List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread

[King Corey]

Edit: will update if ppl happy for this to sticky

Ok starting the hit list of names mentioned in any rumour as linked to us for 2023 trade period.

• Mac Andrew
• Hunter Clark
• Zac Fisher
• Sam Flanders
• Mitch Georgiades
• Liam Henry
• Dougal Howard
• Lewis Melican
• Jack Silvagni
• Dylan Stephens
• Adam Tomlinson

 

[justroyal]

to play devils advocate…

Is Sheezel going to be your HBF next year?

How are you covering logue and McKay?

What primary role does Hollands play?

Aside from Scott, who are your 2024 wingmen?

I hate when you play the devil’s advocate…
Rain on our damn parade with your thought out logic.

 

[kool kangas]

Starting with 2, 16, 39, 53 & 59 this year plus 2024 1st, 2nd and 3rd picks

McKay departs for #3 in compo

Sanders is pre listed as an NGA

Trade 2024 1st for GC #5 and Hollands

Trade #39 for Grundy (pay his salary)

Trade #53 for Joel Smith

Draft at #2, #3, #5, #16

Draft whichever of Curtin and Reid WCE don't take at #2, McKercher at #3, watch Hawthorn take Duursma at #4, take Watson at #5 & A.Reid at #16

Left with 2024 2nd & 2024 3rd

In: Sanders, Hollands, Grundy, Smith, Curtin, McKercher, Watson, A.Reid

Out: McKay, #2, #3, #5, #16, #39, #53, 2024 1st, cash, delistees

Shits easy. I'll drop the BSB on Brady when I get a sec

Going into next season without a KPD in McKay or Logue no good...all the rest sounds ok...

 

[The Filth Wizard]

Starting with 2, 16, 39, 53 & 59 this year plus 2024 1st, 2nd and 3rd picks

McKay departs for #3 in compo

Sanders is pre listed as an NGA

Trade 2024 1st for GC #5 and Hollands

Trade #39 for Grundy (pay his salary)

Trade #53 for Joel Smith

Draft at #2, #3, #5, #16

Draft whichever of Curtin and Reid WCE don't take at #2, McKercher at #3, watch Hawthorn take Duursma at #4, take Watson at #5 & A.Reid at #16

Left with 2024 2nd & 2024 3rd

In: Sanders, Hollands, Grundy, Smith, Curtin, McKercher, Watson, A.Reid

Out: McKay, #2, #3, #5, #16, #39, #53, 2024 1st, cash, delistees

Shits easy. I'll drop the BSB on Brady when I get a sec

This is Real Sex.

(See guys how we have gone full circle?).

 

[The Filth Wizard]

to play devils advocate…

Is Sheezel going to be your HBF next year?

How are you covering logue and McKay?

Aside from Scott, who are your 2024 wingmen? (Is it Hollands? If not, what primary role does Hollands play?)

Free agency brutha.

 

[Flawed Genius]

to play devils advocate…

Is Sheezel going to be your HBF next year?

How are you covering logue and McKay?

Aside from Scott, who are your 2024 wingmen? (Is it Hollands? If not, what primary role does Hollands play?)

To play with my own sack

FB McDonald Smith Curtin
HB Thomas Corr Sheezel
C Scott Wardlaw Goater
HF Stephenson Comben Zurhaar
FF Watson Larkey Curtis
R Grundy LDU Simpkin
I Hollands Phillips Powell George
S Bergman

E McKercher Sanders CCJ A.Reid Taylor Tucker Greenwood Archer Harvey Xerri Drury Hansen Jnr.

Smith, Corr and Curtin as the three defensive talls. Thomas and Sheezel as the rebounding halfbacks. McDonald on a short leash as the lockdown defender with Arch waiting in the wings to step in if LMac has a bad stretch. There's Logue/McKay covered in a pinch

Curtin stepping in frees Goater up to play in his natural position on a wing. Scott as the more defensive winger while Goater with more natural pace can run and gun offensively

Comben back in to play foil to Larkey. Comben as a second ruck to cover Grundy whenever he needs a rest. Watson and Curtis at Larkey/Combens feet. Immediately more dangerous than Turner. Stephenson and Zurhaar pushing up to support as high half forwards with Zurhaar as the primary third forward.

Grundy starting ruck, Wardlaw as defensive centreman, Simpkin and LDU on the outside. Powell, Phillips as midfield cover; Thomas/Sheezel/Zurhaar/Curtin as a pinch in the guts.

Hollands as a switch for Stephenson/Zurhaar as a high half forward/wing. Could also run him off the HBF and push Sheezel forward. Bergman as a running HBF sub, but this could be McKercher, Greenwood, Harvey, Hansen Jnr depending on need.

Developing in the twos you've got McKercher as a wingman/HBF/centre rotation partner with Wardlaw, A.Reid as a swingman if Comben breaks in half, Taylor as a tagger, Tucker as a Swiss army knife, Sanders as an inside mid etc.

I think it's automatically a more dangerous team than we've put on the park at any point this year. It is heaps young but

 

[berniemccarthy]

As much as I love Goldy.

It's time.

That’s a big call from you Handsome.

 

[Flawed Genius]

Free agency brutha.

Only issue is FA dilutes McKay compo

 

[The Filth Wizard]

Only issue is FA dilutes McKay compo

Delisted free agency brutha.

 

[Flawed Genius]

Delisted free agency brutha.

Give me that sweet Paddy McCartin unretirement. Another top 5 pick to wave in Brads face

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

We are going to need better chf/kpf coverage than Comben and CCJ. Going to have to recruit or draft at least one, alongside kpds.

 

[Flawed Genius]

We are going to need better chf/kpf coverage than Comben and CCJ. Going to have to recruit or draft at least one, alongside kpds.

Here's where the Matthew McGuinness plan comes into play

Alternatively double down on salary cap dumps and get Haynes + GWS' first. Play Haynes as a forward & draft Caddy with GWS' first. There's your heated seat my friend

 

[Makeshift Park]

To play with my own sack

FB McDonald Smith Curtin
HB Thomas Corr Sheezel
C Scott Wardlaw Goater
HF Stephenson Comben Zurhaar
FF Watson Larkey Curtis
R Grundy LDU Simpkin
I Hollands Phillips Powell George
S Bergman

E McKercher Sanders CCJ A.Reid Taylor Tucker Greenwood Archer Harvey Xerri Drury Hansen Jnr.

Smith, Corr and Curtin as the three defensive talls. Thomas and Sheezel as the rebounding halfbacks. McDonald on a short leash as the lockdown defender with Arch waiting in the wings to step in if LMac has a bad stretch. There's Logue/McKay covered in a pinch

Curtin stepping in frees Goater up to play in his natural position on a wing. Scott as the more defensive winger while Goater with more natural pace can run and gun offensively

Comben back in to play foil to Larkey. Comben as a second ruck to cover Grundy whenever he needs a rest. Watson and Curtis at Larkey/Combens feet. Immediately more dangerous than Turner. Stephenson and Zurhaar pushing up to support as high half forwards with Zurhaar as the primary third forward.

Grundy starting ruck, Wardlaw as defensive centreman, Simpkin and LDU on the outside. Powell, Phillips as midfield cover; Thomas/Sheezel/Zurhaar/Curtin as a pinch in the guts.

Hollands as a switch for Stephenson/Zurhaar as a high half forward/wing. Could also run him off the HBF and push Sheezel forward. Bergman as a running HBF sub, but this could be McKercher, Greenwood, Harvey, Hansen Jnr depending on need.

Developing in the twos you've got McKercher as a wingman/HBF/centre rotation partner with Wardlaw, A.Reid as a swingman if Comben breaks in half, Taylor as a tagger, Tucker as a Swiss army knife, Sanders as an inside mid etc.

I think it's automatically a more dangerous team than we've put on the park at any point this year. It is heaps young but

I like a lot of this but I think we really need Ralphsmith and/or Fisher types to unlock Thomas and Sheezel. Fundamentally I think defence is by far our worst staffed section of the field now, and it would be remiss of us to not find a skerrick of draft capital for good experienced running defenders this off season.

 

[Shermanator]

Here's where the Matthew McGuinness plan comes into play

Alternatively double down on salary cap dumps and get Haynes + GWS' first. Play Haynes as a forward & draft Caddy with GWS' first. There's your heated seat my friend

Josh Goater grows 3 inches in the off-season or we re-employee Luffy to crunch the Moneyball numbers?..

 

[shinboner magic]

It is. The AFL is looking at going further with matching bids using picks in the same round only.

How does this work if you have pick 6 and someone bids pick 12

 

[Disco Dew]

How does this work if you have pick 6 and someone bids pick 12

Tough shit. Cheating northern state campaigners

 

[BIGHAWK23]

Maybe Jeff and his mate honest Phil could do a report on it.

On SM-S901E using BigFooty.com mobile app

Ahh, woe is me talk
Sounds about right

 

[shinboner magic]

Hollands has looked slow af - I wouldn’t be trading a f1 for him.
Got to be Flanders

We all know we won’t trade our f1 - so it’s a moot point

 

[JGreezy]

To play with my own sack

FB McDonald Smith Curtin
HB Thomas Corr Sheezel
C Scott Wardlaw Goater
HF Stephenson Comben Zurhaar
FF Watson Larkey Curtis
R Grundy LDU Simpkin
I Hollands Phillips Powell George
S Bergman

E McKercher Sanders CCJ A.Reid Taylor Tucker Greenwood Archer Harvey Xerri Drury Hansen Jnr.

I reckon for the back 6...

FB: Archer - Smith/Logue - McDonald
HB: Curtin - Corr/Comben - McKercher

Bring in Riccardi to play CHF

 

[shinboner magic]

Ahh, woe is me talk
Sounds about right

Are you lost

 

[JGreezy]

Ahh, woe is me talk
Sounds about right

 

[ToxicMegaPunts]

to play devils advocate…

Is Sheezel going to be your HBF next year?

How are you covering logue and McKay?

Aside from Scott, who are your 2024 wingmen? (Is it Hollands? If not, what primary role does Hollands play?)

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

To play with my own sack

FB McDonald Smith Curtin
HB Thomas Corr Sheezel
C Scott Wardlaw Goater
HF Stephenson Comben Zurhaar
FF Watson Larkey Curtis
R Grundy LDU Simpkin
I Hollands Phillips Powell George
S Bergman

E McKercher Sanders CCJ A.Reid Taylor Tucker Greenwood Archer Harvey Xerri Drury Hansen Jnr.

Smith, Corr and Curtin as the three defensive talls. Thomas and Sheezel as the rebounding halfbacks. McDonald on a short leash as the lockdown defender with Arch waiting in the wings to step in if LMac has a bad stretch. There's Logue/McKay covered in a pinch

Curtin stepping in frees Goater up to play in his natural position on a wing. Scott as the more defensive winger while Goater with more natural pace can run and gun offensively

Comben back in to play foil to Larkey. Comben as a second ruck to cover Grundy whenever he needs a rest. Watson and Curtis at Larkey/Combens feet. Immediately more dangerous than Turner. Stephenson and Zurhaar pushing up to support as high half forwards with Zurhaar as the primary third forward.

Grundy starting ruck, Wardlaw as defensive centreman, Simpkin and LDU on the outside. Powell, Phillips as midfield cover; Thomas/Sheezel/Zurhaar/Curtin as a pinch in the guts.

Hollands as a switch for Stephenson/Zurhaar as a high half forward/wing. Could also run him off the HBF and push Sheezel forward. Bergman as a running HBF sub, but this could be McKercher, Greenwood, Harvey, Hansen Jnr depending on need.

Developing in the twos you've got McKercher as a wingman/HBF/centre rotation partner with Wardlaw, A.Reid as a swingman if Comben breaks in half, Taylor as a tagger, Tucker as a Swiss army knife, Sanders as an inside mid etc.

I think it's automatically a more dangerous team than we've put on the park at any point this year. It is heaps young but

There isn’t a reality where this isn’t a shit hot team to put in the park.

 

[Shermanator]

Are you lost

Nah, pretty sure the elevator doesn’t go all the way to the penthouse if you know what I mean..

 

[Pres]

Hollands has looked slow af - I wouldn’t be trading a f1 for him.
Got to be Flanders

We all know we won’t trade our f1 - so it’s a moot point

I watched Hollands closely in the GC ressies a few weeks back against Port Melbourne.

They were playing him exclusively on a wing. Really didn't get a lot of it and didn't look quick at all unfortunately. Worked hard both ways though.

Sharp looked a lot more likely on the other wing.

 

[danj]

As much as I love Goldy.

It's time.

Risky unless we can trade in a ready made ruck. If we don’t do that and let Goldie go then we will essentially be playing with vfl/no ruck, which could work for us if that’s part of the new game plan I gues but TBH I think we keep him unless we have a bonafide ruck replacement