Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dawson vs Lloyd

Dawson = $573,400 to spend on a mid premo
Lloyd = $613,300 to spend on a mid premo


Wines vs Bazlenka vs Brayshaw vs Bont vs other
Dawson, great draw late.

Wines or Brayshaw both cheap so best bye. Bont if if you think he will get dpp.
 
Who is more of a forward keeper out of Lipinski and Cameron?

Looking at a cheap forward keeper for N.Martin next week.
Neither of them are keepers.

I’ve got Lipinski, but he’ll leave my team post his bye

Cameron - is a value proposition & not to keep
 

BFMC

Senior List
Mar 22, 2021
277
620
Geelong
AFL Club
Essendon
Wines (m8) and Heeney (f2)
vs
Bont (m7) and Cameron (f5) + 60k

Option 1 inspires more confidence (unless Heeney decides to go back to doing Heeney things). Camerons not a keeper IMO and Bont isnt a certainty to get DPP/how many dogs players can we fit into one side, they cant all ton up every week.
 
Jun 19, 2016
20,756
39,602
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Compare the pair

Macrae to finish my mids, leaving Rosas/Curtis as my F6

Or

Dunkley to finish my FWDs and leave a Clark type as my M8
Hmm Dunks makes the balance better with Clark at M8.
Going Macrae you could maybe hope for Dunkley to have a couple of down games as he’s playing a fair amount of time forward.
 
Apr 12, 2011
5,336
11,962
Yarraville
AFL Club
Sydney
Hmm Dunks makes the balance better with Clark at M8.
Going Macrae you could maybe hope for Dunkley to have a couple of down games as he’s playing a fair amount of time forward.
Yeah that’s the dilemma for me in a nutshell.

Dunks gives the team better balance but Macrae is only 25k more and will be a 10ppg better scorer, and he won’t be this cheap again.

However the thought of fielding Rosas , MRJ or Curtis makes me want to SPEW up Plough style.
 

BFMC

Senior List
Mar 22, 2021
277
620
Geelong
AFL Club
Essendon
Compare the pair

Macrae to finish my mids, leaving Rosas/Curtis as my F6

Or

Dunkley to finish my FWDs and leave a Clark type as my M8

Dunkley & Clark on face value, but given Macrae/Dunks respective BE's it's actually a tough one. Dunks expected to drop $16k this week but then make most of it back over the next 4 weeks. Probably depends on when you plan on doing the second upgrade.
 

BFMC

Senior List
Mar 22, 2021
277
620
Geelong
AFL Club
Essendon
Just realised im having a similar internal debate....

Bring in Clark, Witts and:

a) Laird and field Hamilton/MRJ, completely lost my FWD DPP link in Mids, or
b) Parker and field Clark, keep DPP mid/fwd link through MRJ/Hamilton
 
Sep 9, 2016
5,945
13,641
AFL Club
Richmond
Sinclair vs Ridley,
Byes don't bother me.

On SM-A226B using BigFooty.com mobile app
Sinclair by miles
Essendon stink this year and besides Parish the rest are hot and cold
I’ve already traded out of the Ridley pick and even though he’s looked decent the last few weeks, playing in that side isn’t helping him

Saints in great form Sinclair looking to get more cbas with Steele out
I think he’s a better pick by 5+ points at minimum from here
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back