Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

[JuddgementDay]

Whitfield and Parish
V
Stewart and Amon

2nd option.

Whitfield RD0 is a problem

 

[citizen-erased]

Phillips is a defender - the other are mids and/or forwards so not sure what you are trying to do.

you probably want Clark - so Reid, Clark & Windsor

Berry and Windsor play opening round - see how they go and might help you decide

Zach Reid i should have said

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Zach Reid i should have said

ahh my bad - I'll still go with Reid, Clark and Windsor as the best 3 of that bunch

 

[Jozza44]

Butters, Steele, Fisher

Vs

Dawson, Rozee, Windsor

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Butters, Steele, Fisher

Vs

Dawson, Rozee, Windsor

See what Windsor scores tonight, that might decide it for you.

 

[King Max]

Gulden + Marshall…
Or
Miller + English…

 

[VainGlorious]

Hai kents!

Lazzaro V Kerch V Windsor V HH V Mead for M7

Thanks in advance.

MWAH!

 

[VainGlorious]

Gulden + Marshall…
Or
Miller + English…

Tough one.

Miller and Breakfast

 

[JuddgementDay]

Hai kents!

Lazzaro V Kerch V Windsor V HH V Mead for M7

Thanks in advance.

MWAH!

HH

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Hai kents!

Lazzaro V Kerch V Windsor V HH V Mead for M7

Thanks in advance.

MWAH!

from a role perspective

HH, Lazz, Mead, Kerch, Windsor

unsure on the honey brew - Butters going off early helped in the praccy

 

[VainGlorious]

from a role perspective

HH, Lazz, Mead, Kerch, Windsor

unsure on the honey brew - Butters going off early helped in the praccy

Nelso made quite the compelling case re Mead.

I asked him if he thought that starting Mead would hold me in good stead for cash gen and what not, and this was his response

 

[Chronz]

Hai kents!

Lazzaro V Kerch V Windsor V HH V Mead for M7

Thanks in advance.

MWAH!

HH

 

[balmainforever]

Okay. I’ve locked English as R1
Grundy + Rankine
or
Gawn and Jordan

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Okay. I’ve locked English as R1
Grundy + Rankine
or
Gawn and Jordan

Grundy + Rankine

 

[Veer Right]

Martin v Miller

and why?

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Martin v Miller

and why?

Miller, will go close to 120, bye irrelevant I think he is great value.

 

[Scythe]

Martin v Miller

and why?

Miller comfortably. Set role, not relying on a DPP addition, proven scoring history, higher ceiling and higher floor.

 

[ubeaut]

HH

who's HH?

 

[Scythe]

who's HH?

Hustwaite

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

N.Martin & Heeney

V

Steele & Rankine

 

[buttox]

N.Martin & Heeney

V

Steele & Rankine

Steele and Rankine.
I'm not completely sold on n Martin. He's a good player but I think he's a better early upgrade target when you have more certainty around his DPP.

 

[Bob Butter]

N.Martin & Heeney

V

Steele & Rankine

Can you not find 20k extra to go Steele and Heeney? You can't really compare Steele and Martin. One guy has been an uber premo and averaged 113 the last four years and he was injured all of last season. I would must rather than than an unproven commodity in a new role. And people disregard Heeney but he's averaged 93.5 the last 7 seasons and looks to be spending more time in the middle this season. If he can average 95-100 he will be a top 6 forward based on last years averages. Rankine is once again an unproven commodity who may or may not take his game to the next level, but for 20k extra I think Heeney is the safer bet. I feel like 90-95 average is the best case for Rankine, whereas that may be closer to Heeneys floor, with 105ish being his ceiling. Only thing to consider is the double bye.

 

[St Steady]

sort of a simple one , looking at mid rooks that get dpp back


bonner v Mcergerkin +80k therabouts

have sheez,fishgull and ldu norf players atm , so thats a consideration (and finbar as loop)

 

[Tulendeena]

Reid v Fyfe

 

[St Steady]

Reid v Fyfe

ive been culling my old doods for young doods past few days and like my team better if that helps