiiiiiiii....

 

[BLUES9898]

How did Robinson get suspended

Good to see that we have 5 in the top 30

 

[blues4flag]

What games? Judd's votes were always going to come in between rounds 15-21 and unfortunately, in such a high scoring count it's not going to be enough.

Murphy is the very stiff one. Can't believe he got no votes vs Brisbane and stiff to not get 3 vs Adelaide.

 

[The Flying Doormat]

This why you dont bet on the Brownlow. Its all about the the umpire's opinions and, it appears, agenda. I was itching to throw some of my hard earnt on Juddy, but chucked it on the Geelong / Collingwood double on the weekend instead. Safer bet.

 

[marleyblue]

I feel really dirty saying this but I want Pendlebury to win as I'll pocket $1200.

I know the feeling - I'm cheering on Swann for $1200

Was really hoping Murph would pull it off as I managed to get on @ $51 in the pre-season. Hopefully he can snag it, along with the Norm Smith next year

 

[Dumpstar]

Judd 3

 

[blue gunslinger]

Proddis wins I am moving to bignetball

 

[blues4flag]

Murphy killed by the 1 votes. 6 of them, most stiff.

 

[Tanks_Alot]

Murphy killed by the 1 votes. 6 of them, most stiff.

Murph will win it next year, not that the umpires opinion really matters to me just would be good to see him get a brownlow.