2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[PACatter]

SO it looks like I'm picking JPK .

Just have to narrow down between Beams and Parker.

Are there any cons of going in with 2 premiums from the same team in the midfield?

It's not like you're picking 2 Saints or 2 Norf midfielders.

2 premo Swans mids should be fine.

 

[Goats]

For M4 & F2.

Danger & Deledio Vs. JPK & Buddy.

 

[JC Hawks]

For M4 & F2.

Danger & Deledio Vs. JPK & Buddy.

I like JPK and Buddy. Will be especially good if Essendon players get banned, expect big scores from both Rd 1.

 

[MicCheck12]

Gibson or Adcock?

 

[Vineyy]

Gibson or Adcock?

Gibson if you have the $. Potential top defender this year IMO.

At D4. Ibbotson (343k) or Henderson (320k)?

 

[MicCheck12]

Gibson if you have the $. Potential top defender this year IMO.

Was thinking Adcock (smokie) but will stick with Gibbo.

At D4. Ibbotson (343k) or Henderson (320k)?

D4 for me is KK - Most people on here seem to be going with Ibbotson or KK @ D4.

------

Selwood or Kennedy?

 

[Lachy Jamison]

D4 for me is KK - Most people on here seem to be going with Ibbotson or KK @ D4.

------

Selwood or Kennedy?

I'd have Selwood by the smallest of margins and i dont have any reasoning for it.
Deledio vs Goddard vs Bartel vs Franklin

 

[MicCheck12]

I'd have Selwood by the smallest of margins and i dont have any reasoning for it.
Deledio vs Goddard vs Bartel vs Franklin

Bartel F2 - Absolute Gun! Buddy can have some absolute shockers

 

[Two Planks]

Old vs Young

Swan Bartel vs Bonts Bennell

 

[JC Hawks]

Old vs Young

Swan Bartel vs Bonts Bennell

Conservative would be option 1, however I like to take risks and would probably go option 2. Bennell has a massive ceiling this year. But the safe option would be Swan and Bartel.

 

[JC Hawks]

Lumumba vs Higgins vs Adcock for the D3 position.

 

[Two Planks]

Lumumba vs Higgins vs Adcock for the D3 position.

In the order you listed.

Players in 1st year at new clubs tend to start year in great style. Harry O will average 90 + until the bye.

 

[JC Hawks]

In the order you listed.

Players in 1st year at new clubs tend to start year in great style. Harry O will average 90 + until the bye.

Also what about Kolodjashnij vs Higgins vs Adcock at D4?

 

[Jiska]

Also what about Kolodjashnij vs Higgins vs Adcock at D4?

I don't really like any of those.

Old vs Young

Swan Bartel vs Bonts Bennell

How about Bartel and Benell??

*******

Pendles, Fyfe or Jelwood?

 

[MightyDons4]

Lumumba vs Higgins vs Adcock for the D3 position.

Lumumba

Also what about Kolodjashnij vs Higgins vs Adcock at D4?

Higgins

 

[Kadog]

SO it looks like I'm picking JPK .

Just have to narrow down between Beams and Parker.

Are there any cons of going in with 2 premiums from the same team in the midfield?

No. I used to go in with Swan Pendles & Beams with no problems.
Ftr I'd go Parker>Beams....just! Both excellent choices.

For M4 & F2.

Danger & Deledio Vs. JPK & Buddy.

JPK & Buddy

Gibson or Adcock?

Gibson

Gibson if you have the $. Potential top defender this year IMO.

At D4. Ibbotson (343k) or Henderson (320k)?

Ibbotson

D4 for me is KK - Most people on here seem to be going with Ibbotson or KK @ D4.

------

Selwood or Kennedy?

Jelwood

I'd have Selwood by the smallest of margins and i dont have any reasoning for it.
Deledio vs Goddard vs Bartel vs Franklin

Buddy>Bartel>Deledio>Goddard in that order.

Old vs Young

Swan Bartel vs Bonts Bennell

Swan Bartel

Also what about Kolodjashnij vs Higgins vs Adcock at D4?

I like KK for value, upside & durability.

I don't really like any of those.

How about Bartel and Benell??

*******

Pendles, Fyfe or Jelwood?

Pendles always #2 pick after Gaj for Jiska.

 

[_M_16_]

Had to slightly downgrade one of my top two defenders (Shaw and Gibson) for strategic reasons and to cover a hole elsewhere. At this stage I have decided to stick with Gibson. Have three things I am indecisive over

Gibson or Shaw?

D2 = Kelly, Birchall, Rance, Murphy, Enright or Johnson? These are the players within my price range for D2, leaning towards Kelly or Johnson at the moment

And lastly. Selwood, Fyfe, Parker, Lewis. Should I drop any of those for Beams or stick with those four premiums in the middle?

 

[CotchyPls]

Had to slightly downgrade one of my top two defenders (Shaw and Gibson) for strategic reasons and to cover a hole elsewhere. At this stage I have decided to stick with Gibson. Have three things I am indecisive over

Gibson or Shaw?

D2 = Kelly, Birchall, Rance, Murphy, Enright or Johnson? These are the players within my price range for D2, leaning towards Kelly or Johnson at the moment

And lastly. Selwood, Fyfe, Parker, Lewis. Should I drop any of those for Beams or stick with those four premiums in the middle?

Shaw

Kelly or Johnson

Lewis for Beams

I'm not a fan of Hawk players

 

[Johanpetro]

I think im down to my final decision for my team.

Martin VS Dangerfield

who do we take?

 

[lopylaa]

I think im down to my final decision for my team.

Martin VS Dangerfield

who do we take?

Martin! Danger in last year without contract and history will tell you gazza aside that people just don't perform when their out of contract at season end. Gazza is the only exception and that's because well he's litte gaz

 

[lopylaa]

I'm stuck for m6 do I go wines or griffin? Griffin only slightly cheaper so money Dosn't come into it

Any comments greatly appreciated

Thanks

 

[Two Planks]

I'm stuck for m6 do I go wines or griffin? Griffin only slightly cheaper so money Dosn't come into it

Any comments greatly appreciated

Thanks

Wines. He could average 115 this year.

 

[karaoke]

I'm stuck for m6 do I go wines or griffin? Griffin only slightly cheaper so money Dosn't come into it

Any comments greatly appreciated

Thanks

Griffen - back in the one with history.

-/-

Minson & Gray

V

Goldstein & DMartin

 

[Jars458]

At the stage of their careers and roles they play in there respective teams I'll stick with Shaw easily.
Will average 10+ points more than Kelly imo

Total points is more my concern with Shaw. I have never been comfortable picking him. Hopefully Kelly gets the magical midfield time.

 

[MicCheck12]

Total points is more my concern with Shaw. I have never been comfortable picking him. Hopefully Kelly gets the magical midfield time.

Brodie Smith or Heath Shaw or Simpson?