List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading

[CryptoCrow]

I'm still not sure whether it's talent identification or talent development. One, or both, are definitely broken - I just don't know which.

 

[FullyBigKPro]

I'm just nervous discussing any trade using our first round pick this year if its a top ~6 pick in supposedly a gun Midfield draft.

We desperately need a gun generational midfielder.

Lukosius and Cumming would be very nice a the right prices but not desperate needs for us.

 

[OccamsRazorRay]

Horrendous thought.

Is our Defence too tall with Murray coming back? Murray and Butts IMO are the only two true KPD's on our team

Curtin could certainly slip into defence in the absence of Butts, but who would he knock out with the return of Murray?

I don't think a backline of (in height order) Curtin, Murray, Worrell & Keane works.

I understand Curtin could certainly prove useful eventually in other areas of the park, but his development will be in defence.

We've been absolutely rooted several times this year by small forwards so i don't think going super tall will be feasible.

Great problem to have!

 

[GreyCrow]

I'm just nervous discussing any trade using our first round pick this year if its a top ~6 pick in supposedly a gun Midfield draft.

We desperately need a gun generational midfielder.

Lukosius and Cumming would be very nice a the right prices but not desperate needs for us.

These are the moments good list managers get paid for

Create the space ,start talking to players and managers, ask questions

The worst thing we can do is shuffle names and say we tried our best

Welcome to the club 28 year old journeyman

 

[Carn The Texan]

My view on the players above

I feel like the club is more likely to keep McHenry on than Sholl

 

[GreyCrow]

Parnell season ending shoulder injury likely to see him moved off the list

Sad way to go but for the best

 

[Crows I Am]

Nothing more overrated than draft picks, especially when we're picking. Worth our current first rounder at pick 4? If it was phillipou I'd definitely trade pick 4, not sure for Luko, but I'd still probably say it's worth it.

The possible pick 4 probably wouldn't be a much better player, thats if we even happened to pick the right player.

Gold Coast have had history with letting players go cheaply to get them off their books if they decide they are not part of their future plans. There is a chance we could get him on the cheap at the end of this year if he requests a trade. Might be able to use a 2nd rounder?

If they did demand our first then no way we should be doing that trade this year, we need to use that pick on the best mid available.

 

[Crows I Am]

I feel like the club is more likely to keep McHenry on than Sholl

Yes likely, or they will do something stupid like keeping them both.

 

[King Elvis]

GC also have a ton of academy picks coming through - does that mean they'll need a ton of draft capital?

Would also been talking to a few of the Western Bulldogs guys, likely to be some quality guys in the prime age range looking to move on.

 

[1990crow]

Absolutely love to have Jack but not at any cost.
King and Walter appear to be favoured as KPFs at GC. And probably fair enough too.

I’d be willing to offer a future first and a player.
Murphy, Laird, McHenry, Milera, Sholl, Gollant?

Nothing more.

 

[Crow till I die]

Gold Coast have had history with letting players go cheaply to get them off their books if they decide they are not part of their future plans. There is a chance we could get him on the cheap at the end of this year if he requests a trade. Might be able to use a 2nd rounder?

If they did demand our first then no way we should be doing that trade this year, we need to use that pick on the best mid available.

More likely our F1 IF they are looking at moving him on as he still has 2 years to go on contract. But if that was the price, then count me in. As we preserve our 1st this year for the midfielder - nothing else and the use points for Welsh and hope he does not rise inside the top 10

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Just ditch whatever picks it takes to get Luko. He has been vocal about wanting to play forward. I'd even move Fog on if it mean getting him.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

https://www.adelaidenow.com.au/news/opinion/andrew-capel-time-is-right-for-adelaide-to-bring-caleb-daniel-and-harrison-petty-home/news-story/c9ae033af7b722168875b6895bf102b4?utm_campaign=EditorialSB&utm_source=The+Advertiser&utm_medium=Facebook&utm_content=SocialBakers

 

[El Doederino]

Good mate of Rozee

Wrong. Rozee has no mates.

 

[Grooster24]

I'm just nervous discussing any trade using our first round pick this year if its a top ~6 pick in supposedly a gun Midfield draft.

We desperately need a gun generational midfielder.

Lukosius and Cumming would be very nice a the right prices but not desperate needs for us.

Use future picks for trade.
Go to draft this year.

 

[El Doederino]

Once he fills out? He's 24 this year, I don't see him getting much bigger

He’d want to. Mass and strength peak in your 30’s.

 

[Danger in Texas]

GC also have a ton of academy picks coming through - does that mean they'll need a ton of draft capital?

Would also been talking to a few of the Western Bulldogs guys, likely to be some quality guys in the prime age range looking to move on.

Dale is the one I’d love, but I’m not sure he’d be the most available

I’d take Daniel for pick 30-odd

 

[Firewalker]

Extra mid-season pick opens up with Parnell’s injury… bit of a broken record but I’ve wanted an extra genuine dangerous small forward on the list for a couple of years given Rankine & Rachele are needed higher up the ground and the McHenry & Murphy crud-duo, this goal on the weekend made me think of this guy yet again… Crows were keen a few years ago, still only 23.

 

[King Elvis]

More likely our F1 IF they are looking at moving him on as he still has 2 years to go on contract. But if that was the price, then count me in. As we preserve our 1st this year for the midfielder - nothing else and the use points for Welsh and hope he does not rise inside the top 10

We need to use the GC/Geelong trade (Bowers?) where they gave him away to clear the salary, as the template.

 

[arrowman]

No, we move him on when he is no longer performing.

Make the call towards the end of the year.

Yes, and if he's still performing he gets another year, and he may go off the cliff in that year, and I'd be OK with that "one year too long".

 

[hugecannon]

Parnell season ending shoulder injury likely to see him moved off the list

Sad way to go but for the best

Is he on the primary list or rookie?

 

[Crowstar]

So Milera, Parnell and possibly Sloane (retire) or Thilthorpe (shut down) could potentially open 4 mid season list spots.
Essentially free hits. You'd have to have a crack at 2 atleast.
Toby Murray and ?

 

[Vader]

Is he on the primary list or rookie?

Rookie, not that it makes any difference as far as the MSD is concerned.

 

[BRL121]

One from my left field: I've thought for many years that Essendon's No. 1 pick, McGrath, has performed well under expectations, but, watching him last week, I reckon we could do with his type. He has plenty of run and pretty good disposal. He would be a good back pocket, or McHenry upgrade. Should be gettable. Any thoughts?

 

[1990crow]

One from my left field: I've thought for many years that Essendon's No. 1 pick, McGrath, has performed well under expectations, but, watching him last week, I reckon we could do with his type. He has plenty of run and pretty good disposal. He would be a good back pocket, or McHenry upgrade. Should be gettable. Any thoughts?

He'd be good for half back. But we unfortunately already have a large contract with Milera.