List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[Joffaboy]

TDK is Brad Hill all over again, nice but not a need

And many will agree in 5 years time

Hill cost half of TDK and we weren't about to lose a generational player. I dont need 5 years to agree with you.

 

[SainterinSydney]

Old mate Whitlock with 3 possies at Cattery. According to Port, he should get a trade done for Nas lol

 

[Thirsty_NeedBeer]

Not set in concrete, but after that post game interview, I’m somewhat confident he’s staying. Dude would be an elite Poker player. Gives away nothing.

 

[Barrels]

A few weeks ago, Marshall was a hobbling ruckman who can’t ruck all that well, Moose was a dud who was going to be delisted, and Dodson was miles off it.

Now we’re saying no to TDK because of them.

Never change, you magnificent idiots…

 

[jwikked]

A few weeks ago, Marshall was a hobbling ruckman who can’t ruck all that well, Moose was a dud who was going to be delisted, and Dodson was miles off it.

Now we’re saying no to TDK because of them.

Never change, you magnificent idiots…

If TDK kicks 6 goals today he’ll be worth every bit of $2mil. Until next weeks game, of course

 

[Joffaboy]

A few weeks ago, Marshall was a hobbling ruckman who can’t ruck all that well, Moose was a dud who was going to be delisted, and Dodson was miles off it.

Now we’re saying no to TDK because of them.

Never change, you magnificent idiots…

So you haven't watched football for two months?
None so blind than those who won't see, or whatever the f##k then saying is.

Edit: nice to go with the insults just because some of us think the club can actually make poor decisions.

 

[Sainter62]

Anyone notice that Nas wasn't interested in singing the club song in the rooms ...... not a good sign ...... maybe the doomsayers are right and the interview was all cliches

 

[Joffaboy]

Anyone notice that Nas wasn't interested in singing the club song in the rooms ...... not a good sign ...... maybe the doomsayers are right and the interview was all cliches

None of them were. Most lacklustre rendition I have ever heard.

 

[SainterinSydney]

Anyone notice that Nas wasn't interested in singing the club song in the rooms ...... not a good sign ...... maybe the doomsayers are right and the interview was all cliches

Huh? He was holding one of Brad Hill's kids during it and had his back to the camera.

 

[Joffaboy]

Surely he can't go to Port, they are an unholy rabble

 

[Barrels]

So you haven't watched football for two months?
None so blind than those who won't see, or whatever the f##k then saying is.

Edit: nice to go with the insults just because some of us think the club can actually make poor decisions.

I make no comment on the right or wrong-ness of the comments themselves, but on the utterly bipolar nature of this board.

So have a Bex and a lie down.

 

[phantom13]

None of them were. Most lacklustre rendition I have ever heard.

We beat north at 1.40 on a Sunday when no one gave a **** about the game.

I barely watched the last 10 minutes and I was at marvel. If Nas wandered up to the goat bar for the last 15 minutes I would have cast no judgement at all.

 

[Moquo]

Surely he can't go to Port, they are an unholy rabble

They are playing like the hottest girl in town didn't turn up to watch

 

[gubby88]

There's basically 2 possibilities going forward.
1. Either Nas leaves and Mowman will shit on the club
Or
2. Nas stays and Mowman will still shit on the club.
I think it'll be either 1, or 2..

1. Nas leaves ..Sos's fault
2. Nas stays...Sos's fault because there's no salary cap

 

[stavro#4]

So you haven't watched football for two months?
None so blind than those who won't see, or whatever the f##k then saying is.

Edit: nice to go with the insults just because some of us think the club can actually make poor decisions.

Barrels has probably seen more football blind than most have seen with perfect vision.

Knows his stuff

 

[saintbill]

Port are getting smoked. They look terrible.

 

[Barrels]

Barrels has probably seen more football blind than most have seen with perfect vision.

Knows his stuff

Well that assessment calls all your others into question…

 

[stavro#4]

Well that assessment calls all your others into question…

Oh please, this place is a better place when you are a regular and our draft stuff is

 

[Joffaboy]

Barrels has probably seen more football blind than most have seen with perfect vision.

Knows his stuff

ok.
So because we can see we have great depth in the rucks but kool aide drinkers think SOS shits diamonds and can do no wrong, we are all idiots?
We have seen the development on NWM and his value rise, but when developing rucks are improving and developing at a rapid rate we just ignore that and bring in another middling ruckman on money 200k more than they are willing to offer NAZ?
Ok you guys are absolute guru's and none of us should have an opinion because barrels has watched footy .

FMD you lot are so full of yourselves.

 

[saintbill]

A few weeks ago, Marshall was a hobbling ruckman who can’t ruck all that well, Moose was a dud who was going to be delisted, and Dodson was miles off it.

Now we’re saying no to TDK because of them.

Never change, you magnificent idiots…

The size of TDK's contract has had most people nervous from the outset to be fair, even when he was in form.

Throw in 10 weeks of crap footy, the price of NAS, Windy, Hall all going through the roof, Dodson showing signs etc. I think it is all pretty reasonable.

 

[Mr Clunk]

 

[Joffaboy]

The size of TDK's contract has had most people nervous from the outset to be fair, even when he was in form.

Throw in 10 weeks of crap footy, the price of NAS, Windy, Hall all going through the roof, Dodson showing signs etc. I think it is all pretty reasonable.

Don't be an idiot, others have watched footy.

 

[Mr Clunk]

And for those who wouldn't mind a parrot added

 

[saintkildaman]

Those questioning TDK since Moose’s emergence need to consider that the sub rule is most likely going next year meaning there’ll be 5 on the bench. I think you’ll see most teams playing 2 rucks, a TDK/Roma combination would be one of the best pairings in the comp. Heath and Dodson develop in the VFL and cover any injuries, this would have to be the best ruck depth we’ve had on our list since I can remember.

 

[SainterinSydney]

Jeez, old Kenny and his lads stinking it up at the Cattery. Not exactly making it an appealing prospect to play for them.