B.Johnson or Hamill?

[Silvagnis]

Which one of these two mid-sized forwards would you take?

Johnson for mine because he's just a complete footballer, has the score on the board with three AA guernseys and was loyal to a struggling club that gave him his chance in the bigtime.

How much could he have earnt from another club if he had wanted out?

I feel the media still show Hamill more respect than they do Johnson who has a brilliant footballing resume.

Brad Johnson.

PLAYER HONOURS

Best and Fairest 1999, 2002; 2nd Best and Fairest 2003; 3rd Best and Fairest 2000, 2004; All-Australian 1999, 2000, 2002; International Rules Series 1998, 2000, 2002, 2003; Leading Goalkicker 2001 (49); Best Club Person 1996, 1998; AFL Rising Star nominee 1995. Captain 2005-06 for the injured Darcy.

Aaron Hamill.

Player Honours

Player honours: 3rd St Kilda best and fairest 2001; St Kilda pre-season premiership side 2004; Carlton pre-season premiership side 1997; St Kilda captain 2003.

Fact File
Brownlow Medal: 2005 votes 5; career votes 22. Previous AFL club: Carlton (1996-2000: 92 games, 114 goals).

Hamill's career.

 

[tomthetiger]

.....

 

[Bourky23]

i don't know whats the story here... quite obvious who is better.... umm i wouldn't say johnson gets less recognition than hamill... the only reason hamill has been talked about in the media recently is because he is injured and is extremely important to our side physically come september but everyone knows johnsons importance to the bulldogs and so it doesnt need to repeated again and again...its a given really i'd use the argument that they are different types of players as well... johnson not really known for his physicality

 

[matthewds]

jonno is definetly a better player he is getting better with age deserves AA again as for hamill when he is up and running he is a great player but has been getting alot of injuries

 

[goDees22]

johnson plays

 

[Cassius_Clay]

What an incredibly gay poll.

 

[Richo83]

Johnson. At least he actually plays for his team. Why do St. Kilda even pay Hamill these days. Anyway, even when Hamill is playing, he is inferior to Johnson.

 

[Jeremias]

Johnson by a long way.

Hamill is ok, but Johnno is a star.

 

[Silvagnis]

What an incredibly gay poll.

You posted!

 

[brisbane1]

id say johnno cos hes been pritty consistant over the last couple of years

 

[Cynic]

...perhaps comparing either of them to Chris Judd would be as appropriate as this poll.