Barry Hall vs Warren Tredrea

[Ten Ton Hammer]

who's better and who would you have in your side?

 

[hollis_tom]

Good tough question, really have no idea yet.

 

[don vito of fitzroy]

Hall. He is a great goalscorer and leader but he is tougher than Tredrea so that why I'm going for him. Hall can also turn games around, more so than Tredrea.

 

[Hollow Knight]

Hall.

 

[Bombers2000]

Both great players, I'd have to say Hall.

 

[Bloods]

Hall for me, but I watch him more.

 

[crazy_big_al]

tredders

 

[don vito of fitzroy]

Hall for me, but I watch him more.

It doesn't matter. He is a better player anyway.

 

[Thunderstruck]

Tredrea just. Equally as strong and slightly better hands. Hall better kick.

 

[Fraz]

Would be happy with either at Windy Hill but my vote goes to Hall.

 

[pafc4life]

if Tredders was as good a set shot as Barry it would be Tredders hands down. Having said that, Tredrea just.

 

[Bloods]

if Tredders was as good a set shot as Barry it would be Tredders hands down. Having said that, Tredrea just.

'Hands Down' - I don't think so.

 

[jazzadogs]

hall. i hate tredrea as he is too arrogant but hall is a better player anyway

 

[pafc4life]

'Hands Down' - I don't think so.

I do, and that's why i said it.

Hall = better set shot
Tredrea = better everything else

 

[ManWithNoName]

Hall, better player and Tredrea's far to up himself.

 

[Bloods]

I do, and that's why i said it.

Hall = better set shot
Tredrea = better everything else

You're entitled to your opinion.

I think Tredrea's hands are stronger, that's the only area I've got him ahead on.

 

[X_box_X]

I can't believe Hall is winning this poll. Sure, I'd have both players in the top five or six players in the competition, but Tredrea is surely better. Hall has started to create more goals, but Tredrea is the King of creating and also scoring goals himself. Tredrea's kicking and contested marking is slightly better. He is also better at leading up the ground and has an exceptional left (opposite) foot kick.

 

[Quinz]

Treadrea

 

[ordered off]

I will go with Warren Tredrea because he is a great captain and shows a lot of skill when he marks and kicks the ball through for a goal.

 

[outback jack]

the votes gap will soon widen as the all port supporters would of voted for tredrea by now. Such is their way.

Oh and on careers so far this poll is rather insulting to barry hall. Tredrea showed his true class this season without a top class midfield delivering to him. Barry hall is no pavlich/brown either but he is a very good leading type CHF, bit like tredders, just better and more damaging.

 

[Smokin_Joe]

Tredrea,

 

[Ten Ton Hammer]

the votes gap will soon widen as the all port supporters would of voted for tredrea by now. Such is their way.

Oh and on careers so far this poll is rather insulting to barry hall. Tredrea showed his true class this season without a top class midfield delivering to him. Barry hall is no pavlich/brown either but he is a very good leading type CHF, bit like tredders, just better and more damaging.

I think both Hall and Tredrea are slightly ahead of Brown and pavlich at this point in time!

This is for the other posters.
How is tredrea a better contesed mark than Hall when bazza has taken more than him in the last couple of years?

 

[outback jack]

I think both Hall and Tredrea are slightly ahead of Brown and pavlich at this point in time!

will they're are not ahead of pav, thats why he got the AA spot. I think brown and pav have more complete games hall and tredrea. In terms of who's greater atm its pav followed by hall imo

This is for the other posters.
How is tredrea a better contesed mark than Hall when bazza has taken more than him in the last couple of years?

Agree, tredders is yet to discover the art of contested marking really. Leading is his way. Hall has added contested marking to his game in the last couple of yrs.

 

[pafc4life]

OBJ

Tredrea > Pavlich

It's blatantly obvious the AA selectors went with Pav for a bit of a change. It really coulda gone either way.

 

[Bloods]

What does AA prove? It's just the opinions of the idiots in the media.