2016 Rookies

[superfraser]

No problem.
While we're on rookies.
In the price range Andy Otten.
Will have him on my bench, is a chance to play when he's fit

When will he be fit?

Wouldn't want to wait more than 2-3 rounds for him.

 

[Viva la Mattner]

I'd imagine round 3 may be pushing for selection depending on SANFL form/fitness

 

[Double the Fist]

I'd imagine round 3 may be pushing for selection depending on SANFL form/fitness

Not bad. round 6 cull of an underperformer (no doubt I'll have plenty by then).
May work out well. Will keep an eye out.
Thanks again.

Edit. what was/were his injuries.

 

[Viva la Mattner]

Had knee reco rehab throughout 2015 had a slight cleanout in December putting him slightly behind the others

 

[stevebbb]

Dear Jacob Weitering, Mitch Brown, Michael Hartley, Cieran Byrne, Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti, Jason Ashby and Clem Smith,

Please dominate this NAB challenge match and lock down a spot in your sides best 22, we desperately need rookies down back.

Yours truly,
BF SC

 

[King_Steele]

Dear Jacob Weitering, Mitch Brown, Michael Hartley, Cieran Byrne, Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti, Jason Ashby and Clem Smith,

Please dominate this NAB challenge match and lock down a spot in your sides best 22, we desperately need rookies down back.

Yours truly,
BF SC

Brown & Hartley = locks

Tippa & Byrne going alright so far

 

[nameless]

If Grimley could mark, he'd be an OK player.

 

[Me Myself and I]

If Grimley could mark, he'd be an OK player.

and kick straight.

 

[Double the Fist]

Dear Jacob Weitering, Mitch Brown, Michael Hartley, Cieran Byrne, Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti, Jason Ashby and Clem Smith,

Please dominate this NAB challenge match and lock down a spot in your sides best 22, we desperately need rookies down back.

Yours truly,
BF SC

Put my name down, I'll PM you, and I'm sure they will ALL fire up for us. I'm kind of a big deal around here.....

 

[Double the Fist]

If Grimley could mark, he'd be an OK player.

and kick straight.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Kerridge and Petracca locked. Need two or three more to show themselves.
Not keen on Wells, Anderson at all.

Tippa, Cox look ok.
Adam's a chance maybe.

Anyone know what the 2 Collins' round 1 chances are like?

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Kerridge and Petracca locked. Need two or three more to show themselves.
Not keen on Wells, Anderson at all.

Tippa, Cox look ok.
Adam's a chance maybe.

Anyone know what the 2 Collins' round 1 chances are like?

Kieran Collins would be 50/50 at best based on NAB2, probably a little less than that.
Adams probably slightly behind Collins.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Kieran Collins would be 50/50 at best based on NAB2, probably a little less than that.
Adams probably slightly behind Collins.

Cheers, thought as much. Kieran is the ready made sized Collins isn't he.
Need to see more of him please Bevo.

 

[Double the Fist]

Kerridge and Petracca locked. Need two or three more to show themselves.
Not keen on Wells, Anderson at all.

Tippa, Cox look ok.
Adam's a chance maybe.

Anyone know what the 2 Collins' round 1 chances are like?

Why have you locked Petracca man?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Why have you locked Petracca man?

Will play games and as a big bodied mid who is forward selectable playing for a bottom team. He's a lock.
If he wont play untill round 4/5 I might hold off but would need someone else. Tippa, move Brown forward, ???, panic.

 

[Double the Fist]

Will play games and as a big bodied mid who is forward selectable playing for a bottom team. He's a lock.
If he wont play untill round 4/5 I might hold off but would need someone else. Tippa, move Brown forward, ???, panic.

If he is not named in rnd 1 I won't be grabbing him. DIdn't play any footy last year. Melbs will be a different kettle of fish this year. He'll be in VFL for a while until he has earned a spot. That may be a while, it may not, but I'm very iffy on him first up. See how he goes in teh remaining Nab games.

 

[nameless]

Finding I'm going to have to spend a bit on rookies to get value.

Currently have the following $150+ rookies

Ashby $165k
Oliver $207k
Menadue $155k
Kennedy $187k

Only 3 defensive rookies in the team, and very unsure on the mids.

 

[KardiniaPark]

and kick straight.

The issue being that a forward somewhat relies on being able to mark and kick...

 

[Double the Fist]

The issue being that a forward somewhat relies on being able to mark and kick...

 

[KardiniaPark]

You take that back

 

[Double the Fist]

You take that back

GAGF

 

[borrat]

Finding I'm going to have to spend a bit on rookies to get value.

Currently have the following $150+ rookies

Ashby $165k
Oliver $207k
Menadue $155k
Kennedy $187k

Only 3 defensive rookies in the team, and very unsure on the mids.

dont you rate duggan?

 

[Double the Fist]

dont you rate duggan?

Well I do, just not enough at that price.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Finding I'm going to have to spend a bit on rookies to get value.

Currently have the following $150+ rookies

Ashby $165k
Oliver $207k
Menadue $155k
Kennedy $187k

Only 3 defensive rookies in the team, and very unsure on the mids.

No Mills? He's pretty much guarenteed 22 and looks good for 70-80 average.
Weitering, Milera?

Kennedy interests me a little.

Menadue isn't best 22 IMO.
Ashby and Oliver only look good based on NAB form. Do you think they will get named round 1?

 

[Phoenix_9]

Weitering and Mills are IMO worth the extra dosh, not only for their job security, but also for their scoring potential. Also, why I'm grabbing Wells, as I'm viewing him as an expensive rookie.