List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[stavro#4]

Please be Flanders!!!

Wouldn’t surprise me if he was another one.

But I was and still am referring to Sam Walsh.

 

[unrelentingbelief]

we know who Benny Williams is REALLY working for.

Masterclass by Tex

What’s your take on all of this Jake? Still got a positive feeling re nas?

 

[Mowman]

Oscar Adams looking ok would rather than Aleer

 

[SainterinSydney]

Please be Flanders!!!

 

[Mowman]

If we survive this and Nas stays, I could almost guarantee SOS and his ego will be offering the keys of Moorabbin to Butters as a FA next year.

It will be another injury riddle Carlton player

 

[MightySaint]

I cannot stress how much I want Flanders over Walsh. I actively do not want Walsh, but stupid sexy would be amazing!

 

[Saint Shags]

I'll post what I want to. You aren't a mod.

No but you can disagree with someone without being a campaigner

 

[MightySaint]

No but you can disagree with someone without being a campaigner

100% this. Rude to every single poster he disagrees with.

 

[SaintyMcSaintface]

Only the Pope is infallible, maybe we should get him posting here.

Damn mentioned religion again

Papal infallibility only counts on the field. Off the field, he could still be a sinful jerk

 

[Captain Paddy]

Campaigner Paddy put an end to it yesterday.

They’ll write stories about it

 

[Joffaboy]

No but you can disagree with someone without being a campaigner

Who am I disagreeing with? Some posters telling us what and not to post.

Again I will post what I want within the rules. Don't like it, put me on ignore champ.

 

[Diehard Saint]

You aren't doing a Captain Paddy on us, are you?

You know that little piece of punctuation called a hyphen?
In this context it has a very important meaning…

 

[sasaint]

Wouldn’t surprise me if he was another one.

But I was and still am referring to Sam Walsh.

If that is the case, and I have no reason to doubt you, I am worried that SOS seems to only go after Carlton players. That has got to be a concern. Is SOS just trying to get even with the Blues rather than get the best for the Saints?

 

[Saint Shags]

Who am I disagreeing with? Some posters telling us what and not to post.

Again I will post what I want within the rules. Don't like it, put me on ignore champ.

No, you thought you'd be a campaigner in a completely separate post. Where the other poster wasn't even involved.

You were doing doing it to be a smart arse. And being called out on it has your back up.

Fact is that Wolf was the one who posted about Nas' family. Someone decided to make a joke about a Fatwa. All Wolf asked was for that not to be used in a joke. You disagreed in reply to that one. Which everyone is free to do.

You followed it up in a totally unrelated post by me. A completely different poster.
That there is troll behaviour. You wanted to try and agitate.

 

[Captain Paddy]

Who am I disagreeing with? Some posters telling us what and not to post.

Again I will post what I want within the rules. Don't like it, put me on ignore champ.

I love disagreeing with the 4-5 people on twitter that post about the saints like they’ve got inside scoops.

I can post a bullsh*t rumour on here and one of them is a lock to report it as fact from one of their “sources”

 

[stavro#4]

If that is the case, and I have no reason to doubt you, I am worried that SOS seems to only go after Carlton players. That has got to be a concern. Is SOS just trying to get even with the Blues rather than get the best for the Saints?

Walsh very unhappy at Carlton and is of interest to others aswell.

Imagine if he sorts whatever his issue is there out. He stays.

Geelong also keen as per cal Twomey and I dare say if he ended up there we would have people annoyed sos wasn’t sniffing

 

[Diehard Saint]

We went after Stengle last year so wouldn't be surprised if we went after Ryan. We need more creative forwards.

Not ancient ones ( list-speaking wise)

 

[snails13]

Hey I'm not religious but the new rule is no mention of sky fairy's or their proclamations unless some posters have to retreat to their safe space.

Edit: reckon Christ would rather be crucified again than have to go to SA.

You do know your a Saint,Joffa

 

[littlecreatures]

The club is aware/of the belief he wants to stay. Infact their belief is that there isn’t even ACTIVE negotiations happening with either SA clubs. By which I mean Williams going back and forth putting each offer on the table and putting them against each other. They are aware they are making offers and so they should.

And still no club has approached us to discuss what a trade would need to look like.

That is why there is zero pressure being applied to the player.

Everything is zeroed in on Williams. Hence yesterday’s leak back to Morris.

Which, fair play to the club for outing this Tex Wanganeen story. Whether you agree with the actual action of potentially recruiting a delisted afl player to retain their cousin or not. They have put the ball publicly back in the agents/players court.

Go home to family vs give your cousin another crack the big time

SA friends vs Vic friends

They have matched the key points here.

What’s the rough terms of the updated contract that the club has put forward to Nas early this week to late last week Stav?

 

[Diehard Saint]

Can you imagine trying to spin this at trade week end.
'Sure we lost the best generational talent in decades at this club for a packet of Tim Tam's and Travis Boak, but we got a new middling ruckman and reserve back for 2.5 million a year plus a past it selfish front running small forward for the great price of our first rounder'

Don’t even…….please

 

[Joffaboy]

You do know your a Saint,Joffa

You're

 

[Yawkey way]

Spent many years on Saintsational just like yourself.
Tony has had some good info. He has also had some very incorrect info.

Last thing I wouldn't like to see is posters targeted for the information being incorrect in the end.

And im not sure why the need to be a smart arse comment with the religion aspect. Was asked as a consideration by

Yeah look if we want to go down that route we’ll have multiple perma bans and no one on here. You can’t discuss some topics on the random thread. We already have rules and nothing I’ve seen is even remotely offensive compared to what’s generally acceptable so let’s leave it there.

I cannot stress how much I want Flanders over Walsh. I actively do not want Walsh, but stupid sexy would be amazing!

Walsh is a gun, if fit he’s instantly our best mid who’s a mix of inside/outside imo he’s so much better than Flanders it’s crazy.

The proviso is of course if fit, you’d want to make dam sure you had all his medical info and the examination was thorough.

Happy to trade a 1st and pay him plenty, it’s a move that actually makes sense imo.

 

[TheJackal]

Walsh very unhappy at Carlton and is of interest to others aswell.

Imagine if he sorts whatever his issue is there out. He stays.

Geelong also keen as per cal Twomey and I dare say if he ended up there we would have people annoyed sos wasn’t sniffing

I've been big on Walsh all year. Much like the many on here who didnt want to touch Smith lest year, class is class and we have nowhere near enough of it so we just have to go for it!

 

[Diehard Saint]

The club is aware/of the belief he wants to stay. Infact their belief is that there isn’t even ACTIVE negotiations happening with either SA clubs. By which I mean Williams going back and forth putting each offer on the table and putting them against each other. They are aware they are making offers and so they should.

And still no club has approached us to discuss what a trade would need to look like.

That is why there is zero pressure being applied to the player.

Everything is zeroed in on Williams. Hence yesterday’s leak back to Morris.

Which, fair play to the club for outing this Tex Wanganeen story. Whether you agree with the actual action of potentially recruiting a delisted afl player to retain their cousin or not. They have put the ball publicly back in the agents/players court.

Go home to family vs give your cousin another crack the big time

SA friends vs Vic friends

They have matched the key points here.

So we’re not offering a small-holding. Or his mom a Cotton On franchise. We’ll do it our way.

 

[Yawkey way]

No, you thought you'd be a campaigner in a completely separate post. Where the other poster wasn't even involved.

You were doing doing it to be a smart arse. And being called out on it has your back up.

Fact is that Wolf was the one who posted about Nas' family. Someone decided to make a joke about a Fatwa. All Wolf asked was for that not to be used in a joke. You disagreed in reply to that one. Which everyone is free to do.

You followed it up in a totally unrelated post by me. A completely different poster.
That there is troll behaviour. You wanted to try and agitate.

Where were you on thousands of other occasions ? Selective outrage.