2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[Jiska]

Parker + 65k + improvement, or Jelwood?

 

[cdcanman]

Parker + 65k + improvement, or Jelwood?

Pondering this exact dilemma myself. The extra cash would be handy, but adding another rd12 bye as opposed to Selwood's Rd13 has me leaning his way.

 

[cdcanman]

Cotchin vs Goddard vs Wines vs Griffen vs Steven + cash
Filling M5 for those playing at home
I'm not favouring any one over the other at this stage, hence the 5 possibilities

 

[Jiska]

Cotchin vs Goddard vs Wines vs Griffen vs Steven + cash
Filling M5 for those playing at home
I'm not favouring any one over the other at this stage, hence the 5 possibilities

Goddard for mine. Had an injury game of 11 killing his average and is good value.

Wines next, then daylight.

 

[cdcanman]

Let me put my conundrum another way.
Selwood, Cotchin/Wines/Griffen, Roberton
vs
Parker, Steven, Hodge
???

 

[Jiska]

Let me put my conundrum another way.
Selwood, Cotchin/Wines/Griffen, Roberton
vs
Parker, Steven, Hodge
???

Jelwood, Wines, Roberton when put that way.

 

[MightyMark]

Let me put my conundrum another way.
Selwood, Cotchin/Wines/Griffen, Roberton
vs
Parker, Steven, Hodge
???

If Roberton shows enough in the NAB and comes out unscathed option 1 would be a go. Although the potential of the second option is very appealing.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Similar to the above but I'm just looking at: Wines vs. Griffen ?

Also, Neale vs. Steven ? Steven had 1 good year but I reckon Neale prime possy for a breakout finished the year strong.

 

[MightyMark]

Similar to the above but I'm just looking at: Wines vs. Griffen ?

Also, Neale vs. Steven ? Steven had 1 good year but I reckon Neale prime possy for a breakout finished the year strong.

Wines is probably a safer bet, but Griffen will have a higher ceiling if he gets going. Depends on whether or not your willing to take a punt with this selection.

Steven was under done last year coming back from a broken leg he looked hesitant. If he gets a good run, he should be able to replicate his best again. Neale will struggle to match Steven if Steven gets going, and even if he doesn't reach his best he should still be able to match Neale.

 

[Jiska]

Wines vs Jelwood
Parker vs Rocky (overpriced?)

 

[MightyMark]

Wines vs Jelwood
Parker vs Rocky (overpriced?)

Selwood and Parker

 

[Jiska]

Selwood and Parker

How about Wines vs Parker?

 

[Kadog]

Let me put my conundrum another way.
Selwood, Cotchin/Wines/Griffen, Roberton
vs
Parker, Steven, Hodge
???

Both great choices. I'd go Selwood/Griffen/Roberton

Similar to the above but I'm just looking at: Wines vs. Griffen ?

Also, Neale vs. Steven ? Steven had 1 good year but I reckon Neale prime possy for a breakout finished the year strong.

Griffendorf & Steven

Wines vs Jelwood
Parker vs Rocky (overpriced?)

Jelwood & Parker (only because Rocks overpriced)

With Hanley injured how does this affect Rocky or Beams in terms of a hard tag?

 

[MightyMark]

How about Wines vs Parker?

I can give you my opinion or tell you what you want to hear, cant do both

 

[Jiska]

I can give you my opinion or tell you what you want to hear, cant do both

lol. Parker has been in my team since my first team in mid December. Just second guessing myself

 

[MightyMark]

lol. Parker has been in my team since my first team in mid December. Just second guessing myself

I actually dont have him at the moment, but one of about 5 players vying for M4 in my team. My only concern is the amount of points that will be shared between Sydney's mids.

 

[Jiska]

I actually dont have him at the moment, but one of about 5 players vying for M4 in my team. My only concern is the amount of points that will be shared between Sydney's mids.

Not sure that's an issue. McVeigh has gone now too. Collingwood spent years sharing points and didn't stop Pendles, Beames, Sidebottom and Swan scoring well. Parker was 8th overall last year and he's still a kid that's learning. Can't see him going backwards.

 

[GOAUS!]

Thinking of ditching Watson for Wines for M5, especially with the Rd 12 byes situation.

 

[go you pups]

Cotchin vs Goddard vs Wines vs Griffen vs Steven + cash
Filling M5 for those playing at home
I'm not favouring any one over the other at this stage, hence the 5 possibilities

Vs Andrew Swallow

 

[Kadog]

Sloane v Dangerfield

 

[go you pups]

Similar to the above but I'm just looking at: Wines vs. Griffen ?

Also, Neale vs. Steven ? Steven had 1 good year but I reckon Neale prime possy for a breakout finished the year strong.

I like the Neale pick also, will have Fyfe, Mundy and Barlow copping attention so he's every chance to build on that 87 point average, I like his scope of improvement too, he's raised his game every year and Ross seems to like him.

 

[GOAUS!]

Sloane v Dangerfield

I like Sloane, the questions will start to be asked of Danger, will he rise like Ablett or sink like Cloke? Also how will the coach respond if he thinks Danger is leaving?

 

[I am Jack]

Thinking of ditching Watson for Wines for M5, especially with the Rd 12 byes situation.

I just think Wines is the next Luke Parker.
I've slid them both in. Wines, Parker, Fyfe, blokes who can find that pill - and tackle.

 

[TN25]

Sloane v Dangerfield

Sloane

 

[TN25]

Burgoyne v Hibberd v Hodge v Jaensch