List Mgmt. 2020 Trade and List Management Thread III

[CarnTheKANGAS]

Did you mean for free?

Lol yep, soz i got too excited with other reply.
I'd do it in terms of being free from draft picks (taking on his whole salary) and trying for their first next year as well (maybe swap our 2nd rndr this yr to get it over the line)

 

[Agenda 21]

Yeah he makes Ziebs foot skills look like jarman

Give me Treloar over current day Ziebell.

One will be an automatic top 5 player, the other is captain and will struggle to get a game.

 

[Horizons_00]

Give me Treloar over current day Ziebell.

One will be an automatic top 5 player, the other is captain and will struggle to get a game.

Id take treloar for sure. He Dominates

Sure, he butchers the ball but so does most of our team. Would be a great addition

 

[Agenda 21]

Id take treloar for sure. He Dominates

Sure, he butchers the ball but so does most of our team. Would be a great addition

Anyone who can get the ball 35-40 times in shortened quarters, is a good player.

At times, we struggled to have any mids get over 20 disposals.

You just can't compete, when the stats are so skewed.

 

[shinboner magic]

Give me Treloar over current day Ziebell.

One will be an automatic top 5 player, the other is captain and will struggle to get a game.

Not at 900k he’s not

 

[darko]

We won’t have pick 2 we’re trading it to Gold Coast for pick 5 and there first round pick next year or multiple 2nd round picks


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

No thanks.

 

[ROORAGE]

Id take treloar for sure. He Dominates

Sure, he butchers the ball but so does most of our team. Would be a great addition

No question he can find the footy, but I just don't like the bloke. Strikes me as an arrogant arseh*le who just expects to walk into a successful team without doing any of the hard yards. I've seen or heard nothing that makes me think otherwise. Downhill skiier. We're already carrying Hall and Polec don't want another.

 

[Agenda 21]

Not at 900k he’s not

Out of curiosity, what would our top 3 earners be getting, and how old are they?

 

[shinboner magic]

Out of curiosity, what would our top 3 earners be getting, and how old are they?

You’d think cunners , Goldy and either taz or Jack
Ask their accountants

 

[Agenda 21]

You’d think cunners , Goldy and either taz or Jack
Ask their accountants

So, four blokes over 30 getting the biggest coin?
Fair enough.

 

[shinboner magic]

So, four blokes over 30 getting the biggest coin?
Fair enough.

Yeah we really need to to have replacements ready to go for taz and goldy.
Be it through draft or trade

 

[giantroo]

The Bombers have the threat of walking Caldwell to the pre-season draft if a deal can't be met, but that would rely on other clubs – including North Melbourne and Hawthorn – not jumping in first.

Pay up, Dons: GWS wants first-round pick for mid who's 'ready to explode'

GWS list manager Jason McCartney has made it clear what the club wants in return for Jye Caldwell

www.afl.com.au

 

[Agenda 21]

The Bombers have the threat of walking Caldwell to the pre-season draft if a deal can't be met, but that would rely on other clubs – including North Melbourne and Hawthorn – not jumping in first.

Pay up, Dons: GWS wants first-round pick for mid who's 'ready to explode'

GWS list manager Jason McCartney has made it clear what the club wants in return for Jye Caldwell

www.afl.com.au

Yeah. We're jumping in first, banana heaDodoro.

 

[Hojuman]

Daniher - " we demand players, a 1st round draft pick and compensation ! "

Saad - " we demand 2 x 1st round draft picks ! "

Fantasia - " we demand players, 1st round draft pick and compensation ! "

" GWS want what for Caldwell ? That's outrageous "

 

[ChoppyGun]

Id take treloar for sure. He Dominates

Sure, he butchers the ball but so does most of our team. Would be a great addition

Getting Treloar would go completely against what we are trying to do.

Definite no to Treloar.

 

[Merlin007]

Daniher - " we demand players, a 1st round draft pick and compensation ! "

Saad - " we demand 2 x 1st round draft picks ! "

Fantasia - " we demand players, 1st round draft pick and compensation ! "

" GWS want what for Caldwell ? That's outrageous "

Do as I say, not what I do

 

[ChoppyGun]

No question he can find the footy, but I just don't like the bloke. Strikes me as an arrogant a-hole who just expects to walk into a successful team without doing any of the hard yards. I've seen or heard nothing that makes me think otherwise. Downhill skiier. We're already carrying Hall and Polec don't want another.

He's too old and takes a spot from a younger player.

Not part of our future team, it's as simple as that.

 

[Waussie]

I read it as
North get: 20 and 2021 Geelong 2nd
Cats get: Higgins and 28

How magnanimous.

Happy to pay 11% of his salary.

We take Treloer, we give you Bonar, Hayden or WW 1 off
Mags pay $350k of Treleors Salary year 1, $250k year 2 and $150k year 3

Just a thought

 

[Waussie]

And that is fair enough
Edit: After all the McDonald name has a strong legacy at the club

L Mac 2

 

[muttley45]

We take Treloer, we give you Bonar, Hayden or WW 1 off
Mags pay $350k of Treleors Salary year 1, $250k year 2 and $150k year 3

Just a thought

What are you doing shopping Kyron off Waussie ?

 

[Waussie]

Treloar and Stephenson for the Higgins and Brown picks (assuming both will be mid to late second round). Pay the full salary to get it done. 2 out 2 in. Not exactly like for like but two best 22 players for the next 5 years. Treloar would be a great support for LDU, Simpkin and Holland’s. With Anderson, Goldie and Cunnington it’s a formidable midfield. Certainly not bottom 2 as everyone thinks. Stephenson, Thomas, Zurhar, Garner, Taylor, Larkey Comben and Mahoney forwards. Dumont, Scott, W.Walker and Polec as wingmen. Lmac, Perez, hayden off half back. Taz, Corr Walker as the bigs. I am pumped to see that team live next year. Win or lose it’s exciting times.

I'm. B Mac?

 

[Waussie]

What are you doing shopping Kyron off Waussie ?

You have to make the trade look interesting, no hard feelings

 

[Waussie]

So, four blokes over 30 getting the biggest coin?
Fair enough.

Polec

 

[Agenda 21]

Polec

He still there, is he?

 

[The Nostradamus]

The Bombers have the threat of walking Caldwell to the pre-season draft if a deal can't be met, but that would rely on other clubs – including North Melbourne and Hawthorn – not jumping in first.

Pay up, Dons: GWS wants first-round pick for mid who's 'ready to explode'

GWS list manager Jason McCartney has made it clear what the club wants in return for Jye Caldwell

www.afl.com.au

lol now we capitalise on dodos incompetence

Caldwell for free