Carltons Midfield VS Richmond's Midfield

[Big Bad Buddy]

2 Ruckman 5 Midfielders

Carlton: (R)Kreuzer Cloke(R) Gibbs Murphy Judd Simpson Stevens

Richmond: (R)Graham Pattison (R) Cousins Tuck Foley Deledio Coughlan

 

[jonoman89]

In order of goodness at the moment....

rucks: kreuzer, warnock, jacobs, hampson, cloke

midfielders: judd, murphy, gibbs, stevens, simpson, carrazzo, scotland, grigg, hadley, walker, robinson



and ours is much better. proof is in the pudding.

 

[Danog]

Warnock hasn't even played a game for you yet.

 

[Power King]

Voted for 'both suck' because both are overrated.

LOL at claims prior to round 1 that these were the 3rd and 4th best midfields in the country... just... lol.....

Carlton's is better because they have performed better.

Richmond's midfield is amongst the worst in the league because quite simply, it's been shit. You need more than just names, you need to actually perform.

 

[choo]

Warnock hasn't even played a game for you yet.

Cousins was first named in the midfielders
Cotchin has hardly played

they are either all in or all out

 

[Silvagnis]

Warnock hasn't even played a game for you yet.

Then swap Warnock for the injured Walker and Grigg so we can lock the thread.

Why is CoLOLins listed?

 

[Rosstickle]

Why is CoLOLins listed?

Because he's had a very good first 3 games.

19.3 disposals, 5.7 marks and 1.7 goals. Not bad for a debutant.


Anyway you'd have to go Carltons. Deledio has been really disappointing this year, not to say he won't still be a star. He's gone backwards compared to last year.

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

I reckon a better comparison would have been

Judd vs Richmonds midfield

then we would have had a tighter contest... oh well next time

 

[Jatz]

carltons by a long shot

 

[SouvlakiHut]

Pattison, Jackson, Tambling, Collins.

A fearsome quartet

 

[a_fighting_fury]

Cousins was first named in the midfielders
Cotchin has hardly played

they are either all in or all out

The OP didnt mention Cotchin.

 

[Pocket Aces]

Lost all credibility when you included Tambling.

If you include him then Uni Blues have a better midfield let alone the Blues.