Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2024 List Management thread - Trade Targets Part 2

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wasn't there talk a couple of months ago about Brent Daniels? After watching him today I'd give up what we will use on Bolton to get him in.
 
Agree to disagree.

We need two small forwards and some class in our midfield, and that is if Sturt signs.

Would take Bolton for pick 7, but can't afford to give up multiple picks for him.
The compromise would be only to take Bolton and not Baker as well . Elite talent in a position we need and good picks left over to fill our other needs
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Not Wagner. He was good…or Walker for that matter
Wasn’t meaning Walker.
(pointing out he was already tied up so we didn’t have another small who could do a lockdown job)

Yea Wagner was ok and like what he brings but it’s a no brainer with regards to him or baker
Not sure how anyone could possibly think otherwise
The fact remains defensively he’s still a liability.

As I said with walkers hands full with jones we needed another accountable small defender and baker would’ve been perfect for Daniels- who destroyed us.

It’s not as tho baker can’t offer what Wagner offers on offence either
 
Oh your serious!?

Miss banfields contribution today?
What about Jonnos?, omeara ?
How about Wagner down back?
With Walker hands full with jones Daniels absolutely torched us… need to go on?
Walker was on Jones but Daniels torching us was his fault? Cmon..
Walker was moved around today.
 
Aish, O’Meara, Banfield, Emmett, Walters will be gone soon.
Fyfe. Sharp if he keeps playing like that, Johnson
I don't really think Baker is replacing Walters, Bolton would be. He isn't replacing Fyfe. Not needle moving for Aish. Emmett isn't playing. Nod could replace O'Meara now. Bana's could be replaced by a resting mid ir possibly Simpson. Sharp isn't used to playing full seasons by the looks.
I don't mind getting him for a second rounder otherwise not that fussed.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I don't really think Baker is replacing Walters, Bolton would be. He isn't replacing Fyfe. Not needle moving for Aish. Emmett isn't playing. Nod could replace O'Meara now. Bana's could be replaced by a resting mid ir possibly Simpson. Sharp isn't used to playing full seasons by the looks.
I don't mind getting him for a second rounder otherwise not that fussed.

He can replace Fyfe. Fyfe is finished.
And we don’t have enough class, and those guys are all rotating through.

Is SPS on will get there but he’s not now. And we need to be contending
 
Whose place would Baker take that would shift the needle

Actually think this is a pretty good question.

In my mind he’s 100% best 22 and 100% improves us but I am quite curious as to how we use him if he’s playing for us next season. He could replace a number of different players, including players that IMO we shouldn’t be thinking of replacing.
 
How much will we need to give up for both Bolton and Baker?

Doubt we have much left.
This draft class is apparently quite deep and we have a recruiting team which is elite at spotting talent. I'd rather for once have an off-season where even before you account for youth taking steps the best 22 improves (genuinely on paper probably hasn't happened since the 2018 off season), and then give them enough list spots and picks to fill the gaps.

Gotta be ruthless with the list. Looking at the 2021 off season - delisted 4 players who played a combined 33 games that season (Bewley, Duman, Conca and Watson), and delisted then re-rookied 2 further in-contract who played a combined 29 (Blakely and Crowden).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top