List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

What utter tripe, Michalanney would have been scouted the same as any other youngster showing talent through the junior pathway. It's not his job to identify him as a F/S especially knowing the circumstances.

Whose job is it?

 

[George Kramer]

Whose job is it?

The laundry guy

 

[Sanders]

Anyone else notice that our high end draftees look their best in their first year, early doors and after a few years “development” look way worse than when they first came through the door?

 

[Geoffa32]

What utter tripe, Michalanney would have been scouted the same as any other youngster showing talent through the junior pathway. It's not his job to identify him as a F/S especially knowing the circumstances.

So you agree with Trigger?

Our best first round draft pick in nearly 10 years, Hamish had nothing to with selection.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[George Kramer]

So you agree with Trigger?

Our best first round draft pick in nearly 10 years, Hamish had nothing to with selection.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

And we was bid on earlier than expected by Sydney who just wanted to make us pay, so he snuck into first round by default.

 

[Danger in Texas]

So you agree with Trigger?

Our best first round draft pick in nearly 10 years, Hamish had nothing to with selection.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Nothing to do with it is probably over the top, we obviously saw him as worthy of selecting in the first round. That’s compared to say a Keeler type, who we straight up rejected

‘Fell into our lap’ is probably a more accurate description

 

[GROTTO]

First round picks since 2016


Gallucci pick 15
Fogarty 12
Jones 9
McHenry 16
McAsey 6
Thilthorpe 2
Pedlar 11
Rachele 6
Michalanney 17
Curtin 8

Our rebuild of the AFC can be summarized with this list with why we are in the position we are in.

 

[Eagleboy2011]

First round picks since 2016


Gallucci pick 15
Fogarty 12
Jones 9
McHenry 16
McAsey 6
Thilthorpe 2
Pedlar 11
Rachele 6
Michalanney 17
Curtin 8

Throw in what we gave up for Fog and the cost of the Gibbs transfer that year.
In Gooch's year PA picked up SPP and Marshall straight after Gooch. Marshall has done more than Fog imho.

 

[George Kramer]

Both Edwards and Ryan are 1st round picks..

In name only, someone picked 20s and later isn’t a first rounder, it’s only because of the AFLs bullshit they are classified as one

 

[GROTTO]

Throw in what we gave up for Fog and the cost of the Gibbs transfer that year.
In Gooch's year PA picked up SPP and Marshall straight after Gooch. Marshall has done more than Fog imho.

It gets better as I remember this time period really well in the draft.

We took Milera with Danger compensation which we always have bitched and complained about, however we didnt take the player after Milera because he had some off field issues at the time.

Would we have complained about Danger compo if we took Charlie Curnow who went next after Milera?

 

[GROTTO]

Throw in what we gave up for Fog and the cost of the Gibbs transfer that year.
In Gooch's year PA picked up SPP and Marshall straight after Gooch. Marshall has done more than Fog imho.

lol, like we went out of our way to chose the worst person to get with Gooch from that draft, given the players that came immediately after.
Any player after Gooch would have made a better contribution to our team.

 

[GROTTO]

Our list management does seem a bit scattegun though, maybe if I put myself forward as a cat B rookie they'll use their random number draft generator and I'll be picked

Only Picked? lol.

With the AFC, you are more likely to be also part of our leadership group.

 

[GROTTO]

With Curnow there was also strong word around that he was a big flight risk if drafted interstate.

That flight risk is always a variable with most players drafted outside your home state.

 

[BunjiMac]

Our football philosophy and system is completely broken.

We need to move on from holding up "effort" as the example and standard.

Effort should be a hygiene factor and those who actually execute should be what we highlight as the standard.

We need an administration that appreciates this.

I don't give a s**t how you do in practice if you perform on game day under pressure then that is the example of leadership Im holding up.

 

[GROTTO]

So just need another 21 first-round father-sons to build a team?

There’s Welsh and the other Michelanney, so we only need 19 more.

I see 4 potential elite mids in this picture, at least, so 15 to go.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

There had been 1 SA player taken through the old SANFL Father/Son rule that I can recall Brett Ebert son of the legendary Russel Ebert in the very early 2000's so is it really a surprise some 20 years later a son of a former Norwood SANFL players was missed by everyone other than former Norwood coach Peter Rhode?
There was also plenty of conjecture re Max's eligibility at the time also?

So is it his job or not?

Or is it someone else's at the club?

 

[BunjiMac]

This recruitment team at the AFC really have the best job in football.

No accountability, immune to criticism and it's fine just as long as they trying their best.

Something familiar here...

 

[Crow-eater]

With Milera out for the season, we can now put him on the inactive list, which will give us a spot in the MSD.

 

[George Kramer]

This recruitment team at the AFC really have the best job in football.

No accountability, immune to criticism and it's fine just as long as they trying their best.

Something familiar here...

In hindsight

 

[Eagleboy2011]

With Milera out for the season, we can now put him on the inactive list, which will give us a spot in the MSD.

We don't treat the MSD seriously. Sloane may appear soon?

 

[hugecannon]

Do have our own 2nd round pick this year or just Melbourne’s?

 

[Peter Doherty]

Do have our own 2nd round pick this year or just Melbourne’s?

We have both.

Full set of our own picks plus Melbourne's 2nd.

 

[Danger in Texas]

We have both.

Full set of our own picks plus Melbourne's 2nd.

Nah Saints have our second, we traded it to upgrade to Curtin (Giants then on traded to St K)

 

[Peter Doherty]

Nah Saints have our second, we traded it to upgrade to Curtin (Giants then on traded to St K)

Yeah, just looking again and Lore's spreadsheet doesn't look right.

 

[FR0GGY]

Our football philosophy and system is completely broken.

We need to move on from holding up "effort" as the example and standard.

Effort should be a hygiene factor and those who actually execute should be what we highlight as the standard.

We need an administration that appreciates this.

I don't give a s**t how you do in practice if you perform on game day under pressure then that is the example of leadership Im holding up.

Exactly, if we actually had selection integrity effort would come naturally instead of it being the reason they are picked in the first place.