List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread

[manicpie]

I agree that Reid is a risk. Could go on to be top 5 in the AFL or go the way of Stringer.

Not saying I want the above to occur, just spitballing a hypothetical.

The other problem is that we would have to recruit a decent ruckman, which makes it even more difficult. Although he's not showing it this year, my personal opinion is that in an environment he actually wants to be in, he is the next best player in the game behind Nick. It's worth looking at last year's highlights, we have seen that ever I don't think

 

[Bianconeri]

Beaches are prob the only thing WA has. Not a whole lot of things in perth otherwise.

What can you do in Melbourne that you can’t do in Perth?

 

[manicpie]

What can you do in Melbourne that you can’t do in Perth?

All the streets in Perth are one way if that helps

 

[Bianconeri]

All the streets in Perth are one way if that helps

Is this some kind of dirty joke gone over my head?

Anyways the streets in Melbourne have so many cars parked on them they end up one way.

 

[DopeMaster]

The other problem is that we would have to recruit a decent ruckman, which makes it even more difficult. Although he's not showing it this year, my personal opinion is that in an environment he actually wants to be in, he is the next best player in the game behind Nick. It's worth looking at last year's highlights, we have seen that ever I don't think

My gut feel is the same. So if rumours are true and WC are targeting Cameron/Allan due to Reid wanting to come to us - who’s available as a ready made ruck replacement?

As good as Cameron is, I’d cop a ruck downgrade to have the top two players in the comp for the next 10+ years.

 

[unplugged]

I feel like Harley Reid is tanking this year. As such, has Geelong all over it!

 

[jmac70]

My gut feel is the same. So if rumours are true and WC are targeting Cameron/Allan due to Reid wanting to come to us - who’s available as a ready made ruck replacement?

As good as Cameron is, I’d cop a ruck downgrade to have the top two players in the comp for the next 10+ years.

Rumours are rarely true. Cameron will re-sign with the Pies because that is where he wants to play footy.

With his mates, kicking arse.

 

[cfc19902010]

I feel like Harley Reid is tanking this year. As such, has Geelong all over it!

Yeah they’ll give him the usual tour with C&@$&k head Mackie and Mr Smug danger showing him through selling the wonders and delights of Geelong and the escape from the big smoke advantages line

 

[soreplums]

That not Official though

It will be soon.

 

[Pistol Night]

Yeah they’ll give him the usual tour with C&@$&k head Mackie and Mr Smug danger showing him through selling the wonders and delights of Geelong and the escape from the big smoke advantages line

Is those campaigners can blow Essendons ridiculous offer away with a bullshit “lifestyle” offer and a Cotton On gift basket we need a ****n royal commission into why this bullshit can happen every year and no one asks how. These pricks need to be pulled up now

 

[SchuPie]

I feel like Harley Reid is tanking this year. As such, has Geelong all over it!

Pick 26!!!

 

[manicpie]

Pick 26!!!

Don't be surprised

 

[gouki88]

What can you do in Melbourne that you can’t do in Perth?

Go to the footy multiple times a week, eat the best food in the country, see the best art & music in the country, go to Victoria Park, and plenty more.

Can’t go to any good beach, nor see the sun set over the ocean, nor stay a reasonable temperature in winter though…

 

[SchuPie]

Don't be surprised

Im with you, kind of expecting it

 

[manicpie]

Im with you, kind of expecting it

I hate Geelong

 

[jmac70]

Yeah they’ll give him the usual tour with C&@$&k head Mackie and Mr Smug danger showing him through selling the wonders and delights of Geelong and the escape from the big smoke advantages line

Trust me, there are no wonders and delights in Geelong.

 

[cfc19902010]

Is those campaigners can blow Essendons ridiculous offer away with a bullshit “lifestyle” offer and a Cotton On gift basket we need a ****n royal commission into why this bullshit can happen every year and no one asks how. These pricks need to be pulled up now

Yeah and then start investigating them for the weapon and the supplements before they got to Essendon just coincidentally when they were winning 2007 2009 premierships

 

[nahnah]

Go to the footy multiple times a week, eat the best food in the country, see the best art & music in the country, go to Victoria Park, and plenty more.

Can’t go to any good beach, nor see the sun set over the ocean, nor stay a reasonable temperature in winter though…

Brighton beach has its moments mate

 

[Ludovico]

Trust me, there are no wonders and delights in Geelong.

Well, I mean, Lambys can have a certain appeal when you are trashed and not especially discerning and the concentration of rabid cougars reaches critical mass. So most nights.

 

[cfc19902010]

Well, I mean, Lambys can have a certain appeal when you are trashed and not especially discerning and the concentration of rabid cougars reaches critical mass. So most nights.

The best thing is the road back to Melbourne

 

[manicpie]

The best thing is the road back to Melbourne

Are you sure?, the Nullarbor plain is a really long arduous drive

 

[cfc19902010]

Are you sure?, the Nullarbor plain is a really long arduous drive

From Geelong it is

 

[Go Woods]

Beaches are prob the only thing WA has. Not a whole lot of things in perth otherwise.

The Great White's love hanging out there...

 

[Go Woods]

4 years @ 900k

That's overs imo, but he is a heart and soul player and we don't want to lose him.

 

[TradeDraft]

That's overs imo, but he is a heart and soul player and we don't want to lose him.

and have to at least get close to Norths Offer