Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Andrewy]

Danger / Long (bench) vs Dusty / Hobbs (field).

Pretty keen on Danger but it means Hobbs to a bencher.
Any thoughts?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Danger / Long (bench) vs Dusty / Hobbs (field).

Pretty keen on Danger but it means Hobbs to a bencher.
Any thoughts?

Neither tbh.

Rather Duncan if you must around that price.

 

[Andrew Birch]

This is going to do my head in right up until Rd1

2 of

De Goey v Tarryn v Heeney v Butters

 

[VainGlorious]

This is going to go my head in right up until Rd1

2 of

De Goey v Tarryn v Heeney v Butters

Im going Heeney and Butters, so you should definitely go the other two.

 

[MacStradbroke]

This is going to go my head in right up until Rd1

2 of

De Goey v Tarryn v Heeney v Butters

Degoey > Butters > Thomas > Heeney, with no confidence whatsoever. Will attempt to only start one, probably Degoey pending practice matches. Heeney too up and down, frustrates the crap out me as an owner, pity coz he is super to watch. Rather start an additional defender if possible. (Worked well last year)

 

[JuddgementDay]

This is going to go my head in right up until Rd1

2 of

De Goey v Tarryn v Heeney v Butters

Cripps > Heeney > Tarryn > JDG > Butters

Thank me later

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

This is going to go my head in right up until Rd1

2 of

De Goey v Tarryn v Heeney v Butters

Reckon you've got them in the right order.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Reckon you've got them in the right order.

I’d reverse it but I’m sure I’m in the minority. I can make a case for all of them.

 

[DaTBird187]

This is going to go my head in right up until Rd1

2 of

De Goey v Tarryn v Heeney v Butters

I have three of these four.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

This is going to go my head in right up until Rd1

2 of

De Goey v Tarryn v Heeney v Butters

I have no idea myself .....PS games I think

With Mills in doubt, surely Heeney is a walk up start as a Mid ......and for me, it's a toss between Butters / Degoey .....Butters maybe the more SC friendly game if he can breakout

 

[A Bit Dusty]

I have no idea myself .....PS games I think

With Mills in doubt, surely Heeney is a walk up start as a Mid ......and for me, it's a toss between Butters / Degoey .....Butters maybe the more SC friendly game if he can breakout

IMO Heeney is a natural forward and when he did go in the middle last year he looked lost a bit. I'm not saying he will score terrible but I wouldn't be expecting much either.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

IMO Heeney is a natural forward and when he did go in the middle last year he looked lost a bit. I'm not saying he will score terrible but I wouldn't be expecting much either.

Heeney played mainly Wing in the backend of the season, and still played the season with that suspect ankle .....he's in the right age-group now, and he's too good, not to breakout soon

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Heeney played mainly Wing in the backend of the season, and still played the season with that suspect ankle .....he's in the right age-group now, and he's too good, not to breakout soon

I had him the last few rounds last year and as soon as he went out of the forward line he looked lost as soon as he went forward he was a different player.

 

[weltschmerz]

Ridley, Short, or Dawson?

 

[MacStradbroke]

Ridley, Short, or Dawson?

That order

 

[MacStradbroke]

Duncan/Rook(McGuiness) v Degoey/Curnow?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Duncan/Rook(McGuiness) v Degoey/Curnow?

Degoey/Curnow

 

[TempletonTheRat]

This is going to do my head in right up until Rd1

2 of

De Goey v Tarryn v Heeney v Butters

I'm starting to warm to Heeney as being first picked from this group; I trust him the most to give me a full season of consistent output.

 

[Seymour Skinner]

This is going to do my head in right up until Rd1

2 of

De Goey v Tarryn v Heeney v Butters

DeGoey & Butters.

 

[Duckworthy]

This is going to do my head in right up until Rd1

2 of

De Goey v Tarryn v Heeney v Butters

De Goey & Heeney if they both have clear runs into the start of the season

 

[Dark Sharks]

Peeney is going to suck many in, probably play mid in the Wizard cup and post a mammoth score.

Then he'll come out round 1 and play MID/FWD and score 132. Round 2 he'll back it up with a 103 with a small stint through the midfield. Looks a FWD premo.


Round 3 he'll get injured playing deep forward for a score of 18.

He'll come back in round 9 playing deep forward again and score 60.



His midfield stint is now over. He is also cheaper than his starting price after his inevitable injury.

This is the way of the world.

 

[buttox]

This is going to do my head in right up until Rd1

2 of

De Goey v Tarryn v Heeney v Butters

Tarryn and Degoey.
I don't mind Heeney as a pick.
I'm a bit uncertain about Butters return from injury.

 

[Flandersss]

This is going to do my head in right up until Rd1

2 of

De Goey v Tarryn v Heeney v Butters

Thomas & Heeney

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Dunkley and 123.9k forward

Vs

De goey and curnow

 

[Duckworthy]

Dunkley and 123.9k forward

Vs

De goey and curnow

Forwards @ $123k are pretty poor, so probably not that one.

Bench cover only at this stage. See what the next few weeks uncovers, if anything