List Mgmt. 2013 Trade / Draft / Free Agency

[stkildathunda]

How do you go about getting a rookie from another club? Is it just a trade like normal?

Yep via trade but you have to promote them to your senior list.

 

[Smoke_Me_AKipper]

w
You know what Sheeza, I agree with you. A good trade for Adams, poach Brown thru the PSD, trade for another tall KPD (Griffiths, Keefe, Frost etc), maybe a free agent mid. Take Boyd/Crouch/Dunstan. We really need to further fix the holes in the list with 23-27 year olds. It will give the 17-21 year olds a much more stable base to come thru on

+1 on the proviso we keep our 1st pick for Boyd/Crouch/Dunstan/Aish etc

 

[Barrels]

w
You know what Sheeza, I agree with you. A good trade for Adams, poach Brown thru the PSD, trade for another tall KPD (Griffiths, Keefe, Frost etc), maybe a free agent mid. Take Boyd/Crouch/Dunstan. We really need to further fix the holes in the list with 23-27 year olds. It will give the 17-21 year olds a much more stable base to come thru on

Pretty bloody hard to see that happening, but Jesus what a boost that would give us... Lets say (we can hope) we get Boyd, Keeffe, Brown and Adams as of next year, and (sadly) lose Hayes, Milne, Koschitzke, Fisher and Blake; with age, height and weight in brackets:

FB: Wright (20, 185, 77) // Brown (25, 196, 95) // Simpkin (24, 191, 92)
HB: Roberton (23, 194, 88) // Keeffe (24, 204, 102) // Dempster (30, 191, 87)
CR: Montagna (30, 178, 78) // Armitage (26, 183, 87) // Geary (26, 183, 82)
HF: Siposs (22, 190, 90) // Riewoldt (31, 193, 96) // Saunders (20, 180, 78)
FF: Saad (24, 175, 78) // Boyd (18, 199, 102) // Stanley (23, 200, 96)
RK: Hickey (23, 201, 94) // Steven (24, 180, 79) // Adams (20, 179, 84)
Int: Webster (21, 188, 78) // Dal Santo (30, 185, 85) // Newnes (21, 184, 81) // Ross (21, 187, 86)
Em: Murdoch (20, 188, 80) // Saunders (20, 180, 78) // McEvoy (25, 200, 103) // Gilbert (24, 194, 92)

Ave age: 23.6
Ave ht: 188.7cm
Ave wgt: 87.2kg

Mmmmmmm... Exciting.

 

[hayes]

All the more reason to throw up a few of our million half backs. We need at least two key defenders this offseason which doesn't leave much room for all of Fisher, Gwilt, Roberton, Dempster, Gilbert, Wright, Stanley if he goes back. Throw in Dunell as well.

 

[Falchoon]

Brown subbed, certainly no their worst

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

Brown subbed, certainly no their worst

Injured.

 

[saintsrfreak]

Maybe Daniel Jackson actually would've been a decent pick up...

 

[Sheeza69]

+1 on the proviso we keep our 1st pick for Boyd/Crouch/Dunstan/Aish etc

Is it asking too much for GWS to accept Gwilt or Gilbert, & our second rd pick (21/22) for Adams..

 

[Half Back Pocket]

All the more reason to throw up a few of our million half backs. We need at least two key defenders this offseason which doesn't leave much room for all of Fisher, Gwilt, Roberton, Dempster, Gilbert, Wright, Stanley if he goes back. Throw in Dunell as well.

It we add Brown + Keefe/Griffiths etc, Stan could move forward and play the forward/ruck role and we could add another midfielder...instead of playing 2 rucks who can't go forward.

Imagine Fish marshaling Brown, Keefe, Roberton, Dempster, Wright and Gears!

 

[Half Back Pocket]

Is it asking too much for GWS to accept Gwilt or Gilbert, & our second rd pick (21/22) for Adams..

Depends on the go-home factor. If its strong, and he's gonna walk into the PSD, they'll trade him for a deal like that...having said that, I don't think Gwilt would get it done. Simpkin? Armo?

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

Nathan Brown > Lachlan Keefe

 

[Smoke_Me_AKipper]

Is it asking too much for GWS to accept Gwilt or Gilbert, & our second rd pick (21/22) for Adams..

Haha it could be a win/win!! Would love to get Adams here as well as say a Dunstan (assuming Boyd is gone). Don't know if the current players mentioned would go for it though....

 

[Strahany]

Can't see us getting Adams and then drafting Dunstan. Given the type of player that Adams is, a Kelly or a Billings would be a much better pick to complement him.

 

[Strahany]

Yep via trade but you have to promote them to your senior list.

Sounds easy enough, but, needless to say, if this kid on Collingwood's rookie list is any good, he surely would have been at least tried by now. It's not like he's a raw, stick thin kid like Lever. Sure, Collingwood have a dearth of KPD's, but that would only count for so much.

 

[Strahany]

Is it asking too much for GWS to accept Gwilt or Gilbert, & our second rd pick (21/22) for Adams..

Looking at GWS' list deficiencies, I'd say that Gilbert alone could well net us Adams, assuming that Sam has a decent patch of games after his return from injury.

 

[Barrels]

Nathan Brown > Lachlan Keefe

Also WAY less likely in terms of Collingfilth trading him.

 

[Barrels]

Sounds easy enough, but, needless to say, if this kid on Collingwood's rookie list is any good, he surely would have been at least tried by now. It's not like he's a raw, stick thin kid like Lever. Sure, Collingwood have a dearth of KPD's, but that would only count for so much.

Do you mean glut? If it was a dearth of them he'd have no chance.

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

Also WAY less likely in terms of Collingfilth trading him.

Out of contract so if he asks for a trade they will have too or he just walks.

 

[Barrels]

Out of contract so if he asks for a trade they will have too or he just walks.

**** it then, lets get BOTH Browns and re-create the double Wakelin backline. Nathan at FB and Mitch at CHB. Done and done.

 

[Sheeza69]

Gilbert & Gwilt would be a worth a pick around 25-30..Maybe throw in a third rd pick ( 40- 42), especially if Adams walks into the PSD & GWS risk losing him for nothing..

But a talent like Adams won't come that cheap i reckon, every Victorian club will be chasing him..
Don't be surprised if Adams is part of the Franklin trade..??

 

[Tragic sainter]

Gilbert & Gwilt would be a worth a pick around 25-30..Maybe throw in a third rd pick ( 40- 42), especially if Adams walks into the PSD & GWS risk losing him for nothing..

But a talent like Adams won't come that cheap i reckon, every Victorian club will be chasing him..
Don't be surprised if Adams is part of the Franklin trade..??

I would be surprised. Isn't franklin a restricted free agent?

 

[God Save Max King]

Prestia has just re-signed with the Suns. Strike him off the list.

 

[GrandBlue]

Hypothetically, if your club was chasing Adams, letting him go into the PSD would be a bad idea. Melbourne will unfortunately be all over him.

 

[Defacto]

Gilbert & Gwilt would be a worth a pick around 25-30..Maybe throw in a third rd pick ( 40- 42), especially if Adams walks into the PSD & GWS risk losing him for nothing..

But a talent like Adams won't come that cheap i reckon, every Victorian club will be chasing him..
Don't be surprised if Adams is part of the Franklin trade..??

isnt frankalin a free agent and therefore a trade isnt required?

 

[Defacto]

Mark Hutchins would be handy to still have on our list right about now! He's turned into very handy player!

i'm yet to be convinced. maybe good for depth but hardly someone i would want in my best 22