Autopsy AFL 2023 First Qualifying Final - Pies v Demons Thurs Sept 7th 7:20pm EST (MCG)

[jakson68]

Must be hard supporting a bottom club, being in the finals is fun, hopefully you make it next year.

One should really choose your battles.
A Carlton supporter having a crack at a Geelong fan regarding making finals.

I have no words

 

[HarryBeef]

One should really choose your battles.
A Carlton supporter having a crack at a Geelong fan regarding making finals.

I have no words

Carlton are in the finals, Geelong ain't. Mic drop.

 

[jakson68]

Carlton are in the finals, Geelong ain't. Mic drop.

That is like Rick Astley saying to Bruce Springsteen "I had a hit single"

 

[danielnajdek]

Carlton are in the finals, Geelong ain't. Mic drop.

Geelong won the premiership last year, Carlton hasn’t won one in over 25 years.

Mic drop.

 

[HarryBeef]

Geelong won the premiership last year, Carlton hasn’t won one in over 25 years.

Mic drop.

Stop living in the past mate

 

[danielnajdek]

Stop living in the past mate

Facts. Live with it.

 

[HarryBeef]

Facts. Live with it.

Agree to disagree mate

 

[Demonic Ascent]

“Spud” and therefore not best 22 are the words of your supporters.

Or "Premiership CHF"

 

[No SPIN]

Or "Premiership CHF"

Good post for he VFL forum

 

[CCurnow3votes]

the boxer only has get ONE good punch in.

Ali vs Foreman ?

 

[CCurnow3votes]

I gotta say that I find it weird how JDG is consistently talked up as a 'big game player' while Oliver isn't. Even JDG's best finals have not been anything close to what Oliver produced in the 2021 finals series or the QF against Sydney last year.

Oliver is twice the player JDG is.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

One should really choose your battles.
A Carlton supporter having a crack at a Geelong fan regarding making finals.

I have no words

Our brave new world

 

[danster168]

unplugged with reference to the SEN call and the host still tipping Melbourne. Maybe the fact that melbourne dominated you last time all over the park but were inaccurate (8.18) had something to do with it. But sure, hide around the 4 points margin.

 

[unplugged]

unplugged with reference to the SEN call and the host still tipping Melbourne. Maybe the fact that melbourne dominated you last time all over the park but were inaccurate (8.18) had something to do with it. But sure, hide around the 4 points margin.

You dominated us and could only win by 4 pts.

You were missing the ugliest man in footy, who else?

We were missing De Goey, Elliott, McStay, Sidebottom and Howe.

Come @ me again when we win by 6 goals on Thurs

Just as a bit of truth telling, you should've won by more. 27 points according to Expected Score. But if you've watched the Pies over the last 2 years you'd know we don't need to lead all day to win.

 

[danster168]

You dominated us and could only win by 4 pts.

You were missing the ugliest man in footy, who else?

We were missing De Goey, Elliott, McStay, Sidebottom and Howe.

Come @ me again when we win by 6 goals on Thurs

Just as a bit of truth telling, you should've won by more. 27 points according to Expected Score. But if you've watched the Pies over the last 2 years you'd know we don't need to lead all day to win.

yeah, because we kicked 18 behinds. it was a 50 point win disguised in a 4 point win. killed you blokes.

I'm not even referring to what's going to happen on Thursday but you need to analyse the king bday game better. We killed you guys all over the park. Just couldn't finish off the work. Yeah, you've also not got Daicos.

And the ugliest guy in footy would've won 7 BnF's at your club.

 

[unplugged]

yeah, because we kicked 18 behinds. it was a 50 point win disguised in a 4 point win. killed you blokes.

I'm not even referring to what's going to happen on Thursday but you need to analyse the king bday game better. We killed you guys all over the park. Just couldn't finish off the work. Yeah, you've also not got Daicos.

And the ugliest guy in footy would've won 7 BnF's at your club.

No, it was a 4 goal win disguised as a 4 point win which you could've choked and lost in the last 30 seconds.

I hope your team is getting as much belief from KB as what you are. You realise we've had the wood over you guys since 2017/18 yeah?

Also 4 of your 18 behinds were rushed behinds so don't get too excited.

 

[unplugged]

unplugged with reference to the SEN call and the host still tipping Melbourne. Maybe the fact that melbourne dominated you last time all over the park but were inaccurate (8.18) had something to do with it. But sure, hide around the 4 points margin.

I just realised you had dragged me onto the main board. Here I was thinking I was posting on the Pies board

Had I even posted in here or have you been trawling our thread?

 

[danster168]

No, it was a 4 goal win disguised as a 4 point win which you could've choked and lost in the last 30 seconds.

I hope your team is getting as much belief from KB as what you are. You realise we've had the wood over you guys since 2017/18 yeah?

Also 4 of your 18 behinds were rushed behinds so don't get too excited.

yeah and several of our shots shanked and didn't score.
Yeah ive realised collingwood have had the wood over us but collingwood have lost their invincibility in the back half of this year.

The Petty out is a big out.

 

[SuperSub17]

unplugged with reference to the SEN call and the host still tipping Melbourne. Maybe the fact that melbourne dominated you last time all over the park but were inaccurate (8.18) had something to do with it. But sure, hide around the 4 points margin.

Round 23 last year you were up by 66 at half time against Brisbane.

At the Gabba.

Previous games mean nothing.

 

[Elixuh]

unplugged with reference to the SEN call and the host still tipping Melbourne. Maybe the fact that melbourne dominated you last time all over the park but were inaccurate (8.18) had something to do with it. But sure, hide around the 4 points margin.

You sound nervous Danny, I hate seeing you like this.

 

[Fadge]

Oliver is twice the player JDG is.

Indeed.

My favourite Clayton Oliver game against Collingwood was his 43 possession, BOG winning Queen's Birthday game against the Pies in 2022.

In fact, the Melbourne midfield destroyed us that day, with Oliver, Petracca, Viney and Brayshaw averaging 34 possessions.

The result? Pies win by 26 points.

 

[danster168]

Indeed.

My favourite Clayton Oliver game against Collingwood was his 43 possession, BOG winning Queen's Birthday game against the Pies in 2022.

In fact, the Melbourne midfield destroyed us that day, with Oliver, Petracca, Viney and Brayshaw averaging 34 possessions.

The result? Pies win by 26 points.

His career awards speak for themselves. Degoey hasn't even made an AA team yet.

 

[Fadge]

His career awards speak for themselves. Degoey hasn't even made an AA team yet.

I wasn't disagreeing with you, no need to get defensive...

 

[Gavin Excell]

I felt more pressure as a Geelong fan this equivalent game last year than I did for the PF and GF.
It can be stomach churning the long build up

 

[BuildEmUp]

yeah, because we kicked 18 behinds. it was a 50 point win disguised in a 4 point win. killed you blokes.

I'm not even referring to what's going to happen on Thursday but you need to analyse the king bday game better. We killed you guys all over the park. Just couldn't finish off the work. Yeah, you've also not got Daicos.

And the ugliest guy in footy would've won 7 BnF's at your club.

Lol 7 BnFs ... . lmfao Fritsch will play , and do his foot in first 5 minutes , and y'all will choke on your cheese and wine ( or Whine?)