Changes Next Week

[RichosGuns]

Out: Helbig, Edwards

In: King, Tuck

Thought Helbig tried hard but lacks polish. Edwards was pretty awful tbh

King to come in and Tuck to come in to actually win us some clearances - has to play in our team

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Out: Helbig, Edwards

In: King, Tuck

Thought Helbig tried hard but lacks polish. Edwards was pretty awful tbh

King to come in and Tuck to come in to actually win us some clearances - has to play in our team

Don't agree , an assessment can't be made untill those pushing for selection have played !

 

[Hipster Doofus]

Out- Nahas
In- King

That is all

 

[Croat tiger]

Edwards out and delisted at the end of year not good enough.

 

[RFC7]

Out: [Any of the following]
Helbig - Not ready for AFL level
Houli - WOG (Worst On Ground)
McGuane - Has peaked as a player and is not AFL standard
Nahas - Small who is 23 [!] and not AFL standard

Edwards would want to improved a lot next week

 

[RichosGuns]

Out: [Any of the following]
Helbig - Not ready for AFL level
Houli - WOG
McGuane - Has peaked as a player and is not AFL standard
Nahas - Small who is 23 [!] and not AFL standard

Edwards would want to improved a lot next week

Not a Nahas fan but he "did things" tonight - made opputunities, broke lines. McGuane was rock solid in the first half when it kept coming down there.
Houli was a downhill which was disappointing, quiet when we were getting smashed and then everywhere when we were up and about
Edwards was shit

Pretty dissapointed with Deledio, Martin and Atsbury aswell.

 

[theyellowsash]

i thought nahas played pretty well and helbig thats a bit harsh i reckon he got into it in the second half and got some good touches. batchelor i thought was poor looked a bit awed was dropping simple marks and didnt kick great. also i dont think conca is ready yet. connors was on for a quarter and a half or something and barely got near it, and the less said about lids the better....

 

[007Tigers]

take Edwards out for tuck and possibly hellbig for someone else

id be happy to give hellbig another go... didnt get alot of it but was good

 

[aNImatedTiger]

What does Houli being a WOG have anything to do with it you pathetic Richmond supporter. Obviously RFC7 is an uneducated Collingwood supporter because WOG'S are European and Houli is Lebanese.

 

[RFC7]

Worst On Ground animated tiger.

Nahas as a 23yo small shouldn't just be "doing things" he should be at the peak of his ability and performance.

Helbig i am not knocking, he showed some good signs, but he just looks like he isn't ready for AFL.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

What does Houli being a WOG have anything to do with it you pathetic Richmond supporter. Obviously RFC7 is an uneducated Collingwood supporter because WOG'S are European and Houli is Lebanese.

Worst On Ground , Have another beer ?

 

[thecotch]

Out:
Edwards- enough is enough. Not up to it.
Nahas- VFL standard footballer.

In:
Tucky- some hardness in midflield would have been handy tnght.
King- But hasn't he got another week?

 

[aNImatedTiger]

Sorry dude, I take back my last comment.

 

[northeast tiger]

Nahas's 3rd quarter was great. One of the reasons we got back in the game. Not sure why he didn't go back in the guts in the last quarter.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Please just keep a lid on a couple of points , Nahas and Edwards are purely outside mids , I was astonished the amount of times we seen these two at the centre bounce whilst Cotchin Martin or foley were playing forward . I suspect foley cotchin and Martin were played forward often to add another dimension , the sooner Nason , Post , Griffiths and Taylor are available the better !

 

[Gak Attack]

There were times we missed Tuck and Kingy.. just know despite their lack of skills they will be in and working hard and Kingy will likely spray anyone who isn't.

 

[Spluff]

Not a chance Nahas will be dropped. If it wasn't for him we would have never gotten back into it - he was the only guy willing to break the lines and clear us out of the defensive side of the ground when everybody else was just kicking it long to the opposition.

 

[Ralll]

out:
Rance- needs to work on his composure
Nahas- did some nice things but King has the spot for now
Asbury- send him back to the 2s for a while, needs to bulk up and have a presence in the air
Grigg- i think Tucks a better option

In:
Gourdis
King
Moore
Tuck

Helbig, White, Mcguane, need to improve

 

[PHX]

Out; McGuane
In; thursty.

 

[Lance Uppercut]

Houli was a downhill which was disappointing, quiet when we were getting smashed and then everywhere when we were up and about

yep, sounds familiar

 

[Bazzar]

Tough one. The obvious Nahas for King.

It looks like being dry so i would love to see Post and old man Tuck come in.

One thing, i hope Helbig, Batch and the ripper Conc play 18 - 22 games.

 

[austyn08]

Not a chance Nahas will be dropped. If it wasn't for him we would have never gotten back into it - he was the only guy willing to break the lines and clear us out of the defensive side of the ground when everybody else was just kicking it long to the opposition.

100%. Nahas stays.

 

[Bazzar]

out:
Rance- needs to work on his composure

PMSL. Would have been beaten by 6 - 8 goals if it wasnt for him.

 

[Crumden]

out:
Rance- needs to work on his composure
Nahas- did some nice things but King has the spot for now
Asbury- send him back to the 2s for a while, needs to bulk up and have a presence in the air
Grigg- i think Tucks a better option

lol. Rance, Nahas and Grigg were three of our better players tonight. Rance under huge pressue most of the game and was rarely beaten except when a 7 foot giant managed to get in front of him to mark. Nahas was instrumental in our 6 goal 3rd quarter, and Grigg despite being a bit sloppy by foot was in everything in the backline.

 

[Big Kitty]

Out: Edwards
In: Tuck

Everyone else did enough to warrant another game at least in my eyes.