2011 Official Trade/Delisting Discussion Thread II

[gO_bOmBeRz]

Myers and Gumby for pick#4 ? they would be in stitches from laughter.

 

[gO_bOmBeRz]

Gaff.

I say we should ask for their first round pick as well.

haha.

Just if the Gaff wanting to come back home rumors were true.

Colyer + 1st rounder for Gaff. *dreaming*

 

[Childish Gambino]

Ah, the best of BigFooty:

C grader + C grader + say a 3rd rounder = first rounder

 

[Phone]

Howlett or Lonergan. Who do you guys prefer ?

howlett can also run with the ball and kick it decently. simple as.

 

[Kong]

Howlett or Lonergan. Who do you guys prefer ?

Howlett, quite comfortably.

 

[eth-dog]

With Guy McKenna signalling they may offload this seasons #4 pick, i'd highly consider putting a package together including David Myers and Gumby. God knows I love both players, but with Hurley emerging as a real dominant key position player, and with the likes of Dempsey and Winderlich returning after injury I don't know where these two lads fit in.

Reading some draft forums here, pick #4 would see you looking at the likes of Matthew Buntine or Billy Longer. Longer would be especially handy I believe, having a young out-and-out ruckman combining with the young midfield could prove invaluable. Drafting ruckmen is difficult though as their development is quite different.

Anybody else thought of a draft package for pick #4?

I would give up Monfries and pick 19 for pick 4. I would throw in Gumby if they wanted him too

 

[gO_bOmBeRz]

Monfries + 1st round draft pick for pick 4 ?

Would they accept ?

 

[Fin ice Smuggler]

Monfries + 1st round draft pick for pick 4 ?

Would they accept ?

Freo took Chris Bond and pick 21 (clem Michael) for Pick 2 (Brad Ottens-richmond) back many many years, I doubt anyone would be foolish enough to take that in a weak draft, any draft for that matter.

GC want KPP's

 

[gO_bOmBeRz]

How about Hooker + 3rd rounder

(All hypothetically speaking)

 

[Hencho]

Hooker and 19 for 4 and Toy?

I think we're getting overs but there ain't many reasonable key position backs floating around.

EDIT: I just re-read my post, I think I'm dreaming. this is always a fun game.

Bro-in-law and I play this game all the time. He always asks for Hurley. Most recently I said, the only person on the hawks list worth Hurley is Buddy, might need Cyril to sweeten the deal!

 

[Hencho]

On a more serious note, who could we pillage from the Saints now that Ross has gone?

Dal Santo? Montagna?

 

[gO_bOmBeRz]

Dal Santo turns 28 before the next season, Montagna 29. Too old.

Would love Dal Santo though.

 

[SirJimi05]

I would give up Monfries and pick 19 for pick 4. I would throw in Gumby if they wanted him too

I guess you missed the "stronger bodies" part?

 

[Skeeta Olly]

How about Hooker + 3rd rounder

(All hypothetically speaking)

You do realise how worthless a 3rd round pick is, yes?

 

[gO_bOmBeRz]

Edit: Sorry Hooker + 2nd rounder.

 

[Yoda_]

Angus Monfries would net us a top 30 pick IMO
Brent Stanton could net us a top 20 pick
Cale Hooker could net us a top 40 pick
Tom Bellchambers should net us a top 30 pick
David Myers could possibly net us a top 40 pick

(these are the players I would look at trading for the right price)

For the record, I would prefer Howlett in our side than Lonergan, he is more than a one dimensional player who is able to play multiple roles.

Couple of players I would like people to discuss

Jordan Jones (West Coast Eagles), 189cm, 90kg, HBF/Midfielder who has gone from reasonable half back flanker to WAFL midfield star. Consistently racks up decent numbers in the WAFL and is purely playing a waiting game as he is behind quite a few at WCE (Hurn, Butler, Waters, Smith, Embley to name a few). A Victorian who was picked late in the 09 draft, wouldnt cost much and just needs an opportunity.

Lewis Stevenson (West Coast Eagles), 189cm, 86kg, HBF/Midfielder, same scenario for Stevenson as that of Jones, doing plenty of good things in the WAFL but simply lacking an opportunity. A jet who uses the ball exquisitely, would fit in at Essendon.

 

[Skeeta Olly]

2nd round pick is 37 at best...

 

[Skeeta Olly]

Angus Monfries would net us a top 30 pick IMO
Brent Stanton could net us a top 20 pick
Cale Hooker could net us a top 40 pick
Tom Bellchambers should net us a top 30 pick
David Myers could possibly net us a top 40 pick

You have some low standards.

 

[timbo3195]

Colyer & Hardingham, rumour on the West coast board is they are right into Colyer.

I didn't manage to find any discussion about Colyer on the WC board.. Link?

 

[lamaros]

Angus Monfries would net us a top 30 pick IMO
Brent Stanton could net us a top 20 pick
Cale Hooker could net us a top 40 pick
Tom Bellchambers should net us a top 30 pick
David Myers could possibly net us a top 40 pick

I'd love to be an opposition club trading with you.

 

[Fin ice Smuggler]

(.

Angus Monfries would net us a top 30 pick IMO (probably correct but not worth it in this draft)
Brent Stanton could net us a top 20 pick (huge downside in that option)
Cale Hooker could net us a top 40 pick (hmm hawks got 2 first rounders for J. Hay who had depression issues, KPP's decent ones at that dont grow on trees I think he is worth much much more then a top 40 draft pick)
Tom Bellchambers should net us a top 30 pick (as above with hooker and would not entertain the thought anyway)
David Myers could possibly net us a top 40 pick (keep him, a good pre season away from fulfilling promise, not great against Carlton but not only one, just starting to grow into his body).

 

[Duckworth]

You have some low standards.

I think top 30 pick means at least/better than pick 30.

 

[gO_bOmBeRz]

I didn't manage to find any discussion about Colyer on the WC board.. Link?

Use the 'search' option on the board.

You'll find 35 pages worth of pages which contain Colyer in them.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Colyer's a promising-looking young player and I'm sure we'd be keen if he expressed an interest in coming back to WA.

I doubt the club would be looking to sell the farm to get him, though.

 

[Fin ice Smuggler]

Colyer's a promising-looking young player and I'm sure we'd be keen if he expressed an interest in coming back to WA.

I doubt the club would be looking to sell the farm to get him, though.

we'll sell him to Freo. Rossy Lyon has a penchant for taking midfielders from Essendon for first round draft picks, the upside is, this one will play at least one game for him.