List Mgmt. 2022 Trade Thread - Part II

[Mowman]

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/subscribe/news/1/?sourceCode=HSWEB_WRE170_a_GGL&dest=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.heraldsun.com.au%2Fsport%2Fafl%2Fhow-the-big-deals-of-the-afl-trade-period-get-done%2Fnews-story%2F2951594919d68da5cfabb142886a7338&memtype=registered&mode=premium&v21=dynamic-high-control-score&V21spcbehaviour=append

Anyone have access?

Nothing in it

 

[Barrels]

View attachment 1513454

Don’t do meth, kids.

Seriously… meth is bad.

 

[Mowman]

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/subscribe/news/1/?sourceCode=HSWEB_WRE170_a_GGL&dest=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.heraldsun.com.au%2Fsport%2Fafl%2Fhow-the-big-deals-of-the-afl-trade-period-get-done%2Fnews-story%2F2951594919d68da5cfabb142886a7338&memtype=registered&mode=premium&v21=dynamic-high-control-score&V21spcbehaviour=append

Anyone have access?

How the big deals of the AFL trade period get done​

It’s your turn to be an AFL list manager. Check out our verdict on how the major trades of 2022 will get done and then have your say on what each club should swap.

Simeon Thomas-Wilson
Follow

@Simeon_TW

5 min read
September 20, 2022 - 7:21AM
News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom

148 comments




00:41
Denied! Lobb to stay with Fremantle?

AFL: Fremantle has denied Rory Lobb's trade request with the club stating he's a required player in 2023.

AFL​

Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News.
Follow
It is set to be a bumper trade period.
But how will the deals get done?
Players are starting to tell their current clubs of where they would like to play in 2023.
But that is only the start of what is about to happen.
Here are some of the deals that are already underway, and how they might get done.

Josh Dunkley (Western Bulldgos) to Brisbane​

This could be one of the hardest deals to get done.
Dunkley wants to go to the Lions, but Brisbane’s draft hand is going to be a complicated one.
The Lions currently have picks 15, 33, 44 and 69 and could secure second-round compensation for Dan McStay when he joins Collingwood.

But the Lions will need to match picks for father-son prospects Will Ashcroft, who is expected to go No. 1, and Jaspa Fletcher - with a bid likely to come in the teens.
Right now the Lions draft hand gives them 2086 points and if a bid comes in for Ashcroft from North Melbourne at No. 1 they will need 2400 points to take him.
If the Lions get pick 34 for McStay, that plus 15, 33 and 44 would give Brisbane enough points for Ashcroft.
They then need to find points to match a bid for Fletcher and then have a draft hand big enough to get Dunkley.
The Dogs will want more than a first-round pick for Dunkley and the Lions could be in points deficit with their 2023 first-rounder.
The Lions are going to have to get creative and either will have to shed players or split a pick such as 33.
Verdict: Brisbane’s 2023 first-rounder and a 2022 second-round pick either 33 or if it is part of the Ashcroft points haul another that the Lions will have to find.

Dunkley wants to become a Lion. Picture: Daniel Pockett/Getty Images

What gets the Dunkley deal done?​

First-round pick
Two first-round picks
First-round + second-round pick
First-round + a player
Cast your vote

Izak Rankine (Gold Coast) to Adelaide​

The Crows might not want to, but their first round pick looks like it will have to be at the centre of any deal with the Suns for Rankine.
As well as No. 5 the Crows have picks 23 and 77 but they do need to have enough points to secure a father-son prospect of their own in Max Michalanney.
There was hope that the Crows could include Matt Crouch in a deal, but there isn’t the interest from the Suns, so Adelaide will have to cough up picks.
The Suns have access to highly-touted key forward in Jed Walter next year so they might want 2023 picks to secure him in the draft, which could allow the Crows to keep their first pick in this year’s draft.
Either way, it is looking like a first and a second-round pick from the Crows, with the years of those specific picks to be determined, will be what is required to get a deal done.
VERDICT
Option 1: Crows first pick in 2022 (currently 5) and a 2023 second rounder.
Option 2: Crows second round pick in 2022 (currently 23) and first round pick in 2023.

Adelaide will have to strike a deal with Gold Coast for Izak Rankine Picture: Chris Hyde/Getty Images

What gets the Rankine deal done?​

First-round pick
First-round + second-round pick
Two first-round picks
First-round pick + a player
Cast your vote

Luke Jackson (Melbourne) to Fremantle​

Has requested a trade back to Western Australia and while West Coast have the better draft hand, Fremantle are in the box seat to get the young gun ruck/forward.
Melbourne wants two top 10 picks for the 2021 Rising Star winner but right now Fremantle’s first pick is at No. 13.
The Dockers’ next pick is at 72 but their draft hand is set to be bolstered considerably with five players set to depart.
But the Demons are unlikely to want the later picks the Dockers will likely get for some of their fringe players.
They might not get two top 10 picks for Jackson, but the Demons should be able to make Fremantle pay up for the young star.
Verdict: Dockers first-round pick in 2022 (currently 13) and 2023 first-round pick.

Is Jackson worth two top 10 picks? Picture: Dylan Burns/AFL Photos via Getty Images

What gets the Jackson deal done?​

First-round pick
Two first-round picks
First-round + second-round pick
Cast your vote

Brodie Grundy (Collingwood) to Melbourne​

Another tough one, especially since there has been no indication of what Collingwood might want for the gun ruckman.
Grundy is a two-time All-Australian, but the Pies want his big contract off their books so they shouldn’t be able to demand a big haul for Grundy.
It means the Demons could get the 28-year-old at a cut-price deal from a pick perspective, given they will still have to pay some of Grundy’s big salary, despite the haul they should get for Jackson.
Maybe one of the first round picks Fremantle will give the Demons for Jackson could be the best the Pies get, but this might be overs for a player they want off their books.
The Demons do have picks 32, 41, 50, 63, 68, 86 and those first two could be what gets the deal done.
VERDICT
Option 1: Fremantle’s 2023 first-round pick
Option 2: Melbourne’s 2022 second-round pick (currently 32) and third-round pick (41 tied to Adelaide)

What gets Grundy deal done?​

First-round pick
Second-round pick
Two second-round picks
Second-round + third-round pick
Cast your vote

Can the Demons get brodie Grundy for cheap? Picture: Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images

Junior Rioli (West Coast) to Port Adelaide​

The Eagles might be fuming that Rioli wants to go to the Power, despite West Coast standing by him during his two-year suspension for tampering with a urine sample.
But it is a good opportunity for a rebuilding West Coast to get an extra decent draft pick.
The Eagles already have the Power’s second-round pick this year, but Port should get another when Karl Amon goes to Hawthorn as a free agent.
That should be enough to get Rioli to Alberton, with the Eagles premiership player not worth anything more than a second-round pick at 27-years-old.
The Power need a small forward with Robbie Gray and Steven Motlop retired, combined with Orazio Fantasia’s injury issues.
Giving up the pick they get for Amon should be a no-brainer for the Power given this hole on their list.
Verdict: The Karl Amon compensation pick Port Adelaide will receive, likely in the second round.

Junior Rioli is set to end up at Alberton. Picture: Morgan Hancock/Getty Images

What gets the Rioli deal done?​

Amon compensation (likely early second-round)
First-round pick
Second-round pick + a player
Cast your vote

Tim Taranto and Jacob Hopper (GWS) to Richmond​

The Giants want to get two first rounders, and that is just for Hopper let alone a player in Taranto who won GWS’ Kevin Sheedy Medal in 2019.
Hopper is still under contract, which does explain in part the Giants high price, while Taranto is out of contract.
The Tigers have 12, 19 and 30 in this year’s draft but are likely to have to give up more to get the two Giants to Melbourne.
A player might have to head to Sydney, while Richmond’s 2023 first-round pick might have to be on the table.
It is likely going to be a substantial package the Tigers have to stump up to get the two Giants, but they would be thinking it will be worth it.
Verdict: 12, 19 and Richmond’s 2023 first-round pick and a player.

What gets the Taranto + Hopper deal done?​

Two first-round picks
Three first-round picks
Three first-round picks + a player
Three first-round + second-round pick
Two first-round picks + a player
Cast your vote

Tanner Bruhn (GWS) to Geelong​

The 12th pick from the 2020 Draft wants to return to the Geelong region and the Cats should get the young gun without too much trouble.
The Giants are likely to ask for the one first-round pick for Bruhn, who has shown upside as a midfield-forward hybrid.
The Cats first-round pick for this year is at No. 18.
The Giants might try and get the Cats’ first-round pick from next year, and hope Geelong doesn’t make the grand final again.
Verdict: Geelong’s 2023 first-round pick

Bruhn wants to leave the Giants. (Photo by Dylan Burns/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

What gets the Bruhn deal done?​

First-round pick
Second-round pick
Second-round pick + a player
Two second-round picks
Cast your vote


Rory Lobb (Fremantle) to the Western Bulldogs
Lobb needs to convince the Dockers to let him go to the Bulldogs despite a year on his contract.
If he can then it shouldn’t be too hard of a deal for the Bulldogs to get done with a second-round pick, either this years or next years, likely to secure Lobb.
The 2022 selection is at 29 and could slide into the 30s.
But the Dockers will need picks this year to help them get Jackson and this second-round pick could be a valuable one for them.
Verdict: Bulldogs 2022 second-round pick (currently 29).

What gets the Lobb deal done?​

First-round pick
Second-round pick
Third-round pick
Cast your vote

Billy Frampton is out of contract at the Crows. Picture: Getty Images
Billy Frampton (Adelaide) to Collingwood
Frampton wants to go to Collingwood, which would be his third AFL club.
He is out of contract so the Crows are willing to let him go.
This will ease the list squeeze the Crows currently have and would also help them match a bid for Michalanney.
Collingwood has three picks in the third round - 42 (tied to Hawthorn), 47 (tied to the Bulldogs) and 48 (tied to Richmond).

More Coverage​

Trade latest: Dogs’ demands for DunkleyCripps’ ice cold response to Gill’s tribunal crackThe four recruits who will make Pies better in 2023
One of those should get the deal done.

 

[Sun Ra]

We are being strangely secretive about our list management right now.

Why haven't we announced contract extensions that we know have been signed i.e. Campbell, Byrnes, likely Wood?

Clark ?

 

[BrutThough]

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/subscribe/news/1/?sourceCode=HSWEB_WRE170_a_GGL&dest=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.heraldsun.com.au%2Fsport%2Fafl%2Fhow-the-big-deals-of-the-afl-trade-period-get-done%2Fnews-story%2F2951594919d68da5cfabb142886a7338&memtype=registered&mode=premium&v21=dynamic-high-control-score&V21spcbehaviour=append

Anyone have access?

It is set to be a bumper trade period.
But how will the deals get done?

Players are starting to tell their current clubs of where they would like to play in 2023.

But that is only the start of what is about to happen.

Here are some of the deals that are already underway, and how they might get done.

Josh Dunkley (Western Bulldgos) to Brisbane​

This could be one of the hardest deals to get done.

Dunkley wants to go to the Lions, but Brisbane’s draft hand is going to be a complicated one.

The Lions currently have picks 15, 33, 44 and 69 and could secure second-round compensation for Dan McStay when he joins Collingwood.

But the Lions will need to match picks for father-son prospects Will Ashcroft, who is expected to go No. 1, and Jaspa Fletcher - with a bid likely to come in the teens.
Right now the Lions draft hand gives them 2086 points and if a bid comes in for Ashcroft from North Melbourne at No. 1 they will need 2400 points to take him.
If the Lions get pick 34 for McStay, that plus 15, 33 and 44 would give Brisbane enough points for Ashcroft.
They then need to find points to match a bid for Fletcher and then have a draft hand big enough to get Dunkley.
The Dogs will want more than a first-round pick for Dunkley and the Lions could be in points deficit with their 2023 first-rounder.
The Lions are going to have to get creative and either will have to shed players or split a pick such as 33.
Verdict: Brisbane’s 2023 first-rounder and a 2022 second-round pick either 33 or if it is part of the Ashcroft points haul another that the Lions will have to find.

Izak Rankine (Gold Coast) to Adelaide​

The Crows might not want to, but their first round pick looks like it will have to be at the centre of any deal with the Suns for Rankine.

As well as No. 5 the Crows have picks 23 and 77 but they do need to have enough points to secure a father-son prospect of their own in Max Michalanney.

There was hope that the Crows could include Matt Crouch in a deal, but there isn’t the interest from the Suns, so Adelaide will have to cough up picks.

The Suns have access to highly-touted key forward in Jed Walter next year so they might want 2023 picks to secure him in the draft, which could allow the Crows to keep their first pick in this year’s draft.

Either way, it is looking like a first and a second-round pick from the Crows, with the years of those specific picks to be determined, will be what is required to get a deal done.

VERDICT

Option 1: Crows first pick in 2022 (currently 5) and a 2023 second rounder.

Option 2: Crows second round pick in 2022 (currently 23) and first round pick in 2023.

Luke Jackson (Melbourne) to Fremantle​

Has requested a trade back to Western Australia and while West Coast have the better draft hand, Fremantle are in the box seat to get the young gun ruck/forward.

Melbourne wants two top 10 picks for the 2021 Rising Star winner but right now Fremantle’s first pick is at No. 13.

The Dockers’ next pick is at 72 but their draft hand is set to be bolstered considerably with five players set to depart.

But the Demons are unlikely to want the later picks the Dockers will likely get for some of their fringe players.

They might not get two top 10 picks for Jackson, but the Demons should be able to make Fremantle pay up for the young star.

Verdict: Dockers first-round pick in 2022 (currently 13) and 2023 first-round pick.

Brodie Grundy (Collingwood) to Melbourne​

Another tough one, especially since there has been no indication of what Collingwood might want for the gun ruckman.

Grundy is a two-time All-Australian, but the Pies want his big contract off their books so they shouldn’t be able to demand a big haul for Grundy.

It means the Demons could get the 28-year-old at a cut-price deal from a pick perspective, given they will still have to pay some of Grundy’s big salary, despite the haul they should get for Jackson.

Maybe one of the first round picks Fremantle will give the Demons for Jackson could be the best the Pies get, but this might be overs for a player they want off their books.

The Demons do have picks 32, 41, 50, 63, 68, 86 and those first two could be what gets the deal done.

VERDICT

Option 1: Fremantle’s 2023 first-round pick

Option 2: Melbourne’s 2022 second-round pick (currently 32) and third-round pick (41 tied to Adelaide)

Junior Rioli (West Coast) to Port Adelaide​

The Eagles might be fuming that Rioli wants to go to the Power, despite West Coast standing by him during his two-year suspension for tampering with a urine sample.

But it is a good opportunity for a rebuilding West Coast to get an extra decent draft pick.

The Eagles already have the Power’s second-round pick this year, but Port should get another when Karl Amon goes to Hawthorn as a free agent.

That should be enough to get Rioli to Alberton, with the Eagles premiership player not worth anything more than a second-round pick at 27-years-old.

The Power need a small forward with Robbie Gray and Steven Motlop retired, combined with Orazio Fantasia’s injury issues.

Giving up the pick they get for Amon should be a no-brainer for the Power given this hole on their list.

Verdict: The Karl Amon compensation pick Port Adelaide will receive, likely in the second round.

Tim Taranto and Jacob Hopper (GWS) to Richmond​

The Giants want to get two first rounders, and that is just for Hopper let alone a player in Taranto who won GWS’ Kevin Sheedy Medal in 2019.

Hopper is still under contract, which does explain in part the Giants high price, while Taranto is out of contract.

The Tigers have 12, 19 and 30 in this year’s draft but are likely to have to give up more to get the two Giants to Melbourne.

A player might have to head to Sydney, while Richmond’s 2023 first-round pick might have to be on the table.

It is likely going to be a substantial package the Tigers have to stump up to get the two Giants, but they would be thinking it will be worth it.

Verdict: 12, 19 and Richmond’s 2023 first-round pick and a player.

Tanner Bruhn (GWS) to Geelong​

The 12th pick from the 2020 Draft wants to return to the Geelong region and the Cats should get the young gun without too much trouble.

The Giants are likely to ask for the one first-round pick for Bruhn, who has shown upside as a midfield-forward hybrid.

The Cats first-round pick for this year is at No. 18.

The Giants might try and get the Cats’ first-round pick from next year, and hope Geelong doesn’t make the grand final again.

Verdict: Geelong’s 2023 first-round pick

Rory Lobb (Fremantle) to the Western Bulldogs

Lobb needs to convince the Dockers to let him go to the Bulldogs despite a year on his contract.

If he can then it shouldn’t be too hard of a deal for the Bulldogs to get done with a second-round pick, either this years or next years, likely to secure Lobb.

The 2022 selection is at 29 and could slide into the 30s.

But the Dockers will need picks this year to help them get Jackson and this second-round pick could be a valuable one for them.

Verdict: Bulldogs 2022 second-round pick (currently 29).

Billy Frampton (Adelaide) to Collingwood

Frampton wants to go to Collingwood, which would be his third AFL club.

He is out of contract so the Crows are willing to let him go.

This will ease the list squeeze the Crows currently have and would also help them match a bid for Michalanney.

Collingwood has three picks in the third round - 42 (tied to Hawthorn), 47 (tied to the Bulldogs) and 48 (tied to Richmond).

One of those should get the deal done.

Verdict: Pick 47

 

[Joffaboy]

We are being strangely secretive about our list management right now.

Why haven't we announced contract extensions that we know have been signed i.e. Campbell, Byrnes, likely Wood?

Maybe the list managers know a bit more than us and aren't running about hysterically like their hair is on fire as some on this thread are seem to be doing.

 

[Mstr Strokesman]

Was that you???

No but was very surprised they both kept it very serious.
Surely he was taking ghe piss.

 

[Barrels]

How the big deals of the AFL trade period get done​

It’s your turn to be an AFL list manager. Check out our verdict on how the major trades of 2022 will get done and then have your say on what each club should swap.

Simeon Thomas-Wilson
Follow
@Simeon_TW

5 min read
September 20, 2022 - 7:21AM
News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom
148 comments




00:41
Denied! Lobb to stay with Fremantle?

AFL: Fremantle has denied Rory Lobb's trade request with the club stating he's a required player in 2023.

AFL​

Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News.
Follow
It is set to be a bumper trade period.
But how will the deals get done?
Players are starting to tell their current clubs of where they would like to play in 2023.
But that is only the start of what is about to happen.
Here are some of the deals that are already underway, and how they might get done.

Josh Dunkley (Western Bulldgos) to Brisbane​

This could be one of the hardest deals to get done.
Dunkley wants to go to the Lions, but Brisbane’s draft hand is going to be a complicated one.
The Lions currently have picks 15, 33, 44 and 69 and could secure second-round compensation for Dan McStay when he joins Collingwood.

But the Lions will need to match picks for father-son prospects Will Ashcroft, who is expected to go No. 1, and Jaspa Fletcher - with a bid likely to come in the teens.
Right now the Lions draft hand gives them 2086 points and if a bid comes in for Ashcroft from North Melbourne at No. 1 they will need 2400 points to take him.
If the Lions get pick 34 for McStay, that plus 15, 33 and 44 would give Brisbane enough points for Ashcroft.
They then need to find points to match a bid for Fletcher and then have a draft hand big enough to get Dunkley.
The Dogs will want more than a first-round pick for Dunkley and the Lions could be in points deficit with their 2023 first-rounder.
The Lions are going to have to get creative and either will have to shed players or split a pick such as 33.
Verdict: Brisbane’s 2023 first-rounder and a 2022 second-round pick either 33 or if it is part of the Ashcroft points haul another that the Lions will have to find.

Dunkley wants to become a Lion. Picture: Daniel Pockett/Getty Images

What gets the Dunkley deal done?​

First-round pick
Two first-round picks
First-round + second-round pick
First-round + a player
Cast your vote

Izak Rankine (Gold Coast) to Adelaide​

The Crows might not want to, but their first round pick looks like it will have to be at the centre of any deal with the Suns for Rankine.
As well as No. 5 the Crows have picks 23 and 77 but they do need to have enough points to secure a father-son prospect of their own in Max Michalanney.
There was hope that the Crows could include Matt Crouch in a deal, but there isn’t the interest from the Suns, so Adelaide will have to cough up picks.
The Suns have access to highly-touted key forward in Jed Walter next year so they might want 2023 picks to secure him in the draft, which could allow the Crows to keep their first pick in this year’s draft.
Either way, it is looking like a first and a second-round pick from the Crows, with the years of those specific picks to be determined, will be what is required to get a deal done.
VERDICT
Option 1: Crows first pick in 2022 (currently 5) and a 2023 second rounder.
Option 2: Crows second round pick in 2022 (currently 23) and first round pick in 2023.

Adelaide will have to strike a deal with Gold Coast for Izak Rankine Picture: Chris Hyde/Getty Images

What gets the Rankine deal done?​

First-round pick
First-round + second-round pick
Two first-round picks
First-round pick + a player
Cast your vote

Luke Jackson (Melbourne) to Fremantle​

Has requested a trade back to Western Australia and while West Coast have the better draft hand, Fremantle are in the box seat to get the young gun ruck/forward.
Melbourne wants two top 10 picks for the 2021 Rising Star winner but right now Fremantle’s first pick is at No. 13.
The Dockers’ next pick is at 72 but their draft hand is set to be bolstered considerably with five players set to depart.
But the Demons are unlikely to want the later picks the Dockers will likely get for some of their fringe players.
They might not get two top 10 picks for Jackson, but the Demons should be able to make Fremantle pay up for the young star.
Verdict: Dockers first-round pick in 2022 (currently 13) and 2023 first-round pick.

Is Jackson worth two top 10 picks? Picture: Dylan Burns/AFL Photos via Getty Images

What gets the Jackson deal done?​

First-round pick
Two first-round picks
First-round + second-round pick
Cast your vote

Brodie Grundy (Collingwood) to Melbourne​

Another tough one, especially since there has been no indication of what Collingwood might want for the gun ruckman.
Grundy is a two-time All-Australian, but the Pies want his big contract off their books so they shouldn’t be able to demand a big haul for Grundy.
It means the Demons could get the 28-year-old at a cut-price deal from a pick perspective, given they will still have to pay some of Grundy’s big salary, despite the haul they should get for Jackson.
Maybe one of the first round picks Fremantle will give the Demons for Jackson could be the best the Pies get, but this might be overs for a player they want off their books.
The Demons do have picks 32, 41, 50, 63, 68, 86 and those first two could be what gets the deal done.
VERDICT
Option 1: Fremantle’s 2023 first-round pick
Option 2: Melbourne’s 2022 second-round pick (currently 32) and third-round pick (41 tied to Adelaide)

What gets Grundy deal done?​

First-round pick
Second-round pick
Two second-round picks
Second-round + third-round pick
Cast your vote

Can the Demons get brodie Grundy for cheap? Picture: Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images

Junior Rioli (West Coast) to Port Adelaide​

The Eagles might be fuming that Rioli wants to go to the Power, despite West Coast standing by him during his two-year suspension for tampering with a urine sample.
But it is a good opportunity for a rebuilding West Coast to get an extra decent draft pick.
The Eagles already have the Power’s second-round pick this year, but Port should get another when Karl Amon goes to Hawthorn as a free agent.
That should be enough to get Rioli to Alberton, with the Eagles premiership player not worth anything more than a second-round pick at 27-years-old.
The Power need a small forward with Robbie Gray and Steven Motlop retired, combined with Orazio Fantasia’s injury issues.
Giving up the pick they get for Amon should be a no-brainer for the Power given this hole on their list.
Verdict: The Karl Amon compensation pick Port Adelaide will receive, likely in the second round.

Junior Rioli is set to end up at Alberton. Picture: Morgan Hancock/Getty Images

What gets the Rioli deal done?​

Amon compensation (likely early second-round)
First-round pick
Second-round pick + a player
Cast your vote

Tim Taranto and Jacob Hopper (GWS) to Richmond​

The Giants want to get two first rounders, and that is just for Hopper let alone a player in Taranto who won GWS’ Kevin Sheedy Medal in 2019.
Hopper is still under contract, which does explain in part the Giants high price, while Taranto is out of contract.
The Tigers have 12, 19 and 30 in this year’s draft but are likely to have to give up more to get the two Giants to Melbourne.
A player might have to head to Sydney, while Richmond’s 2023 first-round pick might have to be on the table.
It is likely going to be a substantial package the Tigers have to stump up to get the two Giants, but they would be thinking it will be worth it.
Verdict: 12, 19 and Richmond’s 2023 first-round pick and a player.

What gets the Taranto + Hopper deal done?​

Two first-round picks
Three first-round picks
Three first-round picks + a player
Three first-round + second-round pick
Two first-round picks + a player
Cast your vote

Tanner Bruhn (GWS) to Geelong​

The 12th pick from the 2020 Draft wants to return to the Geelong region and the Cats should get the young gun without too much trouble.
The Giants are likely to ask for the one first-round pick for Bruhn, who has shown upside as a midfield-forward hybrid.
The Cats first-round pick for this year is at No. 18.
The Giants might try and get the Cats’ first-round pick from next year, and hope Geelong doesn’t make the grand final again.
Verdict: Geelong’s 2023 first-round pick

Bruhn wants to leave the Giants. (Photo by Dylan Burns/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

What gets the Bruhn deal done?​

First-round pick
Second-round pick
Second-round pick + a player
Two second-round picks
Cast your vote


Rory Lobb (Fremantle) to the Western Bulldogs
Lobb needs to convince the Dockers to let him go to the Bulldogs despite a year on his contract.
If he can then it shouldn’t be too hard of a deal for the Bulldogs to get done with a second-round pick, either this years or next years, likely to secure Lobb.
The 2022 selection is at 29 and could slide into the 30s.
But the Dockers will need picks this year to help them get Jackson and this second-round pick could be a valuable one for them.
Verdict: Bulldogs 2022 second-round pick (currently 29).

What gets the Lobb deal done?​

First-round pick
Second-round pick
Third-round pick
Cast your vote

Billy Frampton is out of contract at the Crows. Picture: Getty Images
Billy Frampton (Adelaide) to Collingwood
Frampton wants to go to Collingwood, which would be his third AFL club.
He is out of contract so the Crows are willing to let him go.
This will ease the list squeeze the Crows currently have and would also help them match a bid for Michalanney.
Collingwood has three picks in the third round - 42 (tied to Hawthorn), 47 (tied to the Bulldogs) and 48 (tied to Richmond).

More Coverage​

Trade latest: Dogs’ demands for DunkleyCripps’ ice cold response to Gill’s tribunal crackThe four recruits who will make Pies better in 2023
One of those should get the deal done.

Jesus…

Can you cut the photo out?!

Head like a dropped potato.

 

[BrutThough]

Maybe the list managers know a bit more than us and aren't running about hysterically like their hair is on fire as some on this thread are seem to be doing.

It's just weird we haven't announced contract extensions. Why hide them?

Sure Campbell isn't a make or break type on the list but a one line statement saying he's stating around after his great VFL year does no harm.

Or Mason Wood - just wins clubman'award and by his interactions, he isn't going anywhere. There is no reason why they hasn't been released yet.

 

[stavro#4]

For what it’s worth. I think you blokes make good hot dogs.

 

[DougalHoward]

it's nice when a pick of danielle laidley pops up, helps identify the boomers on the board

most of the board

 

[XhazzafootyX]

For what it’s worth. I think you blokes make good hot dogs.

View attachment 1513648

Most delusional fans in the league. They literally convinced themselves Kelly and gaff were going to the kangas

 

[bird_man]

When Clark’s a contracted player, with talent in a demographic we don’t have why would we feel obliged to find middle ground? Recently history is littered with examples of clubs either getting overs in this instance or forcing the player to see out their contract.

Because we have made him available

It's very different to the Papley, Gibbs, Hill etc situations where a club really wants to keep him

It's much closer to the Josh Bruce situation from a few years back

If we were so hung about about his talent and contract situation we wouldn't be telling clubs he's gettable

 

[Joffaboy]

Most delusional fans in the league. They literally convinced themselves Kelly and gaff were going to the kangas

They were getting two First round PP dp's

50 thousand members

 

[Premium]

Maybe the list managers know a bit more than us and aren't running about hysterically like their hair is on fire as some on this thread are seem to be doing.

Fully expect the whole brains trust from Mangers , Coaches with the List management to of already made the moves and are just wanting for a few trades to be announced before committing to any players.

If we are already out of the race for DeGoey they would be after another top rated midfielder to move into the squad who that is who knows - it could well be Nths first round pick.

 

[Hayes4PM]

For what it’s worth. I think you blokes make good hot dogs.

View attachment 1513648

On the one hand they're in their support package thread whinging they didn't get enough priority picks on the other hand they're in their trade thread potting us as the in debt, unsuccessful club. The duality of Norf.

 

[Joffaboy]

On the one hand they're in their support package thread whinging they didn't get enough priority picks on the other hand they're in their trade thread potting us as the in debt, unsuccessful club. The duality of Norf.

Norfies are special

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Because we have made him available

It's very different to the Papley, Gibbs, Hill etc situations where a club really wants to keep him

It's much closer to the Josh Bruce situation from a few years back

If we were so hung about about his talent and contract situation we wouldn't be telling clubs he's gettable

What a load of crap.

If i'm willing to sell my house , it doesn't mean i'll sell it to you for half its value just because i "made it available".

Sick of people peddling bullshit that describes why its polite for the Saints to get screwed in every deal.

 

[shlong]

Decision time approaching for in-demand Saint

Saint Hunter Clark’s playing future will soon be decided as opposition clubs circle and the trade period rapidly approaches. But why is St Kilda willing to give him up?

thewest.com.au

We fold as a club or move to tassie if it's a future 2nd. Bloke has to have been caught with meth if we're trading him for that

 

[bergholt]

What a load of crap.

If i'm willing to sell my house , it doesn't mean i'll sell it to you for half its value just because i "made it available".

If you’ve already bought another one then I might be able to squeeze you down though - motivated seller as they say in the trade. Maybe we’re a motivated seller of Hunts and Hilly?

 

[StCicatriz]

Because we have made him available

It's very different to the Papley, Gibbs, Hill etc situations where a club really wants to keep him

It's much closer to the Josh Bruce situation from a few years back

If we were so hung about about his talent and contract situation we wouldn't be telling clubs he's gettable

fremantle wanted to keep hill did they? strange that they traded him.

 

[StCicatriz]

Decision time approaching for in-demand Saint

Saint Hunter Clark’s playing future will soon be decided as opposition clubs circle and the trade period rapidly approaches. But why is St Kilda willing to give him up?

thewest.com.au

We fold as a club or move to tassie if it's a future 2nd. Bloke has to have been caught with meth if we're trading him for that

like i said he should be in the same value band as cerra. freo didnt let cerra walk for a 2nd rounder. neither did they with weller.

if we are doing this it confirms Gags is 100% done.

 

[bird_man]

What a load of crap.

If i'm willing to sell my house , it doesn't mean i'll sell it to you for half its value just because i "made it available".

When did I say we would sell him for half his value?

I said we'd find middle ground

You don't honestly think we will get a top 10 pick for Clark do you?

Just like a future 2nd won't be enough.

Somewhere in the middle is the middle ground...

Unfortunately we've made a player available when he's at his lowest value, but we aren't naive enough to know clubs won't be throwing top 10 picks at us for him, surely...

 

[Sun Ra]

For what it’s worth. I think you blokes make good hot dogs.

View attachment 1513648

stavro#4 are you in league with this ****stick Psicosis ?

 

[bird_man]

fremantle wanted to keep hill did they? strange that they traded him.

They traded him for one of the most one sided deals in recent history...

They weren't shopping Hill around telling clubs he was available