Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[A Bit Dusty]

Kemp seems likely to play, 3rd year player vs 1st year.

And you save $1,000.00

I don't think Kemp will be best 22

 

[Andrew Birch]

I don't think Kemp will be best 22

Maybe not for the whole year, but early rounds he probably will.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

I don't think Kemp will be best 22

Who knows.

I read a few pages on the Carlton board and they were talking like he was a lock, weren't even debating him.

What makes you think he won't play?

 

[weltschmerz]

I have both Kemp and Sinn.

 

[Mofra]

I have both Kemp and Sinn.

I am currently without Sinn meaning I can throw the first stone.


I'll see myself out...

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Who knows.

I read a few pages on the Carlton board and they were talking like he was a lock, weren't even debating him.

What makes you think he won't play?

I think if McGovern goes down back he probably misses out and Marchbank also to come back in.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

I think if McGovern goes down back he probably misses out and Marchbank also to come back in.

Different types of players/roles though aren't they?

Kemp was talked up as a big bodied mid, now playing in defense to ease him into AFL footy.

Marchbank is more a defensive player. Gov jr is a lazy lump who will be out injured most of the season anyway.

 

[Andrew Birch]

I think if McGovern goes down back he probably misses out and Marchbank also to come back in.

I think Marchbank is still a while back but McGovern could possibly take that spot. Would make the Blues Def a lot slower though as Kemp is reasonably quick from what I've seen of him last year.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Different types of players/roles though aren't they?

Kemp was talked up as a big bodied mid, now playing in defense to ease him into AFL footy.

Marchbank is more a defensive player. Gov jr is a lazy lump who will be out injured most of the season anyway.

Nice way to ease him in Round 1 against Lynch,Reiwoldt and Dusty. 193cm and 81kg I hope your right

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Nice way to ease him in Round 1 against Lynch,Reiwoldt and Dusty. 193cm and 81kg I hope your right

I couldn't care less who wins the game, just as long as he has a good SC score.

Will riewoldt be using a walking frame?

 

[JuddgementDay]

I don't think Kemp will be best 22

IMO CFC will try to get as many games into Kemp as possible, most likely in defense - but, he can play anywhere

 

[VainGlorious]

I read a few pages on the Carlton board

There’s your first mistake.

 

[VainGlorious]

I couldn't care less who wins the game, just as long as he has a good SC score.

Will riewoldt be using a walking frame?

Not sure about a walking frame, but he looked in ripping nick at the Tigs pre-season dance comp

 

[Flandersss]

Petracca, MCrouch & DeGoey (330)
V
Oliver, Titch & Coleman (315)

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Petracca, MCrouch & DeGoey (330)
V
Oliver, Titch & Coleman (315)

Petracca, MCrouch & DeGoey

 

[MacStradbroke]

Petracca, MCrouch & DeGoey

Yeah I like the Degoey and Trac picks. Petracca not getting much love to date on these boards. The man is a star.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Ok guys, risky either way but pick one

BTW - neither is not an option


Crisp, Witts and Berry
Vs
Gawn/ Darcy, Cripps, Milera (assumed fit)

 

[Duckworthy]

For those weighing up the North TT (not the giants one), not sure what this means other than he's not playing for a contract this season

 

[rocker_oz33]

Yeah I like the Degoey and Trac picks. Petracca not getting much love to date on these boards. The man is a star.

Tracc good value @600k.

Had him in.

Then swapped to Larid them Mitchell.

Unsure on which one.

Throw pansy face mills into the mix.

Lkke shooting fish in a Barrell...

 

[Kadog]

Petracca, MCrouch & DeGoey (330)
V
Oliver, Titch & Coleman (315)

Oliver TMitch Coleman

 

[Kadog]

Ok guys, risky either way but pick one

BTW - neither is not an option


Crisp, Witts and Berry
Vs
Gawn/ Darcy, Cripps, Milera (assumed fit)

Darcy Cripps Milera

 

[Kadog]

Oliver/JHF v Cripps/Butters

 

[Skipper_]

Sicily and Curnow vs Hall and rookie

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Sicily and Curnow vs Hall and rookie

Depends on the rookie. If it's a forward rookie probably Sic-dawg and Curnow.

Forward rookies are usually terrible.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Oliver/JHF v Cripps/Butters

I like the more risky, but value based option
So Cripps/Butters