Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[A Bit Dusty]

I am debating this too.

Can you loop them?

JHF to ton up tonight

 

[No eye deer]

So I suppose I should take Nods score. That leaves me having to field one of SDK and Hinge.
Which one?
Toss a coin?
Field both and leave Nods score on the bench?

 

[marcmurphy3]

So I suppose I should take Nods score. That leaves me having to field one of SDK and Hinge.
Which one?
Toss a coin?
Field both and leave Nods score on the bench?

NOD and Hinge

 

[PoopingHindi]

So I suppose I should take Nods score. That leaves me having to field one of SDK and Hinge.
Which one?
Toss a coin?
Field both and leave Nods score on the bench?

I’d field both.
I don’t think there’s much more than 10 points in the NOD/SDK decision either way but Hinge is a definite starter.

 

[Jiska]

Crisp vs Sicily

 

[Soggy2112]

Crisp vs Sicily

Crisp but I don’t think you can go wrong either way

 

[JuddgementDay]

Crisp vs Sicily

 

[Soggy2112]

Petracca vs Brayshaw

 

[toxic]

Petracca vs Brayshaw

Which Bray?

 

[Soggy2112]

Which Bray?

Andrew haha, deciding on a mid upgrade for round 9

 

[toxic]

Andrew haha, deciding on a mid upgrade for round 9

Bray

 

[Petrify]

Parish vs Andy Brayshaw vs Boak

 

[AjsGuns]

Brayshaw vs Mills vs Laird for M8 (will wait if Mills to use his 60 for price drop) - who will avg the most for the rest of the season? Leaning towards Brayshaw.

 

[marcmurphy3]

Brayshaw vs Mills vs Laird for M8 (will wait if Mills to use his 60 for price drop) - who will avg the most for the rest of the season? Leaning towards Brayshaw.

Mills > Laird > Brayshaw

Brayshaw is a good player but think Mills and Lairds game is better suited to SC.

 

[Dundalis]

Dawson v Cumming

 

[stevebbb]

Dawson v Cumming

Dawson.
Better bye, cheaper, and scoring should be similar. Actually think Dawson can top him from here, just. Both will go 105 or more

 

[stevebbb]

Parish vs Andy Brayshaw vs Boak

Not Boak. Started last year like a house on fire as well, then dropped off.
Though if Port start winning (Dixon back soon will help), he should keep scoring well.
But yeah, age factor is scary.

Parish for me.

 

[Scythe]

Need to pick a D6 under $578k (already have Doc, Short, Sicily, Hewett, Crisp), and it can't be a r12 bye player (so no Cumming or Sinclair). Leaves Pendles, Dale, Dawson, Zorko as the main options. Any of those stand out above the rest?

 

[stevebbb]

Need to pick a D6 under $578k (already have Doc, Short, Sicily, Hewett, Crisp), and it can't be a r12 bye player (so no Cumming or Sinclair). Leaves Pendles, Dale, Dawson, Zorko as the main options. Any of those stand out above the rest?

Dale and Dawson, just take the oldies out of it

Both should go around 105, maybe even push 110

Flip a coin?

Dawson if I had to choose, price is great

 

[NMxrkxdxs]

Doch vs Sicily

 

[SC fish]

Doch vs Sicily

Both are decent picks I'd get the one that suits your byes best

 

[weltschmerz]

Carroll or Hamilton?

 

[Gene Simmons]

Cumming v Zorko v Dawson for D5

 

[stevebbb]

Carroll or Hamilton?

I think their JS is similar. Both should stick around if they keep playing well, but both have competition for spots.

Carroll has a higher ceiling, he's a bigger accumulator and plays closer to goal.
Hamilton is not an accumulator, but likes a tackle.

I reckon it comes down to DPP and price. Does the DPP help you? Does the $20k saved help you?

I'm assuming they both play this week of course (against each other mind you).

 

[Soggy2112]

Doch vs Sicily

Can’t go wrong but I’d go Docherty, simply because we’ve seen this level of scoring from him before and know he can maintain it so I have slightly more confidence in him.