List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[SainterinSydney]

The joke is Cordy has the same amount of premierships as St Kilda...

 

[seesalswigs44]

Who da fug is this rooch guy

 

[stavro#4]

So don’t pay him the extra 100-200k from the $1.5m net win from the Rowell situation.

Again, glad you’re not an accountant.

I said we need more like Nas.

How are you paying them oh genius accountant.

 

[CHBench]

Wouldn’t want to be TDK at the saints if we loose nas. Even though they are exactly related the media and the fans will blame him

If I was TDKs manager I'd be lining up a back up destination. He will absolutely be part blamed for Nas leaving

 

[phantom13]

see, this is where journo's get hysterical, and it's then parroted, esp here on BF, as gospel

they hear the figure $1.7m and 7 years and go to town, $12m blah blah blah it's also not the agent's best interest to correct that figure.

but like nearly every other FA who has left, the deal is front-loaded and usually around that sum mentioned, but then smoothed out in the backend to discourage (Carlton in this case) from trying to match.

go have a look at the Daniher move to Brisbane as an example, high initial figure, then they renegotiated a longer deal and smoothed out the $

So again.

TDK blown out of proportion, nowhere near the reported figure.

Nas way under, miles over the reported figure.

Come on. Pick a lane.

 

[Tom12]

Not looking forward to the ensuing pain when Nas does leave.

The system is not built for a trade like this to happen.

 

[phantom13]

I said we need more like Nas.

How are you paying them oh genius accountant.

With the Rowell money you were so adamant we had and was burning a hole in our pocket.

 

[stavro#4]

see, this is where journo's get hysterical, and it's then parroted, esp here on BF, as gospel

they hear the figure $1.7m and 7 years and go to town, $12m blah blah blah it's also not the agent's best interest to correct that figure.

but like nearly every other FA who has left, the deal is front-loaded and usually around that sum mentioned, but then smoothed out in the backend to discourage (Carlton in this case) from trying to match.

go have a look at the Daniher move to Brisbane as an example, high initial figure, then they renegotiated a longer deal and smoothed out the $

Don’t speak common sense.

 

[stavro#4]

With the Rowell money you were so adamant we had and was burning a hole in our pocket.

So we are paying players more like Nas the Rowell money and you are giving Windy the Rowell money.


Rowell money for everyone according to Phantom.

 

[CaptainRisky]

He's been inconsistent most years.

A bit like a few on here

 

[Saint Shags]

I know a few posters who’ll believe this - it’s in a form of print

Not giving much credibility to it. But is the list that far beyond belief when 3 of 4 listed have been bandied about here and the media.
The only ridiculously sounding one is Wilkie.

 

[phantom13]

So we are paying players more like Nas the Rowell money and you are giving Windy the Rowell money.


Rowell money for everyone according to Phantom.

Rowell was $2m and Nas was $1.5m according to you.

Give Nas an extra $500k, give Windy and extra $100k. Leaves plenty for others.

Pretty simple math stav.

 

[botts]

Log off for an hour and we are loosing nas, windy, Wilkie and Steele. Pack it up

 

[Yawkey way]

There is no rubric for it. If Sydney want him they aren’t obliged to offer us anything close to a first. If Windy wants out it would get done for their second round pick. Probably pays for Aleer.

We’re stupid enough.

 

[BarkerFan]

No other team is gonna pay him that much, I like the guy, but that's a lot of money for his output so far.

I think Windy is under rated on this forum. Good player who is important to our future. Should be captain IMO as early as next year.

 

[St Neil]

A nice, uplifting read for your Monday. Thanks Buddy. I’ll be crying myself to sleep now.

Champion player, but as sharp as a cylinder full of paper clips.

Michel de Nostradame he is not.

 

[Tom12]

Log off for an hour and we are loosing nas, windy, Wilkie and Steele. Pack it up

There's a pretty realistic scenario where 3/4 of those players are not on the list next year, tbf

 

[jumperfan]

I heard Adelaide were generous enough to offer us Lachie Murphy for Nas, Wilkie, Steele, Marshall and Windhager.

 

[jumperfan]

There's a pretty realistic scenario where 3/4 of those players are not on the list next year, tbf

It's just a nothing tweet though. There's been rumours around 3 of them all year and I don't see the club letting Wilkie leave.

 

[Tom12]

It's just a nothing tweet though. There's been rumours around 3 of them all year and I don't see the club letting Wilkie leave.

Wilkie is not going to get moved. He's likely captaining the team next year, but it's pretty clear we have massive changes coming during the off-season. Everything is on the table, and it should be.

 

[Saintos The ITK]

Turner and Hooch should just go back to slobbering all over each other.

 

[StFly]

Log off for an hour and we are loosing nas, windy, Wilkie and Steele. Pack it up

Marshall also, we're rebuilding the rebuild cause rebuilding is fun and no one likes a finished model as less hammers and we already have Caminiti so he better be staying...

 

[St Neil]

Marshall, Wilkie and Steele are all contracted until the end of 2027.

This sort of shit is just embarrassing for the dolts who broadcast it.

 

[botts]

If we loose NAS and windy sos and probably bassat has to go. Genuine disaster. Why can’t we just be a normal football club

 

[gringo2011]

Marshall, Wilkie and Steele are all contracted until the end of 2027.

This sort of shit is just embarrassing for the dolts who broadcast it.

Only Wilkie hasn’t been mentioned so far. Perhaps we need the money for Aleer.