List Mgmt. 2016 Free Agency/Trades/Draft thread Part 3

[Vhaluus]

Sorry but Gibbs doesn't get to you guys with a first rounder. The only way a second rounder could suffice is if one of your top 5 players comes back to us instead.

You know how big the gap is between our top 5 players and Gibbs? Gibbs wouldn't even crack our top 10.

 

[Elite Crow]

Sorry but Gibbs doesn't get to you guys with a first rounder. The only way a second rounder could suffice is if one of your top 5 players comes back to us instead.

Most of us realise this

 

[Crowstar]

Its a new Carlton now with SOS in charge of list management. The old Carlton would have jumped all over that haha

Very good point haha

 

[Houston]

Sorry but he doesn't fit our age profile. We aren't going to get rid of Gibbs and bring in someone who is 29 next season.

He's young at heart!

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

He's young at heart!

Will give you points for trying but nah!

 

[Ozzie]

A two for one?

No should have been clearer, Either one.
Reason: Gibbs is older and wanting out. Lyons and CEY happy to leave. Gibbs only worth one of these at his age. Talk of first rounders and players like this +a low pick is stupid stuff.

If we are smart and really want to let our depth walk out the door, we should get 2nd rounders for Dmac and these 2. I hate the idea of over-paying for supposed "stars".

 

[JP Sauce]

I'm waiting for "Adelaide re-sign Mackay to long-term deal after big offers from rival clubs."

Camporeale: "David is one of our leaders at the club and sets a high standard for our younger players. We're absolutely wrapped that he's staying with us for the rest of his career"

 

[Elite Crow]

Whether you rate Gibbs or not, he's contracted for 3 years. Carlton are not going to release him without being made an offer they can't refuse.

Suggestions of a second round pick and average players are dumb and a waste of time.

It will take our first and a player.

Some might not think that's what he's worth but that's what it will take.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Sorry but he doesn't fit our age profile. We aren't going to get rid of Gibbs and bring in someone who is 29 next season.

He has the frame of a teenager

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Simmer Ozzie!

It's peace time

 

[Donkey Magoo]

Its a new Carlton now with SOS in charge of list management. The old Carlton would have jumped all over that haha

What about if we put Mackay in a GWS jumper first?

 

[1970crow]

Whether you rate Gibbs or not, he's contracted for 3 years. Carlton are not going to release him without being made an offer they can't refuse.

Suggestions of a second round pick and average players are dumb and a waste of time.

It will take our first and a player.

Some might not think that's what he's worth but that's what it will take.

Not sure. We mightn't be all that hot for him ourselves. Might be a scenario with 3 parties mildly interested n doing a deal. Gibbs happy to come home, happy to stay. Blues happy to sell, happy to keep. Us happy to buy, happy to walk. I've got a feeling we won't be overpaying.

 

[Donkey Magoo]

Is Tom Mitchell definitely going to Vic? He'd be worth a play.

 

[Mego Red]

No should have been clearer, Either one.
Reason: Gibbs is older and wanting out. Lyons and CEY happy to leave. Gibbs only worth one of these at his age. Talk of first rounders and players like this +a low pick is stupid stuff.

If we are smart and really want to let our depth walk out the door, we should get 2nd rounders for Dmac and these 2. I hate the idea of over-paying for supposed "stars".

Yep. Didn't work with Tom Boyd.

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

What about if we put Mackay in a GWS jumper first?

TBF, that would probably do it hahaha

 

[mattymac]

You know how big the gap is between our top 5 players and Gibbs? Gibbs wouldn't even crack our top 10.

Oh come on. Gibbs would be knocking on the door of top 5. There is some ridiculous over rating of our list. Gibbs walks into our top 10 players

1 Rory Sloane 268

2 Eddie Betts 249

3 Tom Lynch 215

4 Daniel Talia 192

5 Taylor Walker 185

6 Brodie Smith 183

7 Matt Crouch 180

8 Kyle Hartigan 173

9 Charlie Cameron 168

10 Josh Jenkins 167

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Gibbs would be our second best player IMO after Sloane

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Gibbs would be our second best player IMO after Sloane

I would suggest he'd certainly be your second best midfielder behind Sloane.

 

[Ozzie]

Yep. Didn't work with Tom Boyd.

Boyd was a rare beast, unhappy at GWS, dogs came offering immense riches, wouldn't you leave? #1 pick in the draft the year before. Are you saying Gibbs and Rocky are the equivalent worth? I certainly don't think they are. Bad example from you there.

 

[Mego Red]

I would suggest he'd certainly be your second best midfielder behind Sloane.

Depends on what happens with Brad Crouch, but sure.

 

[Mego Red]

Oh come on. Gibbs would be knocking on the door of top 5. There is some ridiculous over rating of our list. Gibbs walks into our top 10 players

1 Rory Sloane 268

2 Eddie Betts 249

3 Tom Lynch 215

4 Daniel Talia 192

5 Taylor Walker 185

6 Brodie Smith 183

7 Matt Crouch 180

8 Kyle Hartigan 173

9 Charlie Cameron 168

10 Josh Jenkins 167

Where is this list from?

 

[Elite Crow]

Not sure. We mightn't be all that hot for him ourselves. Might be a scenario with 3 parties mildly interested n doing a deal. Gibbs happy to come home, happy to stay. Blues happy to sell, happy to keep. Us happy to buy, happy to walk. I've got a feeling we won't be overpaying.

I agree with that, we would only do the deal if we wanted to, we don't have to do it if we don't want to.

My point is what it will take for Carlton to release him. They don't have to do Gibbs or us any favours.

 

[Elite Crow]

Gibbs would be our second best player IMO after Sloane

Nah, he's not better than Talia, Tex, Betts and I'd say even Laird. He would be our second best mid though unless Brad comes on as expected.

 

[Bicks]

Oh come on. Gibbs would be knocking on the door of top 5. There is some ridiculous over rating of our list. Gibbs walks into our top 10 players

1 Rory Sloane 268

2 Eddie Betts 249

3 Tom Lynch 215

4 Daniel Talia 192

5 Taylor Walker 185

6 Brodie Smith 183

7 Matt Crouch 180

8 Kyle Hartigan 173

9 Charlie Cameron 168

10 Josh Jenkins 167

As soon as I saw no Rory Laird I

 

[morris086]

Where is this list from?

This years club champion award.