Resource 2023 AFL Draft Discussion...

[Firewalker]

Would need to tidy up his set shot goalkicking on what I've seen of him up to now, very inconsistent.

His kicking action looks pretty good though albeit from from the limited stuff I’ve seen, so no major technique issues so I don’t think that will be a major issue in the future

 

[Trigger13]

If Moir doesn’t pull his finger out he’ll go from top 5 lock to speculative pick. Plays arrogant football.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

44 HO - 25 SA's way

No surprises there , Read is more post ruck contest dominant

And May isn’t much good

 

[Jeffcrowe]

McCauliffe second half was quite solid I thought

Do SA win a game though this year ? I have my doubts

 

[Jeffcrowe]

If Moir doesn’t pull his finger out he’ll go from top 5 lock to speculative pick. Plays arrogant football.

He wouldn’t be in 1st round at moment , looking more and more speculative

 

[Danger in Texas]

Need to watch a replay, how did Sanders and O’Sullivan look?

 

[Crow_68]

If Moir doesn’t pull his finger out he’ll go from top 5 lock to speculative pick. Plays arrogant football.

Moir is the last player we need at the moment, more pressing needs

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Need to watch a replay, how did Sanders and O’Sullivan look?

sanders had 36 i think was everywhere and prob best on ground , don't reckon he'd suit us though. small and doesn't penetrate

the allies mids dominated from start , mckercher is more damaging and had 27, rogers 20 and cleary also 26

o'sullivan i like , was solid

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Moir is the last player we need at the moment, more pressing needs

can't see us taking Moir

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Sanders small?

186cm and 85kg already?

wow he's bigger than he looks

reminds me of a Tom mitchell type, super IQ

Not sure type of mid we are after

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Then you must have thought the same of JHF because if he put some peroxide through his hair he'd be a dead ringer right down to the pulled up socks..

no he doesn't have power

haven;\'t got him down as the type of mid we need due to this, much prefer mckercher who reminds me of dylan shiel but more aggressive

 

[Jeffcrowe]

We'll agree to disagree then.

yep

i've got mckercher clear best mid outside of harley reid who is i guess a mid but also utility

sanders around 25-35

 

[Danger in Texas]

sanders had 36 i think was everywhere and prob best on ground , don't reckon he'd suit us though. small and doesn't penetrate

the allies mids dominated from start , mckercher is more damaging and had 27, rogers 20 and cleary also 26

o'sullivan i like , was solid

Yeah McKercher’s probably a top 6 prospect at this point

Sanders isn’t that small is he? 186? You’re right in that he doesn’t fill a total need, although we probably need some more young clearance winners to come through once Laird starts to wane in form

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I like McKercher too but I know who I want in the contested hard ball situations that is AFL midfield.

mckercher contested game is v good

sanders reminds me a bit of tom powell , good player not a game changer, definitely an afl player but not someone i think we need

 

[Danger in Texas]

yep

i've got mckercher clear best mid outside of harley reid who is i guess a mid but also utility

sanders around 25-35

I’d put Wilson ahead of McKercher, I’m huge on him

 

[Danger in Texas]

I like McKercher too but I know who I want in the contested hard ball situations that is AFL midfield.

I reckon I’d happily take Sanders with one of our seconds, would probably have to be the NM one

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Yeah McKercher’s probably a top 6 prospect at this point

Sanders isn’t that small is he? 186? You’re right in that he doesn’t fill a total need, although we probably need some more young clearance winners to come through once Laird starts to wane in form

it must bed his short legs long torso , he's taller than i thought

reid walter watson mckercher duursma + read is my early top 6 , no order after harley

your boy wilson is good too , close to that list

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I reckon I’d happily take Sanders with one of our seconds, would probably have to be the NM one

yes i would with one of 2nds prob

 

[Jeffcrowe]

We'll agree to disagree then.

what you think of mccauliffe today and what are his stand out traits ?

 

[Jeffcrowe]

If he continues his form of today throughout the Nationals that's not happening

not sure he gets taken before at least 15, so some chance

 

[Danger in Texas]

it must bed his short legs long torso , he's taller than i thought

reid walter watson mckercher duursma + read is my early top 6 , no order after harley

your boy wilson is good too , close to that list

Yeah agree that it’s tough to separate a few after Reid, at this point

For mine I’d add Edwards and Wilson to that list, and take out Duursma

 

[Danger in Texas]

If he continues his form of today throughout the Nationals that's not happening

Fair enough, Champs domination usually goes a long way

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Apart from Sid Draper he looked like the only SA mid that stood up to the Allies stacked midfield especially in the 2nd half.

Strong over the ball and a penetrating left boot.

agree

 

[Jeffcrowe]

You don't think this looks like JHF?

Get the peroxide out and he's a dead ringer..

He ain't small...he's a bull in the JHF style

And he'll surprise you with the numbers he puts up at the Combine, he ain't slow!

Might look like him but I don’t think he plays like him … he’s neat rather than powerful

Gets alot of ball and accumulates more where as Jason was powerful and very high impact per possession

He’s more death by a thousand cuts

 

[George CantStandYa]

Can we friggin draft a quality midfielder