2020 Trade & List Management discussion

[Thetrader15]

No, Hately is included in the 36.

We currently have 31 on our senior list. Hately makes 32. 4x ND selections makes 36.

I hope we go with our 5 selections inside the first 35 picks (40 will come in) and Borlase. Rookie Edwards and Newchurch or match if inside what is currently pick 40.

Would be strange if we passed on a 2nd rounder.

 

[Thetrader15]

based on what we have been able to see to date, Borlace looks like the biggest improver and is absolutely worth a list spot as a developing quality defender. They must be fairly sure Newchurch is a long way back and won't get a bid and likewise Edwards, they would be thinking he is unlikely to attract a lot of interest in this draft with a low number of picks expected to be used

I'd have rather be in a position to match a ND bid on Newchurch / Edwards and not risk him going as a rookie than signing a 32yo to the main list when he is no threat of going anywhere else.

 

[Crow_68]

So 5AA say we will match bids on Borlase. But leave Newchurch to the rookie draft. Edwards to go into open draft. Nominations to be completed by next week.

Every chance Edwards has been given guarantees elsewhere, ones we weren’t prepared to match.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Mismatched]

So 5AA say we will match bids on Borlase. But leave Newchurch to the rookie draft. Edwards to go into open draft. Nominations to be completed by next week.

Thats basically my feel as to what will happen.

Newchurch has talent, but what from what he’s put on the board he’s a long way off and a rookie spot makes sense.

Borlase looks a really solid KPD prospect moving forward. With Hartigan gone and Talia in his twilight, takes pressure off the development of McAsey/Butts/Worrell, also gives us options to swing McAsey/Worrell forward.

Edwards has seemed a long shot for a while, doesn’t look a massive loss either at this stage.

 

[Carmo]

Has there been any comment from Drugs Are Bad Mackay? about delisting / trading the blonde rinse boys this year (Knight / Atkins)?

Does he approve of this important list management aspect?

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Has there been any comment from Drugs Are Bad Mackay? about delisting / trading the blonde rinse boys this year (Knight / Atkins)?

Does he approve of this important list management aspect?

Let it be a lesson to the rest of them!

We'll know when preseason training resumes and the pics appear on the AFC Facebook page if the squad has its mind on the job this year.

 

[BACCS]

 

[Carmo]

FWIW I reckon many are underrating Edwards. Seems a taller clone of his old man, super composed, always has time, good vision, takes tight situations and turns them comfortable, good enough disposal, balanced in terms of hands and feet, ok overhead, low center of gravity for his height. Will be a pity for us to miss him but understand if he goes in the open draft and considering the picks we have and spots available.

 

[Thetrader15]

FWIW I reckon many are underrating Edwards. Seems a taller clone of his old man, super composed, always has time, good vision, takes tight situations and turns them comfortable, good enough disposal, balanced in terms of hands and feet, ok overhead, low center of gravity for his height. Will be a pity for us to miss him but understand if he goes in the open draft and considering the picks we have and spots available.

From a playing perspective, there should be no reason not to list him.

Then match bids based on where they come, but outside of 23, it should be a no brainer IMO.

No superstar, but a solid McPherson type we get for below market value.

 

[Golumless]

FWIW I reckon many are underrating Edwards. Seems a taller clone of his old man, super composed, always has time, good vision, takes tight situations and turns them comfortable, good enough disposal, balanced in terms of hands and feet, ok overhead, low center of gravity for his height. Will be a pity for us to miss him but understand if he goes in the open draft and considering the picks we have and spots available.

Yeah, I thought he looked like a solid prospect in the youth game that was on a month or so back. Nothing flashy, but looked a very industrious midfielder/half back.

I'm hopeful we do rookie him, but it wouldn't surprise me if he goes in the mid-season draft if he can get midfield time at Glenelg.

 

[MRB37]

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

From a playing perspective, there should be no reason not to list him.

Then match bids based on where they come, but outside of 23, it should be a no brainer IMO.

No superstar, but a solid McPherson type we get for below market value.

You would think we would list him rather than going 1 short on the list with no cap pressure.

 

[1970crow]

Every chance Edwards has been given guarantees elsewhere, ones we weren’t prepared to match.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

We don't get to match if we don't nominate him and him accept it though. I think that's how it works.

 

[1970crow]

Has there been any comment from Drugs Are Bad Mackay? about delisting / trading the blonde rinse boys this year (Knight / Atkins)?

Does he approve of this important list management aspect?

More importantly we've cleansed ourselves of all our sleeves.

 

[Comeonden]

More importantly we've cleansed ourselves of all our sleeves.

Seedsman?

 

[crows dude]

We don't get to match if we don't nominate him and him accept it though. I think that's how it works.

Correct

 

[SaltPeter]

Seedsman?

+ Gibbs and Atkins .. though i think it's more about Crocker and Gallucci (no sure if calf tatts count as sleeves?)

 

[1970crow]

Seedsman?

Sleeve tattoos.

 

[Crowked]

So when does Edwards have to nominate as a FS or not?

 

[MRB37]

So when does Edwards have to nominate as a FS or not?

Think it was today.

 

[Mutineer]

So when does Edwards have to nominate as a FS or not?

Key dates for the 2020 NAB AFL Draft Period:

Wednesday 25 November
• List Lodgement 1
• Nomination of Draft Eligible Father/Son Players Lodged
• Nomination of Draft Eligible Northern & NGA Academy Players Lodged

Thursday 26 November
• AFL Delisted Player Free Agency Period (1) Commences

Sunday 29 November
• AFL Delisted Player Free Agency Period (1) Closes

Monday 30 November
• List Lodgement 2
• Out of Contract Listed AFL Primary List Players Draft Nomination Form and Player Request for Removal from List Form Lodged with AFL
• Final date for Primary List delistings

Tuesday 1 December
• AFL Delisted Player Free Agency Period (2) Commences

Wednesday 2 December
• AFL Delisted Player Free Agency Period (2) Closes

Thursday 3 December
• AFL Trade Period Closes – Selections Only
• Delisted Primary List Draft Nomination Form Lodgement
• Non–Retained Rookie Players Draft Nomination Form Lodgement
• Final Draft Nomination Form Lodgement
• AFL Father-Son Bidding Nominations lodged with AFL

Wednesday December 9 at 7.00pm AEDT
• NAB AFL Draft

Thursday December 10 at 12.00pm AEDT
• NAB AFL Pre-Season & Rookie Draft

 

[Red mist]

boring

I’m glad I’m not entertaining. It’s not the point. But you snacking on it is ok,

 

[Red mist]

22, 23 should go to next year.

 

[Sanders]

They were unders deals to move them on , same has happened this off season with Hartigan

this is a deliberate and deep rebuild

no, Jeff. No

 

[Sanders]

FWIW I reckon many are underrating Edwards. Seems a taller clone of his old man, super composed, always has time, good vision, takes tight situations and turns them comfortable, good enough disposal, balanced in terms of hands and feet, ok overhead, low center of gravity for his height. Will be a pity for us to miss him but understand if he goes in the open draft and considering the picks we have and spots available.

a taller clone of his old man gets a lot more attention than this scrub is