2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[juddola]

GAJ vs Rocky vs Pendles

Pick two

GAJ and Pendles

 

[magpies77]

GAJ and Pendles

Agreed

Parker v Watson

 

[juddola]

Agreed

Parker v Watson

Parker

 

[magpies77]

Agreed

Parker v Watson

Change that to:

Watson/parker & bennel v JPK and bonts

 

[Baird]

Change that to:

Watson/parker & bennel v JPK and bonts

JPK and Bont

 

[Goats]

Dangerfield V Watson V Heppell V Treloar V Boak?????

Watson

Still struggling with my rucks.

Currently going with

Mumford and Goldstein

but considering

Jacobs and Natanui with 80K spare

thoughts??

Mumford and Goldy

I would say newnes.

The prince + 70k vs hibberd

Sheed vs newton

If you're just banking the $70k then Hibberd is your man. Sheed will have more opportunities I feel.

Pendles, Fyfe, Newnes, Salem

V

Pendles, Beams, Hibbered + Forward rookie under 135k e.g.karnezis

Option 1 is sexy.

Can't make up my mind with the forwards.

Bennell vs. Goddard vs. Martin for one spot

Tom Mitchell vs. Bontempelli for the other

any thoughts?

Martin and Bonts for me, Bontempelli is all but guaranteed to spend the year on ball where as Mitchell will spend a lot of his game playing off half forward and is still a sub risk.

I'll try again, J Lewis or Parker?

Very similar players that both do a bit of everything. Parker has more upside but he will certainly cop a lot more attention, might struggle for consistent high scores.

Have two spots in the midfield to fill from 3 players
C. Ward, D. Beams, & JPKennedy
What do you think? or are there better options around that mark

Beams and JPK, reliable 225+ a week.

 

[Goats]

GAJ vs Rocky vs Pendles

Pick two

Ablett and Pendles, Rocky is going to spend more time forward and bleed coin. Definitely one to bring in after his bye.

 

[Lums23]

GAJ vs Rocky vs Pendles

Pick two

GAJ and Pendles

 

[ManWithNoName]

Minson or Big Boy McEvoy?

 

[JT_the_Man]

GAJ vs Rocky vs Pendles

Pick two

Gaz and Pendles

 

[JT_the_Man]

Minson or Big Boy McEvoy?

Minson.

 

[kenneje]

GAJ + Beams + JPK
vs
GAJ + Fyfe + Parker/Boak
vs
Fyfe + Selwood + Beams

 

[juddola]

How about Minson Vs Maric?

Buddy Vs Grey? Considering price difference as well.

 

[kenneje]

Minson or Big Boy McEvoy?

Minson! If Big Boy has a bad week, and Hale tears it up in the VFL, he'll be rotated.

 

[juddola]

GAJ + Beams + JPK
vs
GAJ + Fyfe + Parker/Boak
vs
Fyfe + Selwood + Beams

I like option 2, room for improvement. The other 2 you know what you will get.

 

[12Chill]

Kolodjashnij vs Ibbotson

 

[JC Hawks]

Kolodjashnij vs Ibbotson

KK.

 

[timtamWB]

How about Minson Vs Maric?

Buddy Vs Grey? Considering price difference as well.

I've gone Maric. I don't overly trust Minson this year, he just seems to be a bit meh so far.

As for Buddy and Gray? You can't really go wrong either way, so I'd go Buddy just to save a bit of cash.

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Kolodjashnij vs Ibbotson

Asked the same question earlier. Was 50/50. I'd go KK(and have).

 

[JT_the_Man]

GAJ + Beams + JPK
vs
GAJ + Fyfe + Parker/Boak
vs
Fyfe + Selwood + Beams

Easily in my mind.

 

[ManWithNoName]

Minson! If Big Boy has a bad week, and Hale tears it up in the VFL, he'll be rotated.

I reckon Hale's about done though.

 

[kenneje]

I reckon Hale's about done though.

Clarko bloody loves him though. Will be given every chance.

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

#1 premo def. Who should it be?
Simpson v Hibberd v Gibson v Burgoyne v M.Johnson

Already have Shaw

 

[JT_the_Man]

#1 premo def. Who should it be?
Simpson v Hibberd v Gibson v Burgoyne v M.Johnson

Already have Shaw

Burgoyne. Basically like an extra mid.

 

[juddola]

Simpson