List Mgmt. 2016 List Management thread - 2017 list complete

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
lose said:
For me:

GAWN
Terls, Grimes, White, King

POSSIBLY GAWN/TRADE BAIT
Viv, Newton,Dunn, Garland, M Jones, ANB, JKH, Dawes, Pedo

Now I wouldn't be surprised in the slightest if we threw ANB on the trade table simply because I rekon he's our only player in this category who could get us something in the second round if we are lucky..

Also I hate saying this but I'd be amazed if trenners makes it back.. My god he is bloody slow
Click to expand...

Agree on Trenners, and I'd definitely be up for trading ANB. I understand why Trenners got another year to at least have a preseason but he is no chance of making it back.

Garland has been phoning it in since 2014, can't stand him in the side. I know he was pretty good in our terrible years but he has absolutely zero urgency in his game and looks like he doesn't give a s**t.
 
schmuttt said:
Agree on Trenners, and I'd definitely be up for trading ANB. I understand why Trenners got another year to at least have a preseason but he is no chance of making it back.

Garland has been phoning it in since 2014, can't stand him in the side. I know he was pretty good in our terrible years but he has absolutely zero urgency in his game and looks like he doesn't give a s**t.
Click to expand...

Yeh garlo has gone backwards big time the last couple of years, although today I think he was clearly restricted by the corky? he copped last week..
 

Log in to remove this ad.

hqdefault.jpg
 
From our senior list we need at least four spots for Hibberd and 3 draftees/rookie upgrades. Our current picks are 26, 44, 62, 80

-Trade pick 26 for Hibberd strait swap.

-Strait up delist Terlich and Grimes (both out of contract)

-Trade Dunn for a late pick up grade (Brisbane?), will likely not get much more than fourth round upgrade imo, pick 62 turns to 56

-With 2 years on his contract left, Garland will cost to delist so would try and trade him even for a 5th round upgrade if any takers, only 28 I'd think someone will give him a chance even if we have to pay some of his wage.

That should give us our 4 spots, Hibberd, pick 44, pick 56 and Rookie upgrade Wagner (would need to upgrade Wagner after losing all of Grimes, Garland and Dunn)

-Now I think our greatest list weakness is our ruck depth, Outside of Gawn and Spencer we have no ready made ruckman and if both go down injured we are stuffed, Mitch King very raw and injured this year is a while off. Delist Dawes and find a ready made depth ruckman who can be on the list for a year or 2 until Mitch King has his body right to play AFL.

-On verge of finals I think we need I think we need a bit more experience and leadership, I'd like to add Hamish Hartlett if we can come up with a trade, only 26, harder outside player that is Port's vice captain, after getting Bernie's career to turn around I'd back us to get the best out of Hartlett, Strait swap for next years first or next years second along with ANB? If Port don't accept we then move on. Strait swap of a first would involve delisting M.Jones or Newton

- Still with the experience and leadership adding a delisted free agent (or even 2 if we miss out on Hartlett), Boomer Harvey, Dal Santo, Bartel? Getting good experience and leadership into our joung side could push us into the 8, As I said before Matt Jones and Newton will be the ones making way if we can get 2 guys on to our list, possibly ANB if he's involved in a trade for Hartlett and the one of the other guys survives.


Out: Grimes, Terlich, Dunn, Garland, Dawes
In: Hibberd, Wagner, pick 44, pick 54, experienced ruckman

Potentially In: Hartlett, Brent Harvey
Potentially Out: Newton, M.Jones, 2017 1st rounder.
 
Trenners was cooked the last month of the season - I get why they still played him but he was looking terrible through the finals series.

I still think he can come good with some luck.
 
So what's up with Dunn? I thought he was a pretty handy KPD the last few years prior to 2016.
What happened this year? Injuries? He's past it? Never was any good?
Seems like you guys are pretty keen to get him out of the club for peanuts. Actually think he'd be good for Brisbane. Any intel on where his future lies?
Cheers lads
 
Last edited:
Phoenix_9 said:
So what's up with Dunn? I thought he was a pretty hand KPD the last few years prior to 2016.
What happened this year? Injuries? He's past it? Never was any good?
Seems like you guys are pretty keen to get him out of the club for peanuts. Actually think he'd be good for Brisbane. Any intel on where his future lies?
Cheers lads
Click to expand...
Most likely will go to brissy
The club most likely wasn't playing him because they wanted to put stocks in the future. I'd much prefer to keep him
 
Phoenix_9 said:
So what's up with Dunn? I thought he was a pretty hand KPD the last few years prior to 2016.
What happened this year? Injuries? He's past it? Never was any good?
Seems like you guys are pretty keen to get him out of the club for peanuts. Actually think he'd be good for Brisbane. Any intel on where his future lies?
Cheers lads
Click to expand...
Just struggled to adapt to the zone defence being the good one on one player he is. Personally i'd rather keep him and i hope he can find his way back in to the best 22
 
darthsidusfan said:
Just struggled to adapt to the zone defence being the good one on one player he is. Personally i'd rather keep him and i hope he can find his way back in to the best 22
Click to expand...

Agree. Our back ups for KPD are very slim. Thought he was very stiff not to get more games this year. Great 1 on 1 defenders are hard to come by. We still struggle with big forwards like Hawkins. OMac needed some games, but was hardly up to it most of the year. Hopefully putting games into him pays off. Unless someone offers a silly trade, I'd like to see us keep Dunn.
 
Getting rid of Dunn and Garland for nothing picks is so stupid. We need depth FFS.
 
Who said it'll be for nothing picks? Trade period hasn't happened yet

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

:musicnotes: Get your money for nothing and your picks for free :musicnotes:
 
Blackas87 said:
From our senior list we need at least four spots for Hibberd and 3 draftees/rookie upgrades. Our current picks are 26, 44, 62, 80

-Trade pick 26 for Hibberd strait swap.

-Strait up delist Terlich and Grimes (both out of contract)

-Trade Dunn for a late pick up grade (Brisbane?), will likely not get much more than fourth round upgrade imo, pick 62 turns to 56

-With 2 years on his contract left, Garland will cost to delist so would try and trade him even for a 5th round upgrade if any takers, only 28 I'd think someone will give him a chance even if we have to pay some of his wage.

That should give us our 4 spots, Hibberd, pick 44, pick 56 and Rookie upgrade Wagner (would need to upgrade Wagner after losing all of Grimes, Garland and Dunn)

-Now I think our greatest list weakness is our ruck depth, Outside of Gawn and Spencer we have no ready made ruckman and if both go down injured we are stuffed, Mitch King very raw and injured this year is a while off. Delist Dawes and find a ready made depth ruckman who can be on the list for a year or 2 until Mitch King has his body right to play AFL.

-On verge of finals I think we need I think we need a bit more experience and leadership, I'd like to add Hamish Hartlett if we can come up with a trade, only 26, harder outside player that is Port's vice captain, after getting Bernie's career to turn around I'd back us to get the best out of Hartlett, Strait swap for next years first or next years second along with ANB? If Port don't accept we then move on. Strait swap of a first would involve delisting M.Jones or Newton

- Still with the experience and leadership adding a delisted free agent (or even 2 if we miss out on Hartlett), Boomer Harvey, Dal Santo, Bartel? Getting good experience and leadership into our joung side could push us into the 8, As I said before Matt Jones and Newton will be the ones making way if we can get 2 guys on to our list, possibly ANB if he's involved in a trade for Hartlett and the one of the other guys survives.


Out: Grimes, Terlich, Dunn, Garland, Dawes
In: Hibberd, Wagner, pick 44, pick 54, experienced ruckman

Potentially In: Hartlett, Brent Harvey
Potentially Out: Newton, M.Jones, 2017 1st rounder.
Click to expand...

I like all of this..

The only thing I disagree with is Dunn's value.

I think a 4th round pick upgraded to a 3rd rounder is closer IMO.
 
harry000 said:
I like all of this..

The only thing I disagree with is Dunn's value.

I think a 4th round pick upgraded to a 3rd rounder is closer IMO.
Click to expand...
Lions don't have a 3rd, gave it to Geelong
 
I reckon Dunn might be involved in some sort of complicated pick upgrade. Does somebody whose oven timer isn't currently beeping want to have a shot at how that might work?
 
Hotdees said:
Dean Terlich is officially gone. Sad day for football
Click to expand...

Matt Jones had an ok year tbh. But deserved to go. Same with Terlich. The fact we will have Hibberd and Melksham basically play Grimes role, pretty much sealed the deal for Jack unfortunately. Newton and Michie must be just hanging on by a thread! Same with the boys on the rookie list White and King. 3 delistings isn't enough to get us into the draft fully yet, so there will be more I'm assuming, unless one or two want to get traded...
 
Tempy Tiger said:
The fact Chrish hasn't been delisted yet concerns me regarding Hogan's future...
Click to expand...

Won't get delisted yet, the club is probably still hopeful for someone to get desperate enough to put an ad in the paper for an "experienced Premiership-winning key forward".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Dory_77
AFLW 2023 List management - Draft/Trade thread
Replies
24
Views
2K
SugarHealey
SugarHealey
Scythe94
Injury The Injury/Suspension List – 2024
2
Replies
32
Views
1K
Topkent
Topkent
Headless
Club History Completely random Melbourne memories that come to mind for no particular reason
15 16 17 18 19
Replies
455
Views
8K
Topkent
Topkent
Scythe94
Injury The Injury/Suspension List – 2023
11 12 13 14 15
Replies
374
Views
15K
BG32
BG32
Proper Gander
Random thought thread (sponsored by Crimson)
Replies
19
Views
286
Oscarman
Oscarman
Scythe94
Roast The "I Was Wrong" Self-Reporting Thread
2 3 4 5
Replies
123
Views
3K
Jamurp
Jamurp
Topkent
Universal Love Melbourne's second team thread (Giants 🥳)
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
203
Views
9K
Dory_77
Dory_77

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top