List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread III

[GoRoos2023]

And one way of doing it would be to trade pick 3 with Melbourne's 6 and 11.

And then we'd have pick 2 and 6 to give them.

Deal done...

But we end up with pick 1 and 11 15 17 and 18.

* that.

Much rather 2 and 3 15 17 18

That’s it Johnny we still have another strong offer in us. Let’s see

 

[My Left Foote]

And one way of doing it would be to trade pick 3 with Melbourne's 6 and 11.

And then we'd have pick 2 and 6 to give them.

Deal done...

But we end up with pick 1 and 11 15 17 and 18.

* that.

Much rather 2 and 3 15 17 18

We're on the record saying we'll use 2 picks in the top 3, whether that be 2 & 3 as is or 1 & 3 (if we do a trade with West Coast). We're not trading out both 2 and 3.

 

[gokangas]

Has that been confirmed? I think it’s just speculation.

It's only early - plenty of time so this argy bargy will continue.

 

[Dan]

What would people think if the weagles countered our offer with -

Pick 1 & F1st Round for 2,3 & 15?

 

[My Left Foote]

What would people think if the weagles countered our offer with -

Pick 1 & F1st Round for 2,3 & 15?

They're not trading their F1.

 

[JGreezy]

They're not trading their F1.

Trading us their F1 is their best chance to have a good season next year. We're cursed in that way.

 

[LB2Snake]

They're not trading their F1.

I wouldn’t want their F1 if it costs both 2 and 3. There‘s no guarantee they are bottom 2 next year. They should be, but they also have a massive home ground advantage every second week. Things will turn for them at a some stage.

 

[My Left Foote]

Trading us their F1 is their best chance to have a good season next year. We're cursed in that way.

Wooden Spoon > Premiers

 

[DuckYeah]

For pick 1 (2021) and pick 1 (2022) we got Sheezel (pick 3) Wardlaw (pick 4) and Poortas F1.

These campaigners want pick 2/3/15/17/18 for pick 1.

SUCK MY DICK!

Tell em theyre dreamin

 

[Farthers]

For pick 1 (2021) and pick 1 (2022) we got Sheezel (pick 3) Wardlaw (pick 4) and Poortas F1.

These campaigners want pick 2/3/15/17/18 for pick 1.

SUCK MY DICK!

Tell em theyre dreamin

For reference, GWS paid 3, 12 and F2 (34) (tied to pies) for 1 and a couple of picks in the 50s in that deal.

 

[ohmygewd]

For reference, GWS paid 3, 12 and F2 (34) (tied to pies) for 1 and a couple of picks in the 50s in that deal.

So offerring 3,15 and F2 for 1 is not unreasonable then?

 

[LB2Snake]

For reference, GWS paid 3, 12 and F2 (34) (tied to pies) for 1 and a couple of picks in the 50s in that deal.

That’s all well and good but are GWS a “super rich club”……it’s relevant, for some unknown reason, for majority of WC clowns.

 

[DuckYeah]

So offerring 3,15 and F2 for 1 is not unreasonable then?

Spot on!

 

[chubbspeterson]

The points system isn't everything but it's interesting that pick 2 and any combination of two of our late 1sts for 1 and 23 is a pick 23-27 points difference. The slide from pick 1 to 2 is pick 37 on its own.

Interestingly, the Demons 6,11, F1 and 42 is the roughly a points gain of a top 10 pick, depending on where they finish next year.

Hawks offer of pick 4 and F1 (assume pick 3-5) could be 12-20 pick points difference but looks great on paper.

I'd guess WCE want top 3 and top 6 to get McKercher and Curtin.

 

[R00StaR]

We’ve made another offer. 2, 17, 18 for 1, 23. Rejected by WC.

We could offer slightly better late firsts but for mine thats the best offer we can make.
We start dealing elsewhere now.

 

[Dan]

I wouldn’t want their F1 if it costs both 2 and 3. There‘s no guarantee they are bottom 2 next year. They should be, but they also have a massive home ground advantage every second week. Things will turn for them at a some stage.

Bottom 4 next year.

 

[roos 10]

We could offer slightly better late firsts but for mine thats the best offer we can make.
We start dealing elsewhere now.

I would only do
2/17/18/future 2nd
For
1/23
If that don’t get I done walk away

 

[Kanga Glory]

 

[JGreezy]

I would only do
2/17/18/future 2nd
For
1/23
If that don’t get I done walk away

I would go 3, 15 & 18 as a max

 

[Passmore]

Clarko needs to confiscate Brady's phone…

Clarko wants Reid. He’s given him extra phones.

 

[speedy]

I really want to know what is this infatuation with getting Reid?
Is it because you believe he is a once in a generation talent?
You are that convinced he’s the best player in this draft by some margin that it is worth giving up 2 1st rounders to move up one spot?

 

[DuckYeah]

The points system isn't everything but it's interesting that pick 2 and any combination of two of our late 1sts for 1 and 23 is a pick 23-27 points difference. The slide from pick 1 to 2 is pick 37 on its own.

Interestingly, the Demons 6,11, F1 and 42 is the roughly a points gain of a top 10 pick, depending on where they finish next year.

Hawks offer of pick 4 and F1 (assume pick 3-5) could be 12-20 pick points difference but looks great on paper.

I'd guess WCE want top 3 and top 6 to get McKercher and Curtin.

Ive said it before. Us having 2 and 3 *s em over. They arent able to obtain a top 3 without dealing with us. Sucked in flogs

 

[zoomba23]

I really want to know what is this infatuation with getting Reid?
Is it because you believe he is a once in a generation talent?
You are that convinced he’s the best player in this draft by some margin that it is worth giving up 2 1st rounders to move up one spot?

I haven't been that obsessive over it but the reason I want him is because he's very likely to at least be a top 5 player from this draft and I think he'd be brilliant as a two way player off half back. Hodge-esque. A role that we're lacking in and that can transform a team. That said, I wouldn't offer much more than 2, 15 and a F2

 

[franjon]

Are you serious?

Let's hope so.

 

[drew]

Does anyone know what Melbourne offered today that was rejected? …and was that their best possible offer…