Discussion Bad Graphic Design

[TY24]

The whole brand is a disappointment. The W logo looks like a building company

The W looks like a straight rip off of the old Melbourne Heart logo

 

[TY24]

Numbers aren’t centred within the two text boxes.

 

[Jack Stevens]

 

[The Victorian]

 

[caloschwaby]

View attachment 834807

That's shocking.
Should they even have access to that logo in their graphics package, given how long ago their changed it compared to when Fox Footy upgraded their graphics?

 

[TY24]

That's shocking.
Should they even have access to that logo in their graphics package, given how long ago their changed it compared to when Fox Footy upgraded their graphics?

First time I’ve seen Fox use that GWS logo as well. Normally it just has Giants.

Work experience kid probably just Googled both logos and used the first one they found

 

[The Victorian]

That's shocking.
Should they even have access to that logo in their graphics package, given how long ago their changed it compared to when Fox Footy upgraded their graphics?

Richmonds ‘new’ logo is older than Fox Footy

 

[Andonis1997]

Richmonds ‘new’ logo is older than Fox Footy

Well... the new reincarnation of Fox Footy, yes.
There used to be a Fox Footy years ago when I was in primary school, before the Suns were even a thing.

 

[The Victorian]

Well... the new reincarnation of Fox Footy, yes.
There used to be a Fox Footy years ago when I was in primary school, before the Suns were even a thing.

I know it was FOX FOOTY CHANNEL

 

[caloschwaby]

Richmonds ‘new’ logo is older than Fox Footy

Yes, that's why I said older than the last time Fox Footy upgraded their graphics package

 

[Rubber Arm]

Bit of a crook neck

 

[caloschwaby]

Bit of a crook neckView attachment 838950

It's so random, why are there St Kilda players there? They didn't even play Carlton in the Marsh Series so they'd have to photoshop them in.

Cripps a good choice for cover athlete, although I'd rather move away from that kind of setup, maybe in favour of an AFL Live cover featuring players from the previous years' Grand Final.

 

[Rubber Arm]

It's so random, why are there St Kilda players there? They didn't even play Carlton in the Marsh Series so they'd have to photoshop them in.

Cripps a good choice for cover athlete, although I'd rather move away from that kind of setup, maybe in favour of an AFL Live cover featuring players from the previous years' Grand Final.

There's so much going on in this pic. The worst part being Cripps neck in both photos.
His obviously editedd guernsey, The St Kilda players are extremely low quality photos that had obviously been edited with a blur to make it seem less low quality. The weird firey sparks that's would be cool in 2015. It's horrible

 

[caloschwaby]

There's so much going on in this pic. The worst part being Cripps neck in both photos.
His obviously editedd guernsey, The St Kilda players are extremely low quality photos that had obviously been edited with a blur to make it seem less low quality. The weird firey sparks that's would be cool in 2015. It's horrible

The whole look gives me AFL Live 2 cover vibes, that was horrible. I never played this game.

 

[WonderT]

It's so random, why are there St Kilda players there? They didn't even play Carlton in the Marsh Series so they'd have to photoshop them in.

Cripps a good choice for cover athlete, although I'd rather move away from that kind of setup, maybe in favour of an AFL Live cover featuring players from the previous years' Grand Final.

After quite a bit of searching through AFL Photos and Getty Images I finally found it. The original photo.
From Round 10 last year.



So they had to change all three jumpers. I wonder why they chose this photo if it was just going to cause more work for them.

 

[Prison bar Pete]

After quite a bit of searching through AFL Photos and Getty Images I finally found it. The original photo.
From Round 10 last year.

View attachment 839047

So they had to change all three jumpers. I wonder why they chose this photo if it was just going to cause more work for them.

puzzling. And look at the monogram position - beggars belief

 

[WonderT]

Not necessarily bad, but today, the Geelong Advertiser used a photo of Gary Ablett from 2009 (note the ISC logo on the jumper) before he left for the Gold Coast. I wonder why the paper would even have this photo ready to use.

 

[BringBackTheAnchor]

Saw this in the paper today and it is horrific how did anyone get paid for this

 

[Sauras]

Not necessarily bad, but today, the Geelong Advertiser used a photo of Gary Ablett from 2009 (note the ISC logo on the jumper) before he left for the Gold Coast. I wonder why the paper would even have this photo ready to use.

View attachment 839470

Especially when they've attached Lingys left arm when he was 18 to him.

 

[SFgiant]

The B lldogs’ graphic design and marketing team.. The 'we're playing for U' is so low effort it hurts.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

View attachment 827995
Numbers aren’t centred within the two text boxes.

They aren't, because they're trying to demonstrate depth because it's in 3D.

 

[magpienato]

Watching this blokes AFL Revamped video




This is the logo for the 'Hobart Falcons'


Aside from using Nazi insignia for a team logo, it isn't even a Falcon but rather and Eagle. Not sure if he knowingly used this or not but either way not really a good look.

As for his other designs, they're pretty basic and usually consist of some basic design element and chucking a logo over it.

 

[Craegus]

Watching this blokes AFL Revamped video




This is the logo for the 'Hobart Falcons'
View attachment 892742View attachment 892745

Aside from using Nazi insignia for a team logo, it isn't even a Falcon but rather and Eagle. Not sure if he knowingly used this or not but either way not really a good look.

As for his other designs, they're pretty basic and usually consist of some basic design element and chucking a logo over it.

 

[WonderT]

The Geelong Advertiser back at it with an old Melbourne logo on the back page.

 

[Andonis1997]

The Geelong Advertiser back at it with an old Melbourne logo on the back page.
View attachment 898611

Nah, they know exactly what they're doing...