2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[toxic]

I have B.Smith who I want to upgrade in the next few weeks when I can generate more cash.
I can risk Malceski now and not wait, alternatively:

LAST DEFENDER TO GRAB:
Malceski v Picken v Rance v Yeo or other...

DEF: Hodge, Shaw, Gibson, TMac, Docherty, B.Smith (Lever, Hamling)

Birchall is an option too

 

[MightyMark]

Birchall is an option too

Picken would be the best bet. Birchall seems to be up and done and bit, as the roles switch around too much with the Hawks backs.

I like Malceski, and cant help but think that Abletts return has had something to do with his improvement, dont know how, but I cant shake the feeling.

 

[Krujan]

Picken would be the best bet. Birchall seems to be up and done and bit, as the roles switch around too much with the Hawks backs.

I like Malceski, and cant help but think that Abletts return has had something to do with his improvement, dont know how, but I cant shake the feeling.

Or maybe Saad not being in the team the last 2 weeks.

 

[MightyMark]

Or maybe Saad not being in the team the last 2 weeks.

Thats the logical explanation, but I just have a gut feeling, even once Saad returns Malceski may continue. Cant ignore the Ablett effect.

 

[Krujan]

Thats the logical explanation, but I just have a gut feeling, even once Saad returns Malceski may continue. Cant ignore the Ablett effect.

Eski is still a gun player. No way he spuds up all year. I'm expecting minimum 85 average from him from the remaining games. Should be able to comfortably average 90+ if he's over his injuries though.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Or maybe Saad not being in the team the last 2 weeks.

Thats the logical explanation, but I just have a gut feeling, even once Saad returns Malceski may continue. Cant ignore the Ablett effect.

I reckon from now on in his scores should be ok either way, it was more of a case of him being injured and getting used to a new team set up that effected his scoring than anything else.
Its not as if he will be given a lock down role once Saad gets back in the team, that's not his skill set.

 

[MightyMark]

Eski is still a gun player. No way he spuds up all year. I'm expecting minimum 85 average from him from the remaining games. Should be able to comfortably average 90+ if he's over his injuries though.

Will have one final upgrade in my backs for either Hibberd, Taylor or Ox. Prob wont be Ox, you have already shown the light with him. But one of them will turn into the best available defender. If im lucky i'll just scrape enough to get Picken, otherwise, i'll be looking at Laird, Yeo or Malceski, and the money saved with Malceski will be handy in the kitty if I need to sideways out an injured premo.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Will have one final upgrade in my backs for either Hibberd, Taylor or Ox. Prob wont be Ox, you have already shown the light with him. But one of them will turn into the best available defender. If im lucky i'll just scrape enough to get Picken, otherwise, i'll be looking at Laird, Yeo or Malceski, and the money saved with Malceski will be handy in the kitty if I need to sideways out an injured premo.

Hang onto Ox. I would have loved to have kepthim for the rest of the year but I the only reason I chopped him was to get GAJ in.

 

[MightyMark]

Hang onto Ox. I would have loved to have kepthim for the rest of the year but I the only reason I chopped him was to get GAJ in.

Yeah Hibberd and Taylor are the most likely to get the chop, we will see who does better this weekend.

 

[Hack_Watts]

Fields vs H Goddard?

Thinking of downgrading the non playing MCKenzie to a rookie to fund Wallis to GAJ (225k in bank).

Other option is Wallis and Griffen to B Goddard and GAJ.

Thoughts lads?

 

[SC fish]

Which defender to trade out for cash to get Fyfe: Hamling, A Pearce or Lever.

The two I keep will be D7 and D8 bench cover.

 

[toxic]

Which defender to trade out for cash to get Fyfe: Hamling, A Pearce or Lever.

The two I keep will be D7 and D8 bench cover.

The same fyfe with a sam.mitchell tattoo on his thigh that has him in serious doubt yo play on the weekend

 

[Lums23]

Fields vs H Goddard?

Thinking of downgrading the non playing MCKenzie to a rookie to fund Wallis to GAJ (225k in bank).

Other option is Wallis and Griffen to B Goddard and GAJ.

Thoughts lads?

Fields didn't get named do that makes it an easy choice

 

[SC fish]

The same fyfe with a sam.mitchell tattoo on his thigh that has him in serious doubt yo play on the weekend

oops not Fyfe - total brain fade, meant Gazz

Am thinking Pearce has the lower scoring ability bit at least he's playing - for now...

 

[AngryRanga]

Cotchin or Selwood out for GAJ

 

[Hairy Lager]

Cotchin or Selwood out for GAJ

 

[Red Syrah]

Hodge v Parker v Zorko

Who will score more consistently?
And any concerns about Zorko's scoring if Beams goes down?

 

[MotlopMagic]

Hodge v Parker v Zorko

Who will score more consistently?
And any concerns about Zorko's scoring if Beams goes down?

Hodge.

Priddis or Ward?

 

[MightyMark]

Fields vs H Goddard?

Thinking of downgrading the non playing MCKenzie to a rookie to fund Wallis to GAJ (225k in bank).

Other option is Wallis and Griffen to B Goddard and GAJ.

Thoughts lads?

What about J Kol, already on the bubble, and starting on the field.

Hodge.

Priddis or Ward?

Ward, dont ask me why, I cant give you a good enough reason, both players are guns, I just think Ward has a better chance of pulling out some huge scores in the run home.

 

[jjsmitty8]

Hodge.

Priddis or Ward?

I've got both, I've had Priddis all year, Ward about half the year. Super hard to split, would probably lean towards to Ward.

 

[jjsmitty8]

Jack Lonie to:

A) Luke Dahlhaus
B) Tom Mitchell
C) Jimmy Bartel

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Jack Lonie to:

A) Luke Dahlhaus
B) Tom Mitchell
C) Jimmy Bartel

Dahl > Bart > Mitch for me. Tough though.

 

[Foxx]

Krak to Deledio = Full premium team and 6 trades left minus Gaz
or
Parker to Gaz and final upgrade next week = 4 trades left

Play it safe? Or go with 4 trades with 2 rounds before finals?

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Krak to Deledio = Full premium team and 6 trades left minus Gaz
or
Parker to Gaz and final upgrade next week = 4 trades left

Play it safe? Or go with 4 trades with 2 rounds before finals?

Depends on team but I reckon Krak > Deledio then get Ablett next week.

Gives you another week to assess who you want to get rid of for Ablett.

 

[toxic]

Jack Lonie to:

A) Luke Dahlhaus
B) Tom Mitchell
C) Jimmy Bartel

Dollhouse
jimmy
tmit