Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[A Bit Dusty]

Dumplings please.
Berry has been playing wing. yuck
Minge is a trap IMO. Not a great scorer in the past.

Yep Minge has Mange avoid

 

[JuddgementDay]

JDG he is needed in the Pies mids.
Heeney isnt as much.
+ Heeney always gets his injuries when he is on 40 sc.

Yeah I get where you are coming from with JDG, but Heeney is getting that elusive mid time

Actually, he was playing injured all of last year and this year is coming in fit - so I'm still leaning towards Heeney.
It's just a matter of trust

 

[VainGlorious]

Minge is a trap IMO.

Don’t I know it brother

 

[King Max]

Thoughts on best F3….
Heeney (who I’m swinging more too) Butters or JDG.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Thoughts on best F3….
Heeney (who I’m swinging more too) Butters or JDG.

I like Butters (F2) but it’s just a gut feeling. I think any of them will be solid at their price. Rayner is my F3.

 

[MacStradbroke]

Dumplings please.
Berry has been playing wing. yuck
Minge is a trap IMO. Not a great scorer in the past.

Minge is a trap…stop it!

 

[weltschmerz]

Kemp or Erasmus? I'd be moving Crisp into the midfield if I want Kemp, or keeping him in the backline if I keep Erasmus.

 

[buttox]

Kemp or Erasmus? I'd be moving Crisp into the midfield if I want Kemp, or keeping him in the backline if I keep Erasmus.

To hard to say until pre season.
Erasmus seems the better player IMO.

 

[JuddgementDay]

To hard to say until pre season.
Erasmus seems the better player IMO.

You are under selling Kemp.

We haven’t seen much of him due to injuries, but he has the tools and will play plenty of games IMO

 

[buttox]

You are under selling Kemp.

We haven’t seen much of him due to injuries, but he has the tools and will play plenty of games IMO

After being pick 17.
Erasmus was pick 10
Kemp has not shown anything in 2 years.
It is underselling Erasmus to say it is even close.
my 2c.

 

[weltschmerz]

You are under selling Kemp.

We haven’t seen much of him due to injuries, but he has the tools and will play plenty of games IMO

What role do you think Kemp will be playing? Erasmus seems likely to be a centre bounce midfielder which is SC-friendly.

 

[JuddgementDay]

View attachment 1324389
After being pick 17.
Erasmus was pick 10
Kemp has not shown anything in 2 years.
It is underselling Erasmus to say it is even close.
my 2c.

We’ll see!

1st year player vs let’s say 2nd year player (3rd actually, but has been injured)

 

[JuddgementDay]

What role do you think Kemp will be playing? Erasmus seems likely to be a centre bounce midfielder which is SC-friendly.

I haven’t followed Freo closely, would Erasmus be in their best 22 and will he be straight into the midfield?

Kemp will likely play in defence

 

[Obese Arachnid]

View attachment 1324389
After being pick 17.
Erasmus was pick 10
Kemp has not shown anything in 2 years.
It is underselling Erasmus to say it is even close.
my 2c.

Have to say that 2022 season doesn't fill me with confidence.

 

[buttox]

Have to say that 2022 season doesn't fill me with confidence.

Yep if you go premium over at tooserious they tell you this years scores.
LOL

 

[Fisheroo]

Apologies if already discussed..

Kiddy vs Rioli?

Leaning towards Kiddy at this early stage because a) cheaper and b) has last bye allowing upgrade to any from the earlier byes.

 

[kananooks]

Apologies if already discussed..

Kiddy vs Rioli?

Leaning towards Kiddy at this early stage because a) cheaper and b) has last bye allowing upgrade to any from the earlier byes.

id go with rioli tbh. guaranteed more time on the ball imo.

danger vs brayshaw?

 

[Fisheroo]

id go with rioli tbh. guaranteed more time on the ball imo.

danger vs brayshaw?

I prefer Danger - less susceptible to a tag given that Bray is now the number 1 tagging option in that Midfield.
I also think Danger is a good chance of getting M/F eligibility, if he does he'll be close to the #1 SC forward.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

id go with rioli tbh. guaranteed more time on the ball imo.

danger vs brayshaw?

Andy Bray is improving, Danger is not.

 

[weltschmerz]

Crisp or Ridley?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Andy Bray is improving, Danger is not.

That's been my thinking ....hence why Andy Bray is in my side ....TOG improved last year, future Capt ....so he'll put his best foot fwd

5 from first 8 games at home ....so great opening run of games for Andy

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

That's been my thinking ....hence why Andy Bray is in my side ....TOG improved last year, future Capt ....so he'll put his best foot fwd

5 from first 8 games at home ....so great opening run of games for Andy

I like Brayshaw as a pick, but I want to see how he goes minus Cerra and with Fyfe and Mundy fading. Seems too obvious for oppo coaches to shut him down. I want to see him push through the tag's that are coming first.

Think there are better options for not many more $. But this question was Danger vs Bray, so Brayshaw in that case.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I like Brayshaw as a pick, but I want to see how he goes minus Cerra and with Fyfe and Mundy fading. Seems too obvious for oppo coaches to shut him down. I want to see him push through the tag's that are coming first.

Think there are better options for not many more $. But this question was Danger vs Bray, so Brayshaw in that case.

The other option was Jelly ...... we talk about too many mouths to feed at the Bullies .....and here we have Andy Brayshaw, the only one in the soup-line

He can have seconds at FREO

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

The other option was Jelly ...... we talk about too many mouths to feed at the Bullies .....and here we have Andy Brayshaw, the only one in the soup-line

He can have seconds at FREO

Just imo but you need to find some more cash and get a Walsh/Titch. Much safer picks than those two. But you do you brother

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Just imo but you need to find some more cash and get a Walsh/Titch. Much safer picks than those two. But you do you brother

Haven't got Jelly, or Danger ATM .....have Walsh over Titch ...and Brayshaw as a POD