Remove this Banner Ad

Current Antisemitic Attacks * Govt of Iran Behind Two Attacks

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

ANTISEMITIC EVENTS

May 25, 2024: Australia’s largest Jewish school graffitied in Melbourne.
Oct 13: Antisemitic graffiti on Jewish bakery in Sydney, with note left for owner reading “be careful”.
Nov 21: Cars torched, buildings vandalised in Sydney’s east, an area with a large Jewish population.
Dec 6: Adass Israel Synagogue torched in Melbourne’s south, treated by police as a suspected terror attack.

Jan 7, 2025: Man charged after allegedly threatening worshippers Chabad North Shore synagogue in Sydney’s north.
Jan 10: Allawah Synagogue in Sydney's south graffitied with swastikas.
Jan 11: Graffiti and attempted arson of the Newtown Synagogue in Sydney’s west.
Jan 11: Cars and house vandalised with antisemitic graffiti in Sydney’s west.
Jan 17: Cars torched, building formerly owned by a Jewish community leader vandalised in Sydney’s east.
Jan 21: Childcare centre set alight and graffitied in Sydney’s east.
Jan 29: Around a week ago, police found a caravan packed with explosives with a note of target addresses and a synagogue
Jan 30: Jewish school and a house in Maroubra vandalised
Feb 12: social media footage allegedly shows two nurses at Bankstown Hospital bragging about killing and refusing to treat Israeli patients
July 4: Protestors storm a Melbourne restaurant throwing chairs & breaking a window
July 4: Synagogue in East Melbourne under arson attack

.
 
Last edited:
I'm not denying the proven histories or even some of the unproven conspiracies that I think may have elements of truth behind them.

You can't put names to the perpetrators so you use the generic insult of "zionists".

Excuse the broad brushes, but except for some "end of times" fundementalist Christians, zionists are Jews first and foremost.

Can you give an idea of the number of Jews in Melbourne who actively and aggressivly promote a zionist viewpoint to the extent that they would destroy Torahs in arguably the most conservative and fundementalist Synagogue in Melbourne?

Do you differentiate between Jews, Israeli's and Zionists or fall back to the "Protocols of the Elders oF Zion" for the definitions you use in this forum

Zionism is a political ideology. Most of our major party politicians are zionists, for example.

We wont know the ideology of the perpetrators until they have been identified.

I hope this helps.
 
You've completely missed the point. Nobody in Australia - except some right wing peanuts on here - is saying "oh Israel was goaded and they're wealthier and more powerful so fair enough they've murdered 30,000 women and children". Lots of angry, disappointed, Aussies. Not just Muslims.

I don't doubt that there are plenty of non-Muslim's pissed off with Israel's response to a extreme(ish) level.

But I do doubt your assertion that it's only "right wing peanuts" who are also pissed off with the events of October 7 (which is still a live event that is happening FYI) and the baiting of Israel to war. I think most Aussies are pissed off with both the war-triggering behaviour and the horrors of the response.

And for the record, that is the literally the stance of our current centre-left government.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

You didn't exactly, because you just put in a heap of emotive language that is designed to obfuscate an exceedingly complicated issue, so that you can label people.

I just cut to the chase.
No, I claimed (quite clearly, I thought) that only right wing peanuts are not angry about Israel's response to October 7 and consider it acceptable and proportionate.
 
No, I claimed (quite clearly, I thought) that only right wing peanuts are not angry about Israel's response to October 7 and consider it acceptable and proportionate.

Israel's response is more than 'just' to October 7 and the war crime of continuing to hold hostages.

I have said before that Israel's best approach would have been to do exactly nothing and embarrass Hamas into submission.

But Hamas / Iran knew full well that that wouldn't happen with a right wing Israeli government and they have gotten the response that they were literally seeking. That's not to excuse Israel's part in it, but to include both of the responsible entities in our consideration of events.
 
Israel's response is more than 'just' to October 7 and the war crime of continuing to hold hostages.

I have said before that Israel's best approach would have been to do exactly nothing and embarrass Hamas into submission.

But Hamas / Iran knew full well that that wouldn't happen with a right wing Israeli government and they have gotten the response that they were literally seeking. That's not to excuse Israel's part in it, but to include both of the responsible entities in our consideration of events.

And Hamas’ response is to more than just one incident.

I don’t believe anyone has denied there’s a lot of history leading up to where we’re currently at.
 
That it was a Synagogue firebombed suggests it was a politically or religiously motivated attack.

There's no group behind this pushing a political or religious ideology, so it's not terrorism.
Here's the VIC Police presser yesterday on the matter

"likely to be a politically motivated attack"



'AFP deputy commissioner for national security, Krissy Barrett, confirmed it is now being treated as a terrorist incident, describing it as a "politically motivated attack".'
 
And Hamas’ response is to more than just one incident.

I don’t believe anyone has denied there’s a lot of history leading up to where we’re currently at.

It you list the Jews perspective of all of the wrongdoings to them on one side of the ledger and only read them out and they are an inexplicably persecuted native people to the area.

Do the same for the Palestinians on the other side of the ledger, then they an inexplicably persecuted native people to the area.

The cycle never stops if people can't get away from the opposing extremes. It's why my point against jason_recliner in this instance is that his "30,000 > 700 dead innocents" isn't helpful generally to any resolution and only adds fuel to the fire (so to speak) for burnings to synagogues and setting fire of Islamic school buses ( in Melbourne and Radelaide FFS!).
 
It you list the Jews perspective of all of the wrongdoings to them on one side of the ledger and only read them out and they are an inexplicably persecuted native people to the area.

Do the same for the Palestinians on the other side of the ledger, then they an inexplicably persecuted native people to the area.

The cycle never stops if people can't get away from the opposing extremes. It's why my point against jason_recliner in this instance is that his "30,000 > 700 dead innocents" isn't helpful generally to any resolution and only adds fuel to the fire (so to speak) for burnings to synagogues and setting fire of Islamic school buses ( in Melbourne and Radelaide FFS!).
The fire in the school bus is being treated as opportunistic and not premeditated, at this stage.

 
I'm confident you can't in NSW but can in anything goes Victoria.

There are safe access zone laws around clinics, I don't know why those laws can't quickly be applied to places of worship.

It shouldn't be that complicated.
 
There are safe access zone laws around clinics, I don't know why those laws can't quickly be applied to places of worship.

It shouldn't be that complicated.

I've heard discussions about the NSW permit system and they reckon a group would never get a permit to protest outside a place of worship as it would be purely inflammatory.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

The fire in the school bus is being treated as opportunistic and not premeditated, at this stage.


Fair enough and thanks.

Having grown up in Adelaide as a teenager, wanton destruction is high up on the Tripadvisor's list of 'Things To Do'.
 
Last edited:
I'm confident you can't in NSW but can in anything goes Victoria.

I’m pretty sure there was a pro Palestine protest in Sydney just last week (outside the Great Synagogue) where worshippers had to be locked inside for 3 hours to protect them. As a result Mimms said he wants to implement laws to make protesting outside places of worship illegal.
 
I’m pretty sure there was a pro Palestine protest in Sydney just last week (outside the Great Synagogue) where worshippers had to be locked inside for 3 hours to protect them. As a result Mimms said he wants to implement laws to make protesting outside places of worship illegal.
Yes, there was, and Jewish people on the other side of the road were accused of trying to incite them and moved on by the police 🤔

The overriding fear seems to be that if protesters are limited or controlled in any way the situation will “escalate” - well we saw that outside the weapons exhibition in Melbourne. What gives these “peaceful” protesters the right to “escalate” if they are thwarted in any way? It’s this thinking that has got us to where we are today.
 
Yes, there was, and Jewish people on the other side of the road were accused of trying to incite them and moved on by the police 🤔

The overriding fear seems to be that if protesters are limited or controlled in any way the situation will “escalate” - well we saw that outside the weapons exhibition in Melbourne. What gives these “peaceful” protesters the right to “escalate” if they are thwarted in any way? It’s this thinking that has got us to where we are today.


No one has a right to escalate. There's criminal charges associated with it.

The Police acting to limit the risks of escalation during high risk situations seems sensible.
 
Here comes the crackdown.

The AFP will lead Special Operation Avalite to investigate threats, violence and hatred towards the Australian Jewish community and parliamentarians.

Twenty-one AFP police and analysts, who are an experienced squad of counter terrorism investigators, will deploy nationally to incidents to investigate:


  • Urging violence against members of groups;
  • Advocating Terrorism;
  • Advocating Genocide;
  • Using a carriage service to make a threat; and
  • Using a carriage service to menace or harass.

 
Here comes the crackdown.

The AFP will lead Special Operation Avalite to investigate threats, violence and hatred towards the Australian Jewish community and parliamentarians.

Twenty-one AFP police and analysts, who are an experienced squad of counter terrorism investigators, will deploy nationally to incidents to investigate:


  • Urging violence against members of groups;
  • Advocating Terrorism;
  • Advocating Genocide;
  • Using a carriage service to make a threat; and
  • Using a carriage service to menace or harass.


The attorney general intervened in an ‘advocating genocide’ case yesterday and threw it out of court.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.


No one has a right to escalate. There's criminal charges associated with it.

The Police acting to limit the risks of escalation during high risk situations seems sensible.
The language, the signage and the symbols should be controlled as per the law. Also enforcement (in Victoria) of the law against wearing masks and legislated in other states.
 
Here comes the crackdown.

The AFP will lead Special Operation Avalite to investigate threats, violence and hatred towards the Australian Jewish community and parliamentarians.

Twenty-one AFP police and analysts, who are an experienced squad of counter terrorism investigators, will deploy nationally to incidents to investigate:


  • Urging violence against members of groups;
  • Advocating Terrorism;
  • Advocating Genocide;
  • Using a carriage service to make a threat; and
  • Using a carriage service to menace or harass.


All of those directed at anyone should be unacceptable.
 
How about we keep the war that is happening 14,000 kilometres away the **** out of our courts, synagogues, mosques and streets?

Please and thank you!

How about you keep the genocide spokesmen like Mark Regev off our televisions then?

Otherwise, how you going to stop him from breaking the laws regarding advocating genocide?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Current Antisemitic Attacks * Govt of Iran Behind Two Attacks

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top