Discussion 2021 Player X v Y v Z

[A Bit Dusty]

Do you have a 0 premo forward line? Gawndy, 6 deep defence, guessing 4 or 5 mids. Wtf man

Yes mate pretty much I am loading up in defence this year. Every year I get caught out down there not this year 6 premo's if you include Zilliams.
Oliver,Adams,Cripps,Rowell,Taranto & Atkins midfield. Gawndy Ruck and I have the 4 cheap forward Brown,Ziebell,Daniher,Impey with a couple of rookies.

 

[ImissFrosty]

Yes mate pretty much I am loading up in defence this year. Every year I get caught out down there not this year 6 premo's if you include Zilliams.
Oliver,Adams,Cripps,Rowell,Taranto & Atkins midfield. Gawndy Ruck and I have the 4 cheap forward Brown,Ziebell,Daniher,Impey with a couple of rookies.

View attachment 1045160

Pretty sick dude, i think the defenders are so stacked this year and the kick in rules will help plus we've got Laird and Zilliams who are now full time midfielders and the forwards are trash past Marshall and maybe Dunkley. Imma try it with Preuss and load up the guts too.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Pretty sick dude, i think the defenders are so stacked this year and the kick in rules will help plus we've got Laird and Zilliams who are now full time midfielders and the forwards are trash past Marshall and maybe Dunkley. Imma try it with Preuss and load up the guts too.

The forwards are really hard to tell this year. Even though there are guns down there none of them have any real certainty of scoring big because we don't really know what positions they will play. Danger? Sidebum? Dunkley? Marshall 2nd Ruck? I am going to take a chance this year and hopefully start upgrading the forwards rounds 5-6 when we know what positions they are playing and I can't see their prices going up much but could drop a fair bit.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Lloyd and Laird

Or

Oliver and Laird

 

[Northernsoul74]

Lloyd and Laird

Or

Oliver and Laird

Assuming Laird is on your def line. I’d look at it like this, if you don’t go Lloyd who comes in instead. if you don’t go Oliver who comes in instead.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Assuming Laird is on your def line. I’d look at it like this, if you don’t go Lloyd who comes in instead. if you don’t go Oliver who comes in instead.

It's either going to be Laird in DEF and Oliver in MIDS or Laird in MIDS and Lloyd in DEF.

 

[Significant]

It's either going to be Laird in DEF and Oliver in MIDS or Laird in MIDS and Lloyd in DEF.

so why didn't you just say Oliver v Lloyd?
Oliver btw

 

[Judd_Magic]

so why didn't you just say Oliver v Lloyd?
Oliver btw

Just wanted to see if Laird being back or mid would change anyones mind in which one of Lloyd or Oliver that I should pick I guess.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Simpkin or Taranto?

 

[Flandersss]

Simpkin or Taranto?

Simpkin.
Reckon he will go 105-110 imo

Taranto 100-105

 

[Judd_Magic]

Simpkin.
Reckon he will go 105-110 imo

Taranto 100-105

I'd like both but can only choose 1 and kinda leaning towards Simpkin now.

Cheers mate.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Simpkin or Taranto?

Started with Simpkin last year and it was a hell of a ride. I tried to trade him out a couple of times but had other problem areas so kept him. The 144 in the last round helped ease the pain but I wouldn't pick him as a sole midfielder especially as Higgo isn't there anymore if opposition teams want to tag.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Started with Simpkin last year and it was a hell of a ride. I tried to trade him out a couple of times but had other problem areas so kept him. The 144 in the last round helped ease the pain but I wouldn't pick him as a sole midfielder especially as Higgo isn't there anymore if opposition teams want to tag.

Cunnington is back though so surely he gets the tag over Simpkin?

 

[ImissFrosty]

Cunnington is back though so surely he gets the tag over Simpkin?

Plus why would teams tag north? Simpkin isn't going to save them.

 

[ImissFrosty]

Cerra $484k vs Simpkin $499k vs McCluggage $545k

 

[Judd_Magic]

Cerra $484k vs Simpkin $499k vs McCluggage $545k

Simpkin

 

[THECHIEFTON]

Grundy/Ziebell/Rookie or Pruess/T.Phillips/Milera.

 

[Flandersss]

Grundy/Ziebell/Rookie or Pruess/T.Phillips/Milera.

1st option

 

[A Bit Dusty]

1st option

Agree
Pruess/T.Phillips/Milera are like the 3 ugly sisters they get you off at the start but a week later you realised it wasn't a good idea after what they did to your chol

 

[blueiris]

Cerra $484k vs Simpkin $499k vs McCluggage $545k

The Suitcase

 

[Flandersss]

Agree
Pruess/T.Phillips/Milera are like the 3 ugly sisters they get you off at the start but a week later you realised it wasn't a good idea after what they did to your chol

Could go either way:

Preuss 85
Phillips 88
Milera 90 (if fit)

 

[blueiris]

Yes mate pretty much I am loading up in defence this year. Every year I get caught out down there not this year 6 premo's if you include Zilliams.
Oliver,Adams,Cripps,Rowell,Taranto & Atkins midfield. Gawndy Ruck and I have the 4 cheap forward Brown,Ziebell,Daniher,Impey with a couple of rookies.

View attachment 1045160

Disagree defence is the easiest to upgrade last year I had my top 6 by round 8

 

[Santoz]

Grundy/Ziebell/Rookie or Pruess/T.Phillips/Milera.

But swap Phillips out for some campaigner that can get a kick

 

[Flandersss]

Pick 2:
Walsh v Rowell v Simpkin v Taranto

Stewart v McDonald v Docherty v Zilliams v Witherden

 

[Santoz]

Pick 2:
Walsh v Rowell v Simpkin v Taranto

Stewart v McDonald v Docherty v Zilliams v Witherden

Walsh or Rowell.

Stewart or Two Dogs.

Whichever of those suits your byes.