Remove this Banner Ad

2012 Player Review

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Bombers36

Premiership Player
Jul 15, 2008
3,731
1,681
Keilor East
AFL Club
Essendon
I've done a quick review of each player and put them in 4 groups - those who didnt play seniors, those who had a year to forget, those who had an 'average' year, and those who remain important in the short and/or long term future. not everyone will agree with my comments or how I've categorised certain players, but it is what it is!



Didn’t feature

Ariel Steinberg
Age in 2013: 21, games 2012: 0, ave disposals: 0, tackles: 0, marks: 0, goals: 0
Athletic type still learning the game who like many others in 2012 had his injury issues. Club has shown faith in him by offering another contract and we’ll hopefully see him debut in 2013
Hal Hunter
Age in 2013: 20, games 2012: 0, ave disposals: 0, tackles: 0, marks: 0, goals: 0
Big bodied youngster currently on the rookie list whos football prowess may have been overshadowed by a full beard which gave him somewhat of a cult status amongst Bendigo fans. Played some good games for Bendigo before having some injury issues but showed enough to think he’s worth persisting with
Lauchlan Dalgleish
Age in 2013: 20, games 2012: 0, ave disposals: 0, tackles 0, marks: 0, goals: 0
Youngster who will be given time to develop at Bendigo
Luke Davis
Age in 2013: 21, games 2012: 0, ave disposals: 0, tackles 0, marks: 0, goals: 0
Was flying pre season and in the NAB cup but then cut down by injury. Hopefully can put this behind him and will be in line for debut in 2013 if we can impress again early next year
Anthony Long
Age in 2013: 22, games 2012: 0, ave disposals: 0, tackles 0, marks: 0, goals: 0
Perennially injured youngster and relation of former great unlikely to be kept on the list
Michael Ross
Age in 2013: 22, games 2012: 0, ave disposals: 0, tackles 0, marks: 0, goals: 0
Unsighted in the seniors this year after promising debit in 2011. Had injury issues and look for him to bounce back at Bendigo next year and push for senior selection
Brent Prismall
Age in 2013: 27, games 2012: 0, ave disposals: 0, tackles 0, marks: 0, goals: 0
Hasn’t played AFL since July 2011 will turn 27 in 2013. After a couple of major knee injuries and mixed form during his 61 game career certainly has his critics. Hopefully he can have an impact at senior level in 2013


Year to forget

Cale Hooker
Age in 2013: 25, games 2012: 17, ave disposals: 16.1, tackles: 1.6, marks: 5.6, goals: 0
Key position defender who has his share of both fans and critics. Was given the job to play on some of the games best key forwards Hawkins, Cloke etc in 2012 and has struggled on occasion, but to be fair hasn’t always had a lot of support. Can lack pace but usually very strong in the air if he can get to the contest - will be looking to improve in 2013
Henry Slattery
Age in 2013: 27, games 2012: 2, ave disposals: 4.5, tackles: 1, marks: 0, goals: 0
Seems to have gone backwards from the once aggressive back pocket/shut down player he once was. In the past would have been in line to be picked on the oppositions most dangerous small forward, but now a shadow of his former self and unlikely he will be at the club next year
Mark McVeigh
Age in 2013: 32, games 2012: 3, ave disposals: 13, tackles 1, marks: 5, goals: 0.3
End of the road for spike who hung up the boots before the last game of the season. Explaining the body was not coping with the rigours of AFL footy. Great servant of the club and will be remembered fondly by many fans for his aggression and team work, and leadership on and off the field
Jake Melksham
Age in 2013: 22, games 2012: 22, ave disposals: 14.9, tackles: 2.3, marks: 4.1, goals: 0.6
Played every game for the season but many were calling for him to be dropped given his form -particularly later in the season. His decision making is questionable although this may just be a confidence thing – and he really seems to be a confidence player. It looks like the selection committee are going to persist with him and there is obviously some upside – jake just needs to show it more often and become more consistant
Kyle Reimers
Age in 2013: 24, games 2012: 5, ave disposals: 10, tackles 2.4, marks: 4.2, goals: 1.2
Interesting player often overlooked for a senior game inspite good form at Bendigo and a long injury list. Very dangerous around goal and can play on the ball, will be interesting to see what happens for Kyle in the off season as seems out of favour at Essendon…
Jason Winderlich
Age in 2013: 29, games 2012: 2, ave disposals: 11, tackles: 2, marks: 5, goals: 2.5
Gifted forward sometime midfielder whos body is struggling with the rigours of AFL football. cant help but feel for Winders who has played only 6 games sinse August 2010 which is a concern. Many think we may have seen the best of Winders, and unless he can have a decent pre-season and stay on the park and string some games together they are probably right.
Tayte Pears
Age in 2013: 23, games 2012: 10, ave disposals:12.4, tackles 2.7, marks: 2.4, goals: 0
Frustrating year for Pears who probably hasn’t come on as some would have expected. Like many others will benefit if he can remain injury free for a while and have a strong pre-season
Travis Colyer
Age in 2013: 22, games 2012: 6, ave disposals:12, tackles 2.5, marks: 2.5, goals: 0.5,
Pacey midfielder and goal sneak who needs to improve his disposal to gain a regular spot in the 22. Can be damaging in short bursts but needs to find more consistency.


Not great but not terrible - 'average' year

Angus Monfries
Age in 2013: 26, games 2012: 18, ave disposals: 15.1, tackles: 2.9, marks: 3.9, goals: 1
Medium sized forward who occasionally plays on the ball who was far from our wrost performer towards the end of the season when the team started to tail off. Good mark for his size and goal sense, but not sure how much more improvement there is in him. Good average player who had a reasonable year
Brendan Lee
Age in 2013: 26, games 2012: 2, ave disposals: 18, tackles: 4, marks: 4.5, goals: 0
Mature aged rookie listed player promoted late in the year. Grabbed his chance when he came in and showed enough to prove hes at least a depth player and if he can pick up in a couple of areas may be more than that. Definitely knows how to find the footy – needs to improve disposal
Leroy Jetta
Age in 2013: 25, games 2012: 21, ave disposals: 14.2, tackles 3.2, marks: 2.9, goals: 1
Up and down year – often looks like he’s ready to rip games apart but rarely does. Lots of ability just needs to put it all together more often and not continue to get into the habit of feigning for free kicks.
Mark Baguley
Age in 2013: 26, games 2012: 7, ave disposals: 16.1, tackles 2.1, marks: 4, goals: 0
Grabbed his chance when he came off the rookie list to play the last 7 senior games and performed admirably. May be limited in ability but attacks the ball hard and a pretty reliable back pocket type player who is likely to be given more opportunity in 2013
Corey Dell’Olio
Age in 2013: 24, games 2012: 8, ave disposals: 8.8, tackles: 2.1, marks: 2.5, goals: 1.1
Flashy type promoted from rookie list after good form at Bendigo. Did OK in his first season of AFL but needs to find the ball more often if he is to become a permanent fixture in the starting 22
David Hille
Age in 2013: 32, games 2012: 9, ave disposals: 14.1, tackles: 1.1, marks: 5.2, goals: 1, hitouts: 13
The big ruckman has lost a yard or two of pace but and was probably passed by Tom Bellchambers in 2012. Big heart but not as mobile as he once was and has looked lumbering at times during the year. Out of contract but might be given 1 more year as back up to Ryder and Bellchambers
Jackson Merrett
Age in 2013: 20, games 2012: 1, ave disposals: 3, tackles: 4, marks: 2, goals: 0
Pick 31 from 2011 draft made his debut against Collingwood in the last game of the year and did a couple of nice things. Probably a bit early to make a call on him – certainly has pace and will be given plenty of time to develop at Bendigo
Nathan Lovett-Murray
Age in 2013: 31, games 2012: 17, ave disposals: 13.9, tackles 3.1, marks: 2.7, goals: 0.5
Getting older and may have lost a yard of pace but makes up for it in aggression and has reinvented himself as a professional SUB who usually has some impact when he comes on the ground. Is tough and experienced and will be rewarded for his solid year with another contract
Rick Dyson
Age in 2013: 28, games 2012: 12, ave disposals: 19.1, tackles 2, marks: 5.4, goals: 0.2
Started the season in great form and was a regular contributor when the team was running hot in the first half of the season. Has been around a while and proved many critics wrong this year – but like many others had injury issues and tailed off towards the end of the year. Great kick and can prove a valuable asset again in 2013
Sam Lonergan
Age in 2013: 26, games 2012: 14, ave disposals: 15, tackles 5.3, marks: 2.1, goals: 0.4
Decent player probably in a similar position to Dyson whos strength is his clearance work. At his best a fantastic clearance player but struggled for consistency – particularly in the latter half of the season. Not the worst on the list and likely to be kept on.
Scott Gumbleton
Age in 2013: 25, games 2012: 6, ave disposals:9.7, tackles 1.3, marks: 4, goals: 1.8
Finally got on the park after so many years being ruined by injury. With only 27 games to his name is still learning and whilst there were some good signs we need to be patient with this big marking forward. Should beneifit from his game time this year and a big pre-season, but probably hasn’t locked in his position in the 22 just yet


Important part of the future

Alex Browne
Age in 2013: 21, games 2012:6, ave disposals: 13.7, tackles: 1.2, marks: 3.2, goals: 0.5
Came in late in the year and held his place in the side playing the last 6 games. Has aggression and goal sense, and with another pre-season under his belt should be able to cement his place in the 22 in 2013
Alwyn Davey
Age in 2013: 29, games 2012:16, ave disposals: 12.5, tackles: 4, marks: 2.1, goals: 1.8
Really bounced back from an average 2011 – has been nippy and dangerous around goal and with 29 goals is runner up to Crameri (32 goals) as the clubs leading goal kicker. Our best small forward and still out of contract but will be offered another year.
Ben Howlett
Age in 2013: 25, games 2012: 19, ave disposals: 19.7, tackles: 6.4, marks: 3.3, goals: 0.3
Had a great year and has become a key ingredient in the midfield. Tackling machine who averages just under 20 possesions a game, and if he can continue to improve in 2013 we have a pretty serious midfielder on our hands who can take some of the pressure off Jobe
Brent Stanton
Age in 2013: 27, games 2012: 20, ave disposals: 24.8, tackles: 4.3, marks: 6.4, goals: 0.6
Was in career best form early in 2012 before tailing off towards the end of the year. Can struggle when tagged but his elite running ability usually enables him to find plenty of the ball. A player who will benefit immensely if some of the younger midfield players around him can improve and take the focus of opposition tags of himself and Jobe.
Courtenay Dempsey
Age in 2013: 26, games 2012: 20, ave disposals: 18.1, tackles: 3.1, marks: 5.3, goals: 0.2
Classy half back flanker in great form early in 2012 but like many others tailed off towards the end of the year. Very creative and great to watch in full flight, and will be an important part of the Essendons plans for the next 5 years if he can keep his form going.
David Myers
Age in 2013: 24, games 2012: 9, ave disposals: 17.3, tackles: 2, marks: 3.6, goals: 0.4
Versatile and classy type who whilst injured often probably had his best year of AFL. Played much of his career in defence but showed in 2012 he can play a role in the midfield, and even up forward where his long kick can be particularly damaging. Really like him up forward/rotating through the middle and likely to be asked to play this type of role more often next year. Important player and when not injured best 22.
David Zaharakis
Age in 2013: 23, games 2012: 13, ave disposals: 22.3, tackles: 3.2, marks: 3.3, goals: 0.5
Injured for much of 2012 and whilst he showed glimpse of his best wasn’t able to put it all together for much of the season. Still remains a very important player for the bombers moving forward, and will be hoping like many others to have a strong pre-season and an injury free 2013
Dustin Fletcher
Age in 2013: 28, games 2012: 18, ave disposals: 16.1, tackles: 1.1, marks: 4.9, goals: 0.1
Evergreen defender who is still going strong and hopefully goes around for another year at least in 2013. Only remaining player from 2000 premiership team, is exceptional at reading the play and provides great leadership and guidance for our young defenders. Champion.
Dyson Heppell
Age in 2013: 21, games 2012: 20, ave disposals: 21.5, tackles: 3, marks: 5.6, goals: 0.2
Young gun who had a solid year playing in a variety of roles across the backline and through the midfield. Knows how to find the footy, is elusive and good in traffic, just needs to improve his decision making at times. Important part of the playing group moving forward who can hopefully take his game to the next level
Elliot Kavanagh
Age in 2013: 20, games 2012: 1, ave disposals: 13, tackles: 0, marks: 4, goals: 0
The number 19 draft pick from 2011 debuted in 2012 and didn’t look out of place either. Still needs time to develop but seems to have all the tools – skill, pace, endurance and can read the play. An important part of the young brigade moving forward and hopefully can string togethorsome more senior games in 2013
Heath Hocking
Age in 2013: 26, games 2012: 18, ave disposals: 15.2, tackles: 4.7, marks: 2.1, goals: 0.2
Up and down year for this tough nut. Often used in a tagging role and sacrifices his own game as a result, but probably didn’t play as well as he would have liked in 2012. Can improve in 2013
Jake Carlisle
Age in 2013: 22, games 2012: 18, ave disposals: 12.7, tackles: 2.1, marks: 4.6, goals: 0.1
Gun defender who was one of the stories of the season for the Bombers. Relishing his role down back, has great hands, and can play forward if needed. Looks set for a really bright future and probably starting centre half back in our best 22 for 2013
Jobe Watson
Age in 2013: 28, games 2012: 22, ave disposals: 29, tackles 4.8, marks: 4.8, goals: 0.9
Captain and best player who averages just under 30 possessions a game and is freakish in close and by hand. Brownlow medal favourate for most of the year, and hopefully will be rewarded for a great individual year in what was a poor year for the team. Needs more support
Kyle Hardingham
Age in 2013: 25, games 2012: 21, ave disposals: 12, tackles 1.7, marks: 3.9, goals: 0
High leaping defender with great athletic ability to jump at the last minute and mark or spoil. Decision making questionable at times, but a great asset to have down back and looks set for a bright future at the club
Michael Hibberd
Age in 2013: 23, games 2012: 13, ave disposals: 17.8, tackles 1.2, marks: 5, goals: 0.3
Tough competitor with good hands who reads the play well. Often makes searching runs from the back half – is creastive and strong. Set for a big year in 2013 and like many others will hope for better luck with injuries next year
Michael Hurley
Age in 2013: 23, games 2012: 16, ave disposals: 13.7, tackles 0.8, marks: 5.2, goals: 1.6
Brutish player who gives his all at every contest. Strong contested mark, good on the lead, can play forward where he will often get the oppositions best defender, or back, where he will take the oppositions best forward. Continuing to develop and a class player who is super importnant to the teams future prospects in 2013 and beyond
Nicholas O’Brien
Age in 2013: 20, games 2012: 2, ave disposals: 12, tackles 0, marks: 2, goals: 1.5
Probably would have debuted earlier except for injury and came in to play the last 2 games of the season with big wraps on him and didn’t let anyone down. Proved what great goal sense he has. And didn’t look out of place at all at AFL level, likely to be given more games in 2013.
Patrick Ryder
Age in 2013: 25, games 2012: 15, ave disposals: 13.6, tackles 2.5, marks: 5.9, goals: 1.1, hitouts: 21.9
Good year for Paddy who proved what a valuable player he is – weather its in the ruck or up forward. Hopefully will be able to spend more time in the forward line in 2013 with the emergence of Tom Bellchambers where his strong contested marking and long accurate kicking is a feature
Stuart Crameri
Age in 2013: 25, games 2012: 18, ave disposals:13.8, tackles 2.2, marks: 4.2, goals: 1.8
Leading goal kicker at the club with 32 majors. Was in great form early and then like many others injury slowed him down and probably didn’t get back to his very best. A very dangerous and creative forward who has pace, strength and the ability to kick goals quickly
Tom Bellchambers
Age in 2013: 24, games 2012: 16, ave disposals:11.6, tackles 1.3, marks: 4.8, goals: 0.6, hitouts: 28
Breakout year for this ruckman sometime forward who has become an important player who can damage opposition sides on the scoreboard when moving forward. Look for further imporovement in 2013
 
Good assesment .
It shows what Hird and co ignore and refuse to see.
We need ( wish list )
2 quick mids ( Boak and another ) , 1 key consistent goal kicker who marks ( Cloke ) and 1 solid defender ( Goddard )
 
Good assesment .
It shows what Hird and co ignore and refuse to see.
We need ( wish list )
2 quick mids ( Boak and another ) , 1 key consistent goal kicker who marks ( Cloke ) and 1 solid defender ( Goddard )

Thanks - hopefully we can pick up at least one quick mid between now and next year
 
Good assesment .
It shows what Hird and co ignore and refuse to see.
We need ( wish list )
2 quick mids ( Boak and another ) , 1 key consistent goal kicker who marks ( Cloke ) and 1 solid defender ( Goddard )

Hooker, Dyson, Slattery, Monfries, Davey, Gumby, #1st round pick, #2nd round pick ===> Boak, Goddard, Cloke and Caddy?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

lol ok :rolleyes:

no. of times Zaharakis was dropped = 0

I'll have to update the Zaharakis' graph of improvement since debut to see who really has Dory memories.
___

My thoughts on new moves for 2013:

Ryder: called it first a year or two ago, I'd love to see him have a go as a midfielder. He only really thrives when he's in the thick of it. He's decent below his knees and can build his tank, which is reasonable atm. Could work if Belly is to be the number one ruckmen and could go third man up against the dominant opposition ruckmen, even to read the ball in the air straight off the tap. Would be awesome to see.

Colyer: although he is pacy and core strength is good, doesn't do enough consistent damage and footskills are unreliable. I'd like to see him trialled as our next tagger to release Hocking a bit more.

Hurley: still see him as a game-breaking CHF with presence to win finals, but with a shaky future for our backline, it could be a needs-basis proposition over the next year or two, unfortunately.

Hocking: rotating midfielder released from being a tagger and moving to a forward flank as his goal sense is slightly underrated imo.
___

By the way, great write-up Bombers36
 
lol ok :rolleyes:

no. of times Zaharakis was dropped = 0

I'll have to update the Zaharakis' graph of improvement since debut to see who really has Dory memories.
___

My thoughts on new moves for 2013:

Ryder: called it first a year or two ago, I'd love to see him have a go as a midfielder. He only really thrives when he's in the thick of it. He's decent below his knees and can build his tank, which is reasonable atm. Could work if Belly is to be the number one ruckmen and could go third man up against the dominant opposition ruckmen, even to read the ball in the air straight off the tap. Would be awesome to see.

Colyer: although he is pacy and core strength is good, doesn't do enough consistent damage and footskills are unreliable. I'd like to see him trialled as our next tagger to release Hocking a bit more.

Hurley: still see him as a game-breaking CHF with presence to win finals, but with a shaky future for our backline, it could be a needs-basis proposition over the next year or two, unfortunately.

Hocking: rotating midfielder released from being a tagger and moving to a forward flank as his goal sense is slightly underrated imo.
___

By the way, great write-up Bombers36

Thanks Mumbo Jumbo :)
 
Not sure you can call Jackson Merret in the first group when he is a first year draftee who was always drafted as a 2 - 3 year proposition.

You would have thought that Rick Dyson had a good year, might not be in the future, but he was far from our worst and would not surprise me to see me to see him inside the top 10 for the Chricton in the first dozen games or so, prior to injury.
 
Not sure you can call Jackson Merret in the first group when he is a first year draftee who was always drafted as a 2 - 3 year proposition.

You would have thought that Rick Dyson had a good year, might not be in the future, but he was far from our worst and would not surprise me to see me to see him inside the top 10 for the Chricton in the first dozen games or so, prior to injury.

Hi Yoda
On Merrett I said its a bit early to make a call on him
Agree Dyson was in great form early in the year, but hes has also been at the club 10 years next year and hasnt really set the world on fire - lets be honest. Love to be proven wrong but i still dont see him as an integral part of our future
 
Hi Yoda
On Merrett I said its a bit early to make a call on him
Agree Dyson was in great form early in the year, but hes has also been at the club 10 years next year and hasnt really set the world on fire - lets be honest. Love to be proven wrong but i still dont see him as an integral part of our future

Dont get me wrong the tough calls will be made, and I really bloody hope so, Dyson was (in my books) considered best 22 from his early season form. The fact that we are increasingly likely to lose Henry Slattery, Mark Baguley could be borderline delisted, the injury concerns with David Myers & (up to this year) Courtenay Dempsey, add to that Heppe,l is going to be transformed into a midfielder and Michael Ross is still developing and there is some Long bloke who was suppose to be a back flanker/defender who has not been sighted in 4 years at the club.

I think there is a case for a year by year proposition for Ricky D, I agree, I dont see him as a premiership defender, but in terms of depth, yeah, he could be a handy depth player. Never a star, but someone who can come in and play a role.
 
Hardie arguably doesn't deserve his ranking, Hocking definitely doesn't (is anyone more confident in him now than this time last year?), Lonergan doesn't, and there should be a category for 'serious questions' as well.

Having Melksham in the same category as McVeigh/Reimers is incredibly harsh - having him behind/below guys like Lonergan/Hocking is flat-out wrong.
Melksham fits into average. Decent early, poor late - but keep in mind he was one of only a very few who fronted up in arse-about sides getting thumped every week - not easy conditions and plenty of the others were just as bad but get forgotten because they were dropped & he wasn't.

I was a lot less bullish on him early days than a lot of you lot, and now I'm a lot less critical than most. Suspect criticism is as much to do with him being tipped by all & sundry as "THE BIG IMPROVER (TM)", as much as anything.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Hardie arguably doesn't deserve his ranking, Hocking definitely doesn't (is anyone more confident in him now than this time last year?), Lonergan doesn't, and there should be a category for 'serious questions' as well.

Having Melksham in the same category as McVeigh/Reimers is incredibly harsh - having him behind/below guys like Lonergan/Hocking is flat-out wrong.
Melksham fits into average. Decent early, poor late - but keep in mind he was one of only a very few who fronted up in arse-about sides getting thumped every week - not easy conditions and plenty of the others were just as bad but get forgotten because they were dropped & he wasn't.

I was a lot less bullish on him early days than a lot of you lot, and now I'm a lot less critical than most. Suspect criticism is as much to do with him being tipped by all & sundry as "THE BIG IMPROVER (TM)", as much as anything.

might be right there slatts... he may just be a victim of everyones high expectations.. if his season was looked at as just a 3rd year players year.. it wasnt SO bad...
 
I’ve had a crack... don’t mean to hijack thread but didn’t think it worth starting another. Praise/criticism/abuse welcome. There’s quite a few I really mulled over. In rating seasons, I’ve tried to do it purely on output, not taking into account injuries etc – so many guys have lower rating through no fault of their own.. it’s based on output, not effort.

I think our list does need some decent work... imo we shouldn’t fool ourselves that it doesn’t, and think that 2012 was purely injuries (although they obviously had a big impact). 6 – 8 senior list changes for mine – a big draft, hopefully a trade or two, and a couple of rookie upgrades.

2 Dyson: Looked pretty good early on... but was dropped, and still unable to cement his spot in the best 22 at 27yo and in his 9th season at the club. Out of contract and I think out of time. 5/10. Trade / Delist.

3 Gumbleton: Yet another year ruined by injury... I don’t even want to know what this bloke did to cop his karma. Having said that, six senior games was a relatively good return for where he was and his history, and I still think he shows far more than most other 20-odd game key forwards. Gets a one year deal and hopefully we can re-assess after an injury-free year. 5/10. Retain.

4 Watson: not much needs to be said... took his game to yet another level in 2012, and I reckon his leadership as well. Continues to grow into the Essendon champion we all hoped he’d be the day he walked into the club. Hopefully a Brownlow. 10/10. Retain.

5 Stanton: another mid who took his game to another level. Did drop off a bit in the second half, but was hardly alone there. His gut-running is invaluable and a great example to the younger midfielders. Finally started to win some respect from the wider footy world. 8/10. Retain.

6 Monfries: Another “meh” year for mine. He does good things at times, and can bob up with a goal or two... but doesn’t seem to do so when we really need it. Simply doesn’t do enough imo – and at 25yo and 150 games, it’s time he did. I’d put him on the trade table. If a reasonable offer is not forthcoming, he gets another year – and a massive pre-season with the midfield group, which is where I want to see him. 5/10. Trade / Retain.

7 Jetta: OK year. Gets a lot of heat for inconsistency, which in fairness is levelled at a lot of players in his role. My main beef with him is I believe he was drafted as a quick midfielder/wingman, and I don’t think we’ve ever really seen him in that role. Like Monfries, I’d like to see him build his tank and be a potential midfield option. Will not have a long-term AFL career doing what he’s doing now imo. 5/5. Retain.

8 Winderlich: Year ruined by injury. Showed some great glimpses as a forward in the little we saw of him, especially for somebody coming off a LTI. Pray for an injury free 2013. 3/10 (through no fault of his own). Retain.

9 Prismall: Zero games due to injury. I’d give him another year in the hope he can get back to some of his solid Geelong form. N/A. Retain.

10 McVeigh: Another year cruelled by injury. Has retired, 232 games a great effort. All the best. 2/10. Delist.

11 Zaharakis: Didn’t reach the heights of last year, due mainly to injury (hmm, a theme developing here). Another big pre-season for him, an injury free year, and I think we’ll have a super inside/outside mid on our hands. 6/10. Retain.

12 Crameri: Easy to forget how inexperienced he is, just his second real season at senior level. Has the lot – good hands, brute strength, a good leap and deceiving pace. Positive was he seemed to recover from the shoulder injury that ended his 2011 season, one of our few good new stories re injures. Continued improvement and maybe even the third defender in 2013. 7/10. Retain.

14 Lonergan: Mixed feelings here. I don’t mind the way he plays, but really doesn’t do enough imo. I really can’t see him getting much better and with 80 games to his name, I think we’ve seen enough to make a judgement. 4/10. Trade / Delist.

15 Dempsey: Teased with his best and really showed what he is capable of. Inconsistent but I think it’s easy to forget he was coming off a knee reco – in that sense had a very good year imo. Really excited about what he’ll produce next year. 6/10. Retain.

16 Pears: A more frustrating case does not come easily to mind. I was definitely one who, a few years ago, had him as one of the premier key backs in the land by this stage. Injuries have hurt, but also seems to have lost all feel and confidence. Unlike some, I would definitely not entertain trading him –we all know what he can do, and at 22yo, he can surely get it back. Hopefully a good, injury-free preseason for him. But I’d also be scheduling him in for some extended one-on-one work with a former gun key backman who knows a thing or two about communication and teaching. Anything to help him out. 3/10. Retain.

17 Melksham: I’m one of the many who is just gobsmacked at how this bloke played 22 games. At various times looked lost, disinterested, uncaring, frustrated, redundant, and just downright average. Showed very few glimpses, hopefully this year is the exception and not the rule. Positive? An Essendon player who didn’t get injured, which is a miracle in itself. 3/10. Retain.

18 Hurley: I didn’t mind his year, but never really seemed able to string consecutive solid games together and get a good run at it. I still like him as forward, but am swayed just a little bit more every time he’s sent down back – definitely looks like he knows what he’s doing back there. Suspect his future hinges on the development of Crameri, Gumbleton, and possibly Daniher. A couple of them really come on, and I think he’ll be left down back. Otherwise he’ll be needed up forward. 6/10. Retain.

19 Hille: I thought he started the year off well, but hit a horrible run of in the second half of the year, when he looked, frankly, too old and too slow. Should he feel he’s up to it, I would actually retain him in 2013 given our ruck situation – however he won’t play seniors unless injury demands it. If he’s not up for that, then it may be curtains for a solid servant. 4/10. Retain.

20 Slattery: I think 2 senior games in his eighth year at the club says it all. Not part of our plans. 1/10. Trade / Delist.

21 Heppell: I didn’t mind his year... second year blues are common and whilst he may have dropped off a little, it was hardly dramatic. Pleasingly, another of the few who managed to escape injuries of note. Another I want to see building his tank, and becoming a full-time midfielder over the next couple of years. 6/10. Retain.

22 Carlisle: Loved his season, I wasn’t convinced he was a defender but it looks to have worked well. One of our success stories this year I think. Just looks solid. 7/10. Retain.

23 Myers: Just another one ruined by injury. And another one I want to see as a full time midfielder (two definite themes here). I really like the ways he plays– he’s pretty hard at it imo and just love his massive left hoof. Feels like he’s older – still 23yo and only 45 games to his name. Hopefully gets a good run at it. 4/10. Retain.

24 Browne: I liked what I saw – I think he uses the ball pretty well. Hopefully pushes for more senior games next year... but I kinda feel so far, so good. 3/10. Retain.

25 Steinberg: I know he has some fans, but I don’t watch much Bendigo so won’t pretend I know much. Contracted for next year. N/A. Retain.

26 Hooker: Much underrated imo. His ungainly style attracts critics and makes experts of everybody - people jump all over any obvious mistakes he makes. But I do feel his good work goes noticed and he did some very good jobs this year. I think he’s a bit like Schoenmakers, nobody says a word when he does well, but they jump all over him when he doesn’t. I was disappointed when he was reportedly put up for trade this year, and would be again – Pears is an unknown quantity, and Hooker has been far more reliable and consistent. He’s in our best 22 as a key back at the moment, and goes nowhere in my book. 7/10. Retain.

27 Davis: Another one I won’t judge based on seeing very little. Contracted for 2013. N/A. Retain.

28 Kavanagh: We’ve seen very little – first round pick last year, midfielder, obviously going nowhere. Hopefully he can put on a bit of size. 3/10. Retain.

29 Davey: Here is a tough one... I had written the man off after last year. His major (and perhaps only) weapon – blistering pace – was largely gone, and he looked lost. I thought he started the year very well... he somehow looked a smarter player who was able to out-think opponents and contribute without the pace. He dropped off a bit, but 29 goals from 17 games was a good return. Having said that... at his age... slowing down... out of contract... I simply don’t think he’s part of our future. Thanks for the memories Froggy, superb to watch in his prime. 5/10. Trade / Delist.

30 Ryder: Paddy, Paddy, Paddy. The first few rounds... I saw it. The promised land. Dominating the ruck, with Hille in tow simply pinch hitting. This is it, I said. It’s here. Patrick Ryder the dominant, All Australian ruckman. As usual (aside from injury), I feel the drop-off in his season correlated directly with the amount of time spent in the ruck. Then injury hit, and that was it. Liked his year, especially the start... but like many others, I just cannot stress this to the coaching team enough: Paddy. Ryder. Is. A. Ruckman. That is all. Extended periods anywhere but the ruck equal unfulfilled talent... please don’t let it happen long term. 7/10. Retain.

31 Fletcher: nothing needs to be said – continues to defy age, accepted wisdom, and plain logic. Brilliant and hasn’t dropped a notch. Hope he plays another 5 years. 8/10. Retain.

32 Colyer: I’m really not sure about him. Adds a bit of spark when he comes in, but does he get enough of it? Is his disposal good enough? Contracted for next year and happy to adopt the wait’n’see. 4/10. Retain.

33 Merrett: saw him once. Play on. 3/10. Retain.

34 Hardingham: Bit of an enigma imo. Seems to attract his share of criticism, in that sense I think he’s bit like Hooker – he’s prone to making a howler that sticks in your craw – a very poor, goal-costing disposal... or leaving his man to fly for a ball which he misses... my biggest question is I’m not convinced of what he is... is he really a defender? I don’t really see him as the lockdown type. And I wasn’t really convinced of him as a forward when he started, either. Here’s a thought... midfield? Could he develop a tank? Forget he’s only 186cm. Food for thought, but I’d see how he goes. 5/10. Retain.

35 O’Brien: only got a brief-ish glimpse, but he seemed comfortable enough, and maybe knows where the goals are. One I hope becomes a midfielder, and not another nondescript flanker type. 4/10. Retain.

37 Reimers: I don’t have much to say, I think the coaches have said it all with selection. 3/10. Trade / Delist.

38 Ross: Really haven’t seen enough to comment. N/A. Retain.

39 Hocking: Unspectacular, but gets the job done. An automatic selection, best 22 and our designated stopper. However, would like to see him do a little more the other way in a more consistent manner, he shows some great inside work at times. 6/10. Retain.

40 Howlett: Love how he always punches above his weight... or tries too at least! I love his attack on the ball and the man, but he will be 24 next year, and hopefully he steps it up. 6/10. Retain.

42 Lovett-Murray: I’m a fan of the bloke, so it’s a tough one. Still doesn’t have the tank to run consistently through the middle and although he has that great ability to have a physical impact, I feel amongst us Essendon people his reputation for that may now outweigh the actual – he really isn’t having a noticeable physical impact a lot of the time. Out of contract and turning 30 soon... the only thing I can see saving him is leadership. 4/10. Delist.

43 Hibberd: Ruined by multiple tissue injuries, but I really like him when he’s out there. I think his disposal is reasonable, he can play a lock-down role, and he’s tough as nails. A great pick-up who I think and hope will kick right on. 5/10. Retain.

44 Bellchambers: Super development and probably our biggest success this year: With Ryder doing his thing early, and Hille playing a role, I had TBC down for a year of fill-in and development. But when he got his chance, **** me, didn’t he grab it and choke the life out of it. He’s now an extremely valuable commodity: a 23yo, genuine, no.1 AFL ruckman. It is however, for this reason... that I’d look at trading him. Only if the right deal came up – that being gun midfielder/s, potential gun midfielder/s, or a very high draft pick. As good as Bellchambers is and will be, I think the presence of Ryder actually makes him just about the most tradeable bloke on our list – he’s certainly valuable, he’d attract interest, and imo, both him and Ryder are pure ruckmen who offer little more than pinch-hitting ability in other positions. I think playing both can be to the detriment of the team, particular should the interchange/substitute move from 3/1 to 2/2. Obviously it’d have to be a bloody good deal which reflects TBC’s worth, otherwise I’d be hanging onto him. But I just don’t think Ryder and Bellchambers works, and you have to give something to get something at the trade table. 7/10. Trade / Retain.

46 Baguley: I think we saw enough to give him more time. Age is not hugely on his side, but seemed solid enough off half-back. 4/10. Retain.

47 Dell’Olio: I wasn’t hugely excited, but he retained a spot and seemed to adapt to league footy ok. I’d give him another year. 4/10. Retain.

I won’t do the rest of the rookies, I didn’t see enough of Bendigo.
 
Nice write ups.

My ratings out of 10 without comments based on what they did at AFL level this year:

Dyson: 4
Gumbleton: 3
Watson: 10
Stanton: 6.5
Monfries: 4.5
Jetta: 5
Winderlich: 2.5
Prismall: 0
McVeigh: 1
Zaharakis: 5.5
Crameri: 6
Lonergan: 4
Dempsey: 6
Pears: 2.5
Melksham: 3.5
Hurley: 6
Hille: 4.5
Slattery: 1
Heppell: 6
Carlisle: 7
Myers: 4
Browne: 4
Steinberg: 0
Hooker: 6
Davis: 0
Kavanagh: 1
Davey: 6
Ryder: 6.5
Fletcher: 8
Colyer: 3
Merrett: 1
Hardingham: 6
O’Brien: 4
Reimers: 2
Ross: 0
Hocking: 4
Howlett: 8
Lovett-Murray: 4
Hibberd: 5
Bellchambers: 7
Baguley:4
Dell’Olio: 3
 
I could easily slip Jetta into the trade category there... just not enough output! Your comments on him were correct but every year its the same old story.. building a tank, will play midfield.... does not happen, probably wont happen. Downhill skier. Trade while still has value.

But if we look at our zippy small types..... how many can we really shed to try again?

We have.. Jetta, Davey, Colyer, Riemers, Dell Olio.

There have been calls for alot of different combinations of these guys to get the chop. All have been mentioned. You are keen to chop/trade Davey and Reimers.

I'd happily trade/chop Reimers, Jetta and Dell'olio. Colyer lucky but has something to give, needs to work on dispsal. Davey has more to give on a short deal, Dell'olio didnt seem up to standard.. i'd keep on the rookie list if possible, not sure if he is worth a list spot as yet.

Is it time to spend a proper pick on a dedicated small forward finally?
 
Hocking's year is being massively, massively over-rated. IMHO.
Half way through last year he was probably in our best 2-3 midfielders - covering ground well, kicking goals, monstering the inside contest - fast forward 18 months, where is he at? Was he in the bests more than 2 or 3 times all year? Did he really stop anyone, bar a flagging Chris Judd?

Statistically, his worst year since 2008.
Clearly passed by Howlett & Myers.

If his year's a 6/10, we're well ****ed.
I'd give him a 3/10.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Hocking's year is being massively, massively over-rated. IMHO.
Half way through last year he was probably in our best 2-3 midfielders - covering ground well, kicking goals, monstering the inside contest - fast forward 18 months, where is he at? Was he in the bests more than 2 or 3 times all year? Did he really stop anyone, bar a flagging Chris Judd?

Statistically, his worst year since 2008.
Clearly passed by Howlett & Myers.

If his year's a 6/10, we're well screwed.
I'd give him a 3/10.
I agree. I gave him 4 out of 10 basically because he managed to play 18 games.

Started slow and never really got going.

He is someone who in the off season will need to work on his endurance. Seems to have totally lost the ability to sprint multiple times in a game.
 
Hocking's year is being massively, massively over-rated. IMHO.
Half way through last year he was probably in our best 2-3 midfielders - covering ground well, kicking goals, monstering the inside contest - fast forward 18 months, where is he at? Was he in the bests more than 2 or 3 times all year? Did he really stop anyone, bar a flagging Chris Judd?

Statistically, his worst year since 2008.
Clearly passed by Howlett & Myers.

If his year's a 6/10, we're well screwed.
I'd give him a 3/10.

Absolutely.

I'm going to keep going in to bat for Dyson as well. Not sure what else he could have done, quite a few thought he was stiff to get dropped, and the only real stinker I can recall him playing was the Melbourne game, in which everyone bar Zaharakis, Watson, and Carlisle stunk as well.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

2012 Player Review

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top