2025 Rolling ALL-Australian Team

Fadge · Apr 20, 2025

Libba having a massive year. Would be the first midfielder picked if the team was picked after this weekend.

eth-dog · Apr 20, 2025

Will do the combined goals/assists after the game tomorrow or more likely to be Tuesday but Riley Thilthorpe is first with 5 blokes on equal second at this stage

WalshistheGOAT · Apr 20, 2025

FB: Dayne Zorko - Sam Taylor - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera
HB: Lachie Whitfield - Jacob Weitering - Jack Sinclair

C: Hugh McCluggage - Matt Rowell - Andrew Brayshaw
F: Tom De Koning - Nick Daicos - Tom Liberatore

HF:Toby Greene - Josh Treacy - Ben Keays
FF: Ben Long - Riley Thilthorpe - Paul Curtis

I/C: Bailey Smith - Noah Anderson - Touk Miller - Zac Merrett

Unlucky - Caleb Serong, Ed Richards, Jordan Dawson

Going to be very hard to fit Bont, Butters, Rozee etc coming back from injury if they keep up their current form. A lot of players having very good seasons so far.

jakson68 · Apr 21, 2025

WalshistheGOAT said:
FB: Dayne Zorko - Sam Taylor - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera
HB: Lachie Whitfield - Jacob Weitering - Jack Sinclair

C: Hugh McCluggage - Matt Rowell - Andrew Brayshaw
F: Tom De Koning - Nick Daicos - Tom Liberatore

HF:Toby Greene - Josh Treacy - Ben Keays
FF: Ben Long - Riley Thilthorpe - Paul Curtis

I/C: Bailey Smith - Noah Anderson - Touk Miller - Zac Merrett

Unlucky - Caleb Serong, Ed Richards, Jordan Dawson

Going to be very hard to fit Bont, Butters, Rozee etc coming back from injury if they keep up their current form. A lot of players having very good seasons so far.

Great call on Paul Curtis, he is going along nicely.

South of the Yarra · Apr 21, 2025

Darcy Moore having a tremendous season

South of the Yarra · Apr 21, 2025

WalshistheGOAT

Yes, he is in most rolling All Australian Teams of balanced unbiased experts.

WalshistheGOAT · Apr 21, 2025

South of the Yarra said:
WalshistheGOAT

Yes, he is in most rolling All Australian Teams of balanced unbiased experts.

View attachment 2290154

Good luck getting that one past Cornes who describes him as the most gettable key defender in the comp. Pies have been good but Moore is still prone to getting flogged by a good KPF, Sam Darcy took him to the cleaners when they played one another.

South of the Yarra · Apr 21, 2025

WalshistheGOAT said:
Good luck getting that one past Cornes who describes him as the most gettable key defender in the comp. Pies have been good but Moore is still prone to getting flogged by a good KPF, Sam Darcy took him to the cleaners when they played one another.

Have a look how many contests Moore has lost this year then get back to me. Is in almost all teams.

South of the Yarra · Apr 21, 2025

WalshistheGOAT said:
Good luck getting that one past Cornes who describes him as the most gettable key defender in the comp. Pies have been good but Moore is still prone to getting flogged by a good KPF, Sam Darcy took him to the cleaners when they played one another.

Also in Sporting News

WalshistheGOAT · Apr 21, 2025

South of the Yarra said:
Have a look how many contests Moore has lost this year then get back to me. Is in almost all teams.

Have a look at his intercept marks and contested grabs this year compared to the best in the business Taylor, Weitering and Andrews.

Sam Darcy took 6 contested marks and kicked 4 on him a few weeks ago.

Still a way off the team for mine

Muddiemoose · Apr 21, 2025

South of the Yarra said:
Have a look how many contests Moore has lost this year then get back to me. Is in almost all teams.

He’s well behind the other big keys like weaters and even some of the smaller guys like Vlastuin are have better years

I like Moore but he’s definitely not in the frame for AA at this stage

Lindsay_Gilbee · Apr 21, 2025

WalshistheGOAT said:
FB: Dayne Zorko - Sam Taylor - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera
HB: Lachie Whitfield - Jacob Weitering - Jack Sinclair

C: Hugh McCluggage - Matt Rowell - Andrew Brayshaw
F: Tom De Koning - Nick Daicos - Tom Liberatore

HF:Toby Greene - Josh Treacy - Ben Keays
FF: Ben Long - Riley Thilthorpe - Paul Curtis

I/C: Bailey Smith - Noah Anderson - Touk Miller - Zac Merrett

Unlucky - Caleb Serong, Ed Richards, Jordan Dawson

Going to be very hard to fit Bont, Butters, Rozee etc coming back from injury if they keep up their current form. A lot of players having very good seasons so far.

Surely can’t pick that backline. Four of them don’t defend.

Have to pick a genuine third defender, probably Guthrie.

South of the Yarra · Apr 21, 2025

Muddiemoose said:
He’s well behind the other big keys like weaters and even some of the smaller guys like Vlastuin are have better years

I like Moore but he’s definitely not in the frame for AA at this stage

Yet most media outlets have him in the team. He has been the best defender in one of the best defences. Pies average 66 kicked against them having played 6 of last years finalists. Moore is the main reason why.

WalshistheGOAT · Apr 21, 2025

Lindsay_Gilbee said:
Surely can’t pick that backline. Four of them don’t defend.

Have to pick a genuine third defender, probably Guthrie.

Unfortunately actual defenders are rarely picked. If it were up to me I'd have an Idun or Ash type.

Same goes for Wings and HFF, nearly always end up with a couple of extra inside mids there instead of actual wings and HFFs

Lindsay_Gilbee · Apr 21, 2025

WalshistheGOAT said:
Unfortunately actual defenders are rarely picked. If it were up to me I'd have Idun or Ash type.

Same goes for Wings and HFF, nearly always end up with a couple of extra inside mids there instead of actual wings and HFFs

I’d much rather a third key tall or a medium defender, plenty of those to justify getting in.

Toump Ass · Apr 21, 2025

Max Gawn 10 clearances against Freo, slow start to the year but the big guy is coming for his 8th (count 'em, EIGHTH) AA!!!

Serong been very good this year, and that campaigner got SMASHED by Jack Viney, could be a smokie for a bench spot IMO.

Bowing probably winning Dees best and fairest currently, few Sainters lining up for that HBF role would be looking over their shoulders IMO.

Kozzie Pickett, 5 goals. BIG start to the season!!!

TheUnicorn · Apr 21, 2025

I wouldn't have Moore in AA discussion personally.

The Kings Ransom · Apr 21, 2025

WalshistheGOAT said:
Have a look at his intercept marks and contested grabs this year compared to the best in the business Taylor, Weitering and Andrews.

Sam Darcy took 6 contested marks and kicked 4 on him a few weeks ago.

Still a way off the team for mine

South of the Yarra said:
Have a look how many contests Moore has lost this year then get back to me. Is in almost all teams.

I don’t understand how these stats work.

AFL app saying he has lost 1 defensive contest all year. Yet Darcy put him to the sword.

Any ideas?

eth-dog · Apr 21, 2025

Combined goals and assists round 6:

1. Riley Thilthorpe 24 (16/8)
2. Josh Treacy 21 (18/3)/Ben King (18/3)/Jack Higgins (17/4)/Darcy Fogarty (16/5)/Taylor Walker (14/7)
7. Paul Curtis 20 (15/5)
8. Mitch Georgiades 19 (15/4)/Ben Long (13/6)
10. Toby Greene 18 (14/4)/Sam Darcy (14/4)/Ben Keays (12/6)

I think this is the first time I've had so many players from the one team in the top 10 (well, 12, but still). Shows how good Adelaide's forward line has been this year.

The Kings Ransom · Apr 21, 2025

eth-dog said:
Combined goals and assists round 6:

1. Riley Thilthorpe 24 (16/8)
2. Josh Treacy 21 (18/3)/Ben King (18/3)/Jack Higgins (17/4)/Darcy Fogarty (16/5)/Taylor Walker (14/7)
7. Paul Curtis 20 (15/5)
8. Mitch Georgiades 19 (15/4)/Ben Long (13/6)
10. Toby Greene 18 (14/4)/Sam Darcy (14/4)/Ben Keays (12/6)

I think this is the first time I've had so many players from the one team in the top 10 (well, 12, but still). Shows how good Adelaide's forward line has been this year.

By average to account for difference in number of games teams have played

1. Ben King 4.2
2. Riley Thilthorpe 4
3. Ben Long 3.8
4. Josh Treacy 3.5/Jack Higgins 3.5/Darcy Fogarty 3.5/Taylor Walker 3.5
8. Paul Curtis 3.3
9. Mitch Georgiades 3.2
10. Toby Greene 3 /Sam Darcy 3/Ben Keays 3

JHF1870 · Apr 21, 2025

South of the Yarra said:
WalshistheGOAT

Yes, he is in most rolling All Australian Teams of balanced unbiased experts.

View attachment 2290154

Can't take seriously if they are ignoring Hewitt

JHF1870 · Apr 21, 2025

Here are my top 21 players sorted by:

Game Votes

	POTY (Round 6)	AFL vote	AVG
1	George Hewett	19	69.75
2	Connor Rozee	17	60.67
3	Andrew Brayshaw	17	66.25
4	Noah Anderson	16	67.90
5	Matt Rowell	15	72.40
6	Max Gawn	15	62.00
7	Nick Daicos	15	63.25
8	Hugh McCluggage	15	58.17
9	Tom De Koning	14	62.08
10	Touk Miller	14	66.50
11	Jack Macrae	14	65.08
12	Izak Rankine	13	60.33
13	Ed Richards	13	58.75
14	Tom Green	13	66.10
15	Zak Butters	13	74.50
16	Jai Newcombe	13	62.92
17	Caleb Serong	12	63.08
18	Jordan Dawson	12	62.08
19	Tom Liberatore	11	64.08
20	Sam Darcy	11	54.83
21	Jake Soligo	11	56.00

By Total Score'

	POTY (Round 6)	Iscore	AFL vote	AVG
1	George Hewett	418.5	19	69.75
2	Andrew Brayshaw	397.5	17	66.25
3	Jack Macrae	390.5	14	65.08
4	Tom Liberatore	384.5	11	64.08
5	Nick Daicos	379.5	15	63.25
6	Caleb Serong	378.5	12	63.08
7	Jai Newcombe	377.5	13	62.92
8	Tom De Koning	372.5	14	62.08
9	Jordan Dawson	372.5	12	62.08
10	Max Gawn	372	15	62.00
11	Connor Rozee	364	17	60.67
12	Izak Rankine	362	13	60.33
13	Matt Rowell	362	15	72.40
14	Ed Richards	352.5	13	58.75
15	Hugh McCluggage	349	15	58.17
16	Noah Anderson	339.5	16	67.90
17	Jake Soligo	336	11	56.00
18	Touk Miller	332.5	14	66.50
19	Tom Green	330.5	13	66.10
20	Sam Darcy	329	11	54.83
21	Zak Butters	223.5	13	74.50

Lingsface · Apr 21, 2025

If Dangerfield isn’t in your forward line, you can have a good hard look at yourself.

eth-dog · Apr 21, 2025

The Kings Ransom said:
By average to account for difference in number of games teams have played

1. Ben King 4.2
2. Riley Thilthorpe 4
3. Ben Long 3.8
4. Josh Treacy 3.5/Jack Higgins 3.5/Darcy Fogarty 3.5/Taylor Walker 3.5
8. Paul Curtis 3.3
9. Mitch Georgiades 3.2
10. Toby Greene 3 /Sam Darcy 3/Ben Keays 3

Tell me you're a GC fan without telling me you're a GC fan

JHF1870 · Apr 21, 2025

Lingsface said:
If Dangerfield isn’t in your forward line, you can have a good hard look at yourself.

10 goals or more, sorted by average score. Cross reference with the total score given some players only played a few games

FORWARDS	POTY (Round 6)	GL	Iscore	AFL vote	AVG
1	Toby Greene	14	348.5	10	58.08
2	Jesse Hogan	15	165	5	55.00
3	Sam Darcy	14	329	11	54.83
4	Riley Thilthorpe	16	303	6	50.50
5	Ben Long	13	246.5	1	49.30
6	Patrick Dangerfield	14	289	2	48.17
7	Ben Keays	12	278.5	2	46.42
8	Taylor Walker	14	276.5	2	46.08
9	Jeremy Cameron	13	274	2	45.67
10	Josh Treacy	18	271	6	45.17
11	Paul Curtis	15	270		45.00
12	Jack Gunston	13	179		44.75
13	Zac Bailey	12	256.5		42.75
14	Mitch Georgiades	15	248		41.33
15	Ben King	18	199	2	39.80
16	Jack Higgins	17	235		39.17
17	Mitch Owens	11	189.5	1	37.90
18	Willie Rioli	10	226.5		37.75
19	Darcy Fogarty	16	226.5		37.75
20	Nick Larkey	17	220.5		36.75

Log In or Create New Account

2025 Rolling ALL-Australian Team

Hall of Famer

Tier 1 WW Player

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Moderator

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

The Big Deal

Premiership Player

Premiership Player

Tier 1 WW Player

Premiership Player

Premium Platinum

Premium Platinum

Norm Smith Medallist

Tier 1 WW Player

Premium Platinum

2025 Rolling ALL-Australian Team

Similar threads