Beerfish
Unscripted Hot Takes
- Jan 20, 2008
- 64,539
- 110,074
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Nic Martin
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

BigFooty AFLW Notice Img
AFLW 2025 - AFLW Trade and Draft - All the player moves
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Redman was good tonight. Made a couple of errors but did some really good things as well.Redman looks more disinterested than injured.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Redman has been himself.Redman (despite tonight) is another who I have wondered is carrying something. Just not themselves in 2024
He does seem to drop his head too easily. Almost defeatist.There is quite literally zero dawg in Kyle Langford. You could tell he was down in confidence from the first bounce and nothing changed over the course of the game. He's been putrid since the bye.
It’s the contract he signed last year.Redman (despite tonight) is another who I have wondered is carrying something. Just not themselves in 2024
I think it is 100% right. Clubs can afford to play a proper key defender on him as we do not have decent or experienced KP forwards and Langford ends up being the main man.I'm hoping the form drop is due to hip concerns.
In the back of my mind I remember a hawthorn mate telling me how the hawks worked out Stringer after he looked unstoppable in 2015 by matching him up with a proper key defender and I wonder if something similar may have happened to Langers.
Yeah, he couldn't even kick from 50.Has to be playing injured. Not that he was ever quick but he has lost any zip and his kicking penetration is gone as well.
Yeah, not trading Langford.it's laughable that a lot of people in other threads are suggesting to trade langford, literally our best forward when healthy. how about we get players to actually support him
Our season is over and some people are melting hard which manifests as everyone either being sacked, delisted or traded.it's laughable that a lot of people in other threads are suggesting to trade langford, literally our best forward when healthy. how about we get players to actually support him

I think everyone knew we needed an upgrade on 2mp the moment we picked him up. I felt our best shot was to throw the kitchen sink at one rather than via the draft but only when we were ready. Are we ready?Yeah, not trading Langford.
Clearly injured IMO. Stringer's form not helping. Needs an in form 2mp back to take focus off him.
Don't think 2 medium forwards in Stringer and Langford is working esp when we lack a speedy small or 2.
Let’s be honest though there’s less than 10 players on our list that are “untouchables”.Our season is over and some people are melting hard which manifests as everyone either being sacked, delisted or traded.
I mean some people even want Hird back.![]()
You could even trade Ridley for all I care. Not durable enough.I think everyone knew we needed an upgrade on 2mp the moment we picked him up. I felt our best shot was to throw the kitchen sink at one rather than via the draft but only when we were ready. Are we ready?
Our forwards are so bad at kicking for goal, and Langford is likely our best, oppo can afford to put a better defender on Langford and play the odds the other Essendon forwards will miss anyhow.
Let’s be honest though there’s less than 10 players on our list that are “untouchables”.
Merrett
Ridley
Martin
Durham
Caldwell
Some should be (i.e. Redman) or could be (i.e. Caddy) but the majority of our list could be shopped around. There’ll be few takers and that will be a good lesson learned.
I do think we should trade one of Langford or Parish, preferably both. Not because they aren't important players, but because they're the only ones with currency. If we don't aggressively regenerate the list before Tassie comes in, we'll be stuffed for years after that.We need to be bold with our list management and think of long term and sustained success.it's laughable that a lot of people in other threads are suggesting to trade langford, literally our best forward when healthy. how about we get players to actually support him
Wait, wasn't he December born?Langford is 28 next year so he isn't exactly young. If we can turn him into a young KPF, then that's worthwhile.
We'll be fine without him, even if we go backwards at the beginning.
I'm hoping the form drop is due to hip concerns.
In the back of my mind I remember a hawthorn mate telling me how the hawks worked out Stringer after he looked unstoppable in 2015 by matching him up with a proper key defender and I wonder if something similar may have happened to Langers.
Ha yes, as predictable as the sun rising every morning.Our season is over and some people are melting hard which manifests as everyone either being sacked, delisted or traded.
I mean some people even want Hird back.![]()