2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[Flandersss]

May have already been asked, but I haven't read the thread. Wines vs B Crouch?

Would have both of them if I could. Crouch had a strong finish after coming back late last year and by all reports is firing in the preseason (which he didn't have at all last year_)

Ollie by the length of the Flemington straight!

 

[MightyMark]

Goldstein Beams KK vs
Minson Parker Shaw/Hibberd

Minson, Parker and Shaw

 

[SnappyHappy]

Gray v Parker v Lewis

 

[MightyMark]

Gray v Parker v Lewis

Parker

Lewis and Gray maxed out last year, and whilst im dubious on how how will go, of the 3 he has the best chance to increase his average.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Burger and $288k or Goldy and $77k.

 

[jaguaress]

J. Watson or D. Heppell for my midfield please

 

[Kadog]

J. Watson or D. Heppell for my midfield please

Watson daylight Heppell

 

[toxic]

J. Watson or D. Heppell for my midfield please

Watson, agree with Kadog

 

[MightyMark]

Burger and $288k or Goldy and $77k.

Depends on who your other ruck is. If you other ruck is solid, take the risk with Berger. If your running with Kruze or another risky choice already take Goldy.

J. Watson or D. Heppell for my midfield please

Gotta disagree with the others, I reckon Heppell will have a better year SC wise than Watson.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Depends on who your other ruck is. If you other ruck is solid, take the risk with Berger. If your running with Kruze or another risky choice already take Goldy.



Gotta disagree with the others, I reckon Heppell will have a better year SC wise than Watson.

Other ruck is Nic Nat, risky-ish. Is Luey still #1 ruck?

 

[MightyMark]

Other ruck is Nic Nat, risky-ish. Is Luey still #1 ruck?

NicNat is a solid choice, one injured year has cast a lot of doubt over him. But its the first full preseason he has had, will play even more in the ruck, and this is coming from a guy who managed 114ppg when he was 22 AS A RUCK! Lock him in.

Kruze is a better choice atm than Berger for me. Still dubious about whether he will get stuck forward, it would be a huge waste. And it remains to be seen how Berger will go with Martin. Berger will be number one ruck as Martin is more versatile in other roles, but doubtfull Berger will get as much time in the middle, as Martin would be given a fair run there as well.

 

[cdcanman]

NicNat is a solid choice, one injured year has cast a lot of doubt over him. But its the first full preseason he has had, will play even more in the ruck, and this is coming from a guy who managed 114ppg when he was 22 AS A RUCK! Lock him in.

Kruze is a better choice atm than Berger for me. Still dubious about whether he will get stuck forward, it would be a huge waste. And it remains to be seen how Berger will go with Martin. Berger will be number one ruck as Martin is more versatile in other roles, but doubtfull Berger will get as much time in the middle, as Martin would be given a fair run there as well.

Pretty good assessment of both Leuenberger and Kreuzer.
Not much more I can add about Leuey.
With Kreuzer, as much as Carlton have been talking about him spending more time forward, I just can't see him being anything other than their no.1 ruckman. Warnock? Wood? Give me a spell. I'd say he will be their sole ruckman as well. Supported by Casboult and Jones.
Completely agree, Kreuzer the better prospect at this stage.

 

[jaguaress]

Watson daylight Heppell

Watson, agree with Kadog

Gotta disagree with the others, I reckon Heppell will have a better year SC wise than Watson.

Thanks gentlemen

 

[RobZombie]

Burger and $288k or Goldy and $77k.

Goldy. But actually NicNat with Goldy as upgrade target.

2 of Deledio/Dusty/Gray?

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Goldy. But actually NicNat with Goldy as upgrade target.

2 of Deledio/Dusty/Gray?

I think Grey is overpriced, I've got Dusty at this stage hoping he will see more midfield time. So both them yellow and black, but we are lucky to have so many fwd line options this season you could go a number of different ways.

 

[MightyMark]

Goldy. But actually NicNat with Goldy as upgrade target.

2 of Deledio/Dusty/Gray?

Martin at this stage. Hard to ignore the talk coming out of Richmond, but NAB cup will give you the best idea between Deledio and Martin.

Agree OhhhhhCyril, Gray maxed out at the moment.

Pretty good assessment of both Leuenberger and Kreuzer.
Not much more I can add about Leuey.
With Kreuzer, as much as Carlton have been talking about him spending more time forward, I just can't see him being anything other than their no.1 ruckman. Warnock? Wood? Give me a spell. I'd say he will be their sole ruckman as well. Supported by Casboult and Jones.
Completely agree, Kreuzer the better prospect at this stage.

Carlton would be crazy not to have Kruze at ruck. I understand the merit behind the thinking, but what a waste of talent it would be. He will never be a solid KPF.

 

[SickQwon]

Sam Docherty (412K) OR Andrew Walker (472K)?

Docherty had a great first year at Carlton and expect him to improve.
Walker announced he was carrying an injury through 2014 and is a proven high SC scorer in the past.

 

[RobZombie]

Sam Docherty (412K) OR Andrew Walker (472K)?

Docherty had a great first year at Carlton and expect him to improve.
Walker announced he was carrying an injury through 2014 and is a proven high SC scorer in the past.

Docherty easily for me. Too much uncertainty re walker's role.

 

[MightyMark]

Docherty easily for me. Too much uncertainty re walker's role.

That being said though, if Walker does end up playing off HB, he will be in my side in a heart beat.

 

[karaoke]

That being said though, if Walker does end up playing off HB, he will be in my side in a heart beat.

Still got a knee worry doesn't he?

 

[MightyMark]

Still got a knee worry doesn't he?

I did read that somewhere, but I dont know the extent.

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Buddy vs Dusty

 

[MightyMark]

Buddy vs Dusty

Dusty probably a safer bet, but if Franklin gets going, you would want to be on that train.

 

[SickQwon]

Still got a knee worry doesn't he?

Had surgery during the 2014 season, predicted to be fully fit by round 1

 

[timtamWB]

Buddy vs Dusty

Honestly? Flip a coin. Both will average similar IMO. Grab both if you can.