2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[Flandersss]

Of the rookies, anyone want to have a go at ranking the JS of:

Hamling
Steele
Neale-Bullen
Stretch

There's a good chance I might pick up 2 or 3...

ANB & Steele.

 

[Jiska]

Of the rookies, anyone want to have a go at ranking the JS of:

Hamling
Steele
Neale-Bullen
Stretch

There's a good chance I might pick up 2 or 3...

I reckon the order you posted in is spot on.

 

[keithrichards]

I reckon the order you posted in is spot on.

My thoughts too.

Here's another one....!

McDonald vs Taylor vs Enright in the Backline?

 

[Lums23]

My thoughts too.

Here's another one....!

McDonald vs Taylor vs Enright in the Backline?

I'd take Mcdonald just ahead of Enright.

 

[Jiska]

My thoughts too.

Here's another one....!

McDonald vs Taylor vs Enright in the Backline?

Enright, TMac, Taylor IMO.

 

[keithrichards]

I'd take Mcdonald just ahead of Enright.

Cheers guys

EDIT: by the way FYI I went with McDonald...

 

[Goats]

So at M 6-9 I've got Wallis, Barlow, Selwood and Griffin.

Excluding Wallis which one of these sacks of shit should I downgrade to finish off my backs and forwards?

The downgrade will allow me to bring in Houli and Dahlhaus for Tarrant and Tosh.

 

[MightyMark]

Cheers guys

EDIT: by the way FYI I went with McDonald...

How pissed off are you with that choice. WTF happened to him on the weekend, would have expected him to kill it in a win.

 

[keithrichards]

How pissed off are you with that choice. WTF happened to him on the weekend, would have expected him to kill it in a win.

Couldn't believe it! I only really traded him in this week to secure a league win... I was 80 points up leading in to the game, and my opponent had Harry Taylor, so turns out I didn't need him anyway!

As long as he bounces back and averages his 90-95 I'll be happy, but that's not a great start.

 

[MightyMark]

Couldn't believe it! I only really traded him in this week to secure a league win... I was 80 points up leading in to the game, and my opponent had Harry Taylor, so turns out I didn't need him anyway!

As long as he bounces back and averages his 90-95 I'll be happy, but that's not a great start.

Trouble is if he starts getting put in shut down roles for the rest of the year. Thats always the risk with KPP, hopefully he gets freed up more.

 

[buttox]

My thoughts too.

Here's another one....!

McDonald vs Taylor vs Enright in the Backline?

enright taylor daylight mcdonald

 

[buttox]

So at M 6-9 I've got Wallis, Barlow, Selwood and Griffin.

Excluding Wallis which one of these sacks of shit should I downgrade to finish off my backs and forwards?

The downgrade will allow me to bring in Houli and Dahlhaus for Tarrant and Tosh.

griff easy then barlow
but if you have fyfe and neale as other mids id dump barlow

 

[Red Syrah]

Who to hold for D6: Newnes or Rance?

And does anyone know what has happened to Rance??

 

[juddola]

Who to hold for D6: Newnes or Rance?

And does anyone know what has happened to Rance??

The guy at Champion Data who had him traded him out.

 

[tommyv49]

Hannebery vs Armitage?

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hannebery vs Armitage?

Hanners for me.

 

[Lums23]

Hannebery vs Armitage?

Hannebery just. Armo has only averaged 106 over the last 5

 

[Red Syrah]

Montagna vs Beams

Montagna has 5 rd avg of 121 compared to Beams of 124 but is 38K cheaper. Just not sure if the Saints can keep on trying hard.

 

[MightyMark]

Montagna vs Beams

Montagna has 5 rd avg of 121 compared to Beams of 124 but is 38K cheaper. Just not sure if the Saints can keep on trying hard.

I would go with Beams

 

[Lums23]

Parker vs Hodge

 

[SnappyHappy]

Parker vs Hodge

Parker

 

[ohh_v]

Get Laird, or pay the premium for Hodge?

 

[juddola]

Get Laird, or pay the premium for Hodge?

I would go Hodge, you know he wont drop off much.

 

[Lums23]

Get Laird, or pay the premium for Hodge?

Hodge is only 40k more. I'd shell out that much if you think he is going to score better from here on

 

[PAFC1996]

Pendles v Mundy v Lewis v Sidebottom?