List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[Captain Paddy]

I’ve been calling it out since it stared, if he walks you won’t miss him half as much as you think.

This is an insane take

 

[70s sainter]

I’ve been calling it out since it stared, if he walks you won’t miss him half as much as you think.

Ahhh , now I get it . Coping mechanism. I need to get on board I think .

 

[Joffaboy]

Ahhh , now I get it . Coping mechanism. I need to get on board I think .

 

[Captain Paddy]

Averaging like 35 and 1.5 goals as a mid.

Runs full tilt and then pulls out a bullet pass without breaking stride

We’ve got a genuine freak on our hands

 

[SG34]

I know you all hate AI, so I won’t quote any of its ‘garbage’ here. But it told me that it’s 50/50 when it comes to players keeping silent and then staying. And it gave me details. I would t dare to spill such bile here. But I believe it’s a definite 50/50 that he’ll stay, based on that ‘bile’.

 

[mighty_sainters]

Averaging like 35 and 1.5 goals as a mid.

Runs full tilt and then pulls out a bullet pass without breaking stride

We’ve got a genuine freak on our hands

Just watched a few highlights of the weekend and forgot half of the stupidly good things he did.

Absolute freak.

 

[ARCHIE66]

Verdict








While nothing is final yet, all signs point toward Nasiah Wanganeen‑Milera staying at St Kilda for 2026 and potentially beyond, unless he surprises with a request to return home to South Australia. The Saints seem to have the best combination of money, support, and promise—and his manager’s statement frames staying as the most likely outcome.

 

[stfan]

Posted by BackfromUSA on SS unsure of accuracy/history:


“Multiple VERY good sources say he will sign, but then again, I had an impeccable source that Lyon would sign that next morning as coach and he walked to Freo the next morning. I am told that the cost of NAS will mean that one lined up recruit may not be afforded unless a back ended deal can be swung - and it is not TDK - or we sacrifice current players.

Who could foresee that the value of NAS would double this year AND 50% alone in the past 6 or 7 weeks.”

Is a well known on SS. SS would not still be running without him, though he is less active in the running now.
From posts over many, many years is known to have good contacts inside the Club.

 

[stfan]

The one thing im really struggling with is all this talk that we had massive room in the cap. Enough to offer TDK 1.7 and throw out 2m to Rowell to see if he was at all keen.

Now surely we still have that 2m laying around. And even if we were originally putting aside a max of 1.2 it still means that we should have plenty spare.

What are we missing? We've been told that we have been better with our contracts and having money 'saved'

Pretty simple really, Nas's recent form after moving to the midfield has greatly increased both his future contract $$$$, and his trade price.

This has all happened only over the last month.

I mean hand on heart, would you have thought at the start of this season that by season's end that Nas would be rated in the Top 5 in the AFL and be just about the hottest property up for grabs this trade period?

 

[Teflon]

Verdict








While nothing is final yet, all signs point toward Nasiah Wanganeen‑Milera staying at St Kilda for 2026 and potentially beyond, unless he surprises with a request to return home to South Australia. The Saints seem to have the best combination of money, support, and promise—and his manager’s statement frames staying as the most likely outcome.

Thanks for the AI read out….

 

[SainterinSydney]

Thanks for the AI read out….

Wait, are you saying Anthony 74 2.0 is just an AI...

 

[True Believer]

I know you all hate AI, so I won’t quote any of its ‘garbage’ here. But it told me that it’s 50/50 when it comes to players keeping silent and then staying. And it gave me details. I would t dare to spill such bile here. But I believe it’s a definite 50/50 that he’ll stay, based on that ‘bile’.

Be careful what you say!!

The borg can hear you..!!!

 

[HunterClarksHeadband]

Bongos for longer being an inside joke between NWM, Ro and Windy.... all not in the RWB next year

 

[tomjoad]

Ok check his stats for turnovers and clangers, then cheapies. What you won’t see is hard ball gets, we have given him free rein. It’s not helping us, you think the Nas feast got us up over north but you have it all wrong. The Nas feast if killing us, we were better when he played his role.

I think NAS is our best player, nonetheless, I see your point. I've noticed the cheap possessions too over the last month. He's being used for every play, and not always for the best play.

 

[dudeintheswamp]

Well if it ain't C U Next Tuesday maybe it's...

Wednesday
And
Nas
Knows
Everyone's
Restless

 

[Grav]

I think NAS is our best player, nonetheless, I see your point. I've noticed the cheap possessions too over the last month. He's being used for every play, and not always for the best play.

Wonder if that was our idea to get his price to skyrocket, to hopefully scare off any suitors?

 

[Dr Spaceman]

I Don’t Know if the In The Knows actually know any known facts or if they are knowingly spouting unknowns as knowns.

I mean; who really knows?

 

[Windtagger]

Bongos for longer being an inside joke between NWM, Ro and Windy.... all not in the RWB next year

And Max Hall who resigned.

 

[Armitage2Riewoldt]

Just watched a few highlights of the weekend and forgot half of the stupidly good things he did.

Absolute freak.

He's gonna be close to the best in the game. He might not do it for us which will be heart destroying.

But jeez we picked and developed a genuine superstar. Haven't done that in a while.

 

[BrutThough]

Ok….Im scraping Reddit depths now…but sometimes…you just gotta do I guess…from SS

It says what I want it to say so it's an impeccable and reliable source.

 

[Armitage2Riewoldt]

Ok….Im scraping Reddit depths now…but sometimes…you just gotta do I guess…from SS

1.5 year old account, 10,000 karma (likes effectively). Lists themselves as a west coast supporter.

Not likely to be a troll.

I'll take it too.

 

[Longmembrey]

I asked A.I. if Nas is likely to stay. It said:

"Unsure, but I will give Ben Williams head cannon if he does"

Make of that what you will.

 

[puntking]

I feel if his wrong he needs a ban if right needs to be put on Ross shoulders

 

[CaptainRisky]

Verdict








While nothing is final yet, all signs point toward Nasiah Wanganeen‑Milera staying at St Kilda for 2026 and potentially beyond, unless he surprises with a request to return home to South Australia. The Saints seem to have the best combination of money, support, and promise—and his manager’s statement frames staying as the most likely outcome.

Talk about 50 cents each way LOL

 

[Saintpav]

Thought experiment:

Are Port or Crows fans confident of getting Naz?

You know it makes sense.