2018 Rookies

[TheBeardAmigos]

You really going the twig Zac Guthrie?

Yuckkkkk bro.

its him and ZGL v C Brown + Barry

plus, i like Zach

 

[Flandersss]

its him and ZGL v C Brown + Barry

plus, i like Zach

Fair enough brother.

Can only see him getting 60-70 type scores, if that

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Fair enough brother.

Can only see him getting 60-70 type scores, if that

thats all im expecting tbh

 

[rocker_oz33]

You really going the twig Zac Guthrie?

Yuckkkkk bro.

Leave Her alone.

 

[Seymour Skinner]

From Ben Guthrie's Twitter.
Paddy Dow confirmed to make his debut for Carlton against Richmond tomorrow night. Jarrod Garlett, Matt Kennedy and Aaron Mullett will all play for the Blues.


Garletttt lock on the bench!
Might still grab Dow, worried that Brodie won't be there round 1.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Where's the Zuthrie love come from?
People getting desperate already?

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Where's the Zuthrie love come from?
People getting desperate already?

its just from me, dw

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

its just from me, dw

Doesn't that make you the DW?

 

[Flandersss]

Where's the Zuthrie love come from?
People getting desperate already?

Would only pick him if he was 123k not 200 lol. Soz TBA

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Doesn't that make you the DW?

possibly, but he has better JS than Brown, who i replaced Guthrie with

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

possibly, but he has better JS than Brown, who i replaced Guthrie with

I don't even have Naughton in my back line let alone Zuthrie or Coff

**** the rookies

 

[raymagoo]

I cannot for the life of me see why Dew would play Barlow (end of career) over the future in Will Brodie?
For my SC purposes and to better the GCS Brodie should be played this year as often as possible.

Because you need leaders around you and he’s still valueable

 

[Significant]

From Ben Guthrie's Twitter.
Paddy Dow confirmed to make his debut for Carlton against Richmond tomorrow night. Jarrod Garlett, Matt Kennedy and Aaron Mullett will all play for the Blues.


Garletttt lock on the bench!
Might still grab Dow, worried that Brodie won't be there round 1.

No O'Shea?

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

No O'Shea?

nah, they are preferring Byrne over him

 

[rocker_oz33]

I wish Byrne was cheaper.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

I wish Byrne was cheaper.

same, think he will only push a 75 average at best

 

[rocker_oz33]

same, think he will only push a 75 average at best

Hes numbers were alright around 20 touches a game but his SC score's were only about 70.Also high hand ball receives so hes team mates are looking for him.

 

[Huttabito]

I don't even have Naughton in my back line let alone Zuthrie or Coff

**** the rookies

Yeh I don't get why people are selecting rookies.

I'm going to start full premo and see how that goes.

 

[hoddo]

Saw retirees Lonergan and Mackie being interviewed on TV last night and it got me wondering who their likely replacements are in the Geelong defence this season. Do Geelong supporters feel they're departure will create a chance for any specific fringe player to become decent SC scorers? Are there particular rookies who might get regular games in their spots?

The Geelong midfield and forward rookies really worry me this season. They could be a trap. About 5 of them performed well enough in the JLT to be considered for a round 1 spot in the likely absence of Danger and Menegola, but which if any of the ones named for round 1 will still be there when those players return and last to even play 3 games?

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Saw retirees Lonergan and Mackie being interviewed on TV last night and it got me wondering who their likely replacements are in the Geelong defence this season. Do Geelong supporters feel they're departure will create a chance for any specific fringe player to become decent SC scorers? Are there particular rookies who might get regular games in their spots?

The Geelong midfield and forward rookies really worry me this season. They could be a trap. About 5 of them performed well enough in the JLT to be considered for a round 1 spot in the likely absence of Danger and Menegola, but which if any of the ones named for round 1 will still be there when those players return and last to even play 3 games?

Guthrie bois and they will go Taylor/Henderson/Stewart/Kolod as the talls

Kelly is the main one, but everyone should have him

 

[hoddo]

Guthrie bois and they will go Taylor/Henderson/Stewart/Kolod as the talls

Kelly is the main one, but everyone should have him

Yes you're probably right that the Taylor forward experiment will, and should, be over. Guthrie's interesting, but he was already getting games late last season and all those sub 60s scores combined with his price make him a no go zone for me. Agreed on Kelly. He's the one Geelong rookie I'm confident about.

 

[raymagoo]

No O'Shea?

Won’t play 14 defenders that could be in calculations

 

[raymagoo]

Hes numbers were alright around 20 touches a game but his SC score's were only about 70.Also high hand ball receives so hes team mates are looking for him.

I’m running him

 

[Marlowe]

Doesn't that make you the DW?

So which one of you is Arthur?

 

[peppy la pew]

Whatever happened to Worpel, Hawks were all over him a while back

Don't think he had a run in JLT