List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread III

[The Nostradamus]

It's probably been mentioned somewhere here on BF but if we recruited Soldo surely he would be our no 1 ruckman? Richmond didn't get much for him either.

Yep we should have gone after him

He’d have been able to stay in vic also

They are showing a lot of faith in xerri and CCJ

Didnt Brady say that we currently have 5 list spots to pick players...Surely that would not include Turner, Mahoney and Bonar because they officially have not been delisted yet..

No he said we are likely to take 5 picks in the ND and that we have 32 on the senior list

So looks like we are going to do a 37-7 structure
Currently have 5 rookies signed

In which case we have 2 spare rookie list spots (I think turner stays on the rookie list then we decide if we want 1 of the 2 senior boys or to take another rookie instead)

 

[Farthers]

It's probably been mentioned somewhere here on BF but if we recruited Soldo surely he would be our no 1 ruckman? Richmond didn't get much for him either.

I thought what Richmond got for Soldo was overs tbh. Future 2nd tied to Freo was enough.

 

[perplexed]

Rawlings didnt stuff up the numbers.

We got the dregs as part of the JHF trade. They had some value so Rawlings did his best to swap them for futures.

Yes, he stuffed it up. We ended player trade period with more picks than list positions and rather than push a couple of players back to the rookie list, he traded in another pick so we had to dump trade. We ended up one of three teams with a maxed out primary list and had no flexibility at the draft because we had committed to taking Cooper with our last pick. It was a complete shambles.

 

[perplexed]

Didnt Brady say that we currently have 5 list spots to pick players...Surely that would not include Turner, Mahoney and Bonar because they officially have not been delisted yet..

I can only count four, but happy to be contradicted. We started with 38, lost 8 and gained 4.

 

[tiltraise]

It's probably been mentioned somewhere here on BF but if we recruited Soldo surely he would be our no 1 ruckman? Richmond didn't get much for him either.

The player has to want to come.

Not much love for X on here but I think he deserves a shot and we arent going to win the flag next year anyway so why not look at what we have?

 

[Gumble Frankieton]

And get done for tampering? It’s already shameless enough what they’ve been doing with McClure.

We have a solution at hand. Just get Harley to start wearing this t-shirt and drink from this bottle during interviews

 

[tiltraise]

Yes, he stuffed it up. We ended player trade period with more picks than list positions and rather than push a couple of players back to the rookie list, he traded in another pick so we had to dump trade. We ended up one of three teams with a maxed out primary list and had no flexibility at the draft because we had committed to taking Cooper with our last pick. It was a complete shambles.

If you think getting Wardlaw, Sheezel and trading up for George was a shambles then good luck to you.

He got left with some useless currency which he converted to futures.

Rawling cops a lot on here but I think hes been fine especially since Viney came.

 

[The Nostradamus]

If you thing getting Wardlaw, Sheezel and trading up for George was a shambles then good luck to you.

He got left with some useless currency which he converted to futures.

Rawling cops a lot on here but I think hes been fine especially since Viney came.

Worth looking into now that its all materialised
from memory he gave up picks in the 40s/50s last year that we could have taken a KPF like Lemmey, scully or keeler for picks this year which are 57 from dees and 63 from hawks which we gave up for biggy and werent going to use anyway

will take a look into this in more detail when i can be bothered

 

[LB2Snake]

Worth looking into now that its all materialised
from memory he gave up picks in the 40s/50s last year that we could have taken a KPF like Lemmey, scully or keeler for picks this year which are 57 from dees and 63 from hawks which we gave up for biggy and werent going to use anyway

will take a look into this in more detail when i can be bothered

What happened to Keeler, anyone remember? He looked like he could really play.

 

[New_Roo]

Worth looking into now that its all materialised
from memory he gave up picks in the 40s/50s last year that we could have taken a KPF like Lemmey, scully or keeler for picks this year which are 57 from dees and 63 from hawks which we gave up for biggy and werent going to use anyway

will take a look into this in more detail when i can be bothered

Did we see lemmey Scully or keeler this yr?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[The Nostradamus]

Did we see lemmey Scully or keeler this yr?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

They’re long term KPF prospects

Looked good at reserve level

 

[New_Roo]

They’re long term KPF prospects

Looked good at reserve level

Will wait snd grab them when developed!

If and when!


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[The Nostradamus]

Will wait snd grab them when developed!

If and when!


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

I’m glad we got pick 57 and 63 this year instead of using those picks last year

 

[My Left Foote]

I’m glad we got pick 57 and 63 this year instead of using those picks last year

We traded pick 65 for Biggie.

 

[The Nostradamus]

We traded pick 65 for Biggie.

I’m aware
We also weren’t going to use that pick
And could have got biggie in the psd

 

[Mav]

What happened to Keeler, anyone remember? He looked like he could really play.

Battled some injuries this year and played about a dozen games in the VFL. He's working hard and looking towards a big preseason.

 

[R00StaR]

Safest: Reid and Mckercher

Highest ceiling: Reid and Duursma

What I would do/least likely to occur: Watson and Duursma

What I think we do: Mckercher and Duursma

We can't go wrong with any of them to be honest.

Hope we go Sanders and McKercher.

 

[Mav]

Did we see lemmey Scully or keeler this yr?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

None of those guys were going to be ready for AFL this year but they all still have massive potential.

 

[tiltraise]

Worth looking into now that its all materialised
from memory he gave up picks in the 40s/50s last year that we could have taken a KPF like Lemmey, scully or keeler for picks this year which are 57 from dees and 63 from hawks which we gave up for biggy and werent going to use anyway

will take a look into this in more detail when i can be bothered

He traded them for market rate.

Brady went from a surprise of JHF asking for a trade at start of window to Wardlaw and Sheezel.

Sure he got left with some dregs but he converted them into live currency.

With the George pick obviously we rated that part of the draft so he used an F2 to get it.

 

[The Filth Wizard]

I’m glad we got pick 57 and 63 this year instead of using those picks last year

We only had one list spot left and we still needed to draft Cooper.

 

[The Nostradamus]

He traded them for market rate.

Brady went from a surprise of JHF asking for a trade at start of window to Wardlaw and Sheezel.

Sure he got left with some dregs but he converted them into live currency.

With the George pick obviously we rated that part of the draft so he used an F2 to get it.

I’m not talking about the high end picks I’m responding and backing up the point that was made that we ended up with picks in the 40s and 50s which we essentially threw away for 57 and 65 this year

 

[Psicosis]

Last year Rawlings stuffed up the list numbers and we ended up having to dump picks. We can't afford to make that rookie mistake again.

At the moment we have four senior list spots and six picks.

If we plan on taking five players at the draft, we need at least six list spots to give ourselves some flexibility. This isn't good news for Bonar and Mahony, we really need to delist them both. If we wanted to keep one of them, we could also pay out or push back Lazarro.

Bonar was done as soon as Biggy agreed IMO

 

[perplexed]

If you think getting Wardlaw, Sheezel and trading up for George was a shambles then good luck to you.

He got left with some useless currency which he converted to futures.

Rawling cops a lot on here but I think hes been fine especially since Viney came.

Crikey, what a defensive reaction. I like Rawlings. The recent selections have been excellent and he is a capable negotiator. These are the most important parts of his job. However, his management of player numbers has been poor. He clearly needs help with this, I hope we have someone doing that this year.

 

[giantroo]

 

[LB2Snake]

Battled some injuries this year and played about a dozen games in the VFL. He's working hard and looking towards a big preseason.

what team?