Prediction Changes v GWS R16

[KERRPOW]

^ exactly. He cant do any ****ing worse than mcinnes

 

[Wet Toast Rule]

I dont understand what ppl are trying to say with Barrass.
The club are saying its a back injury, and they take a while to get better.
What else is it going to be?

Sounds like LeCras and Kennedy will be pressing their claims but neither is likely to make it given how conservative our medicos are.

So its likely Vardy for NN (looks injured - cant take a mark or jump in the ruck so as good as useless atm)

Sheed for Ainsworth (good signs but not mature enough against the Giants)

Would also consider MAllen for McInness

 

[numbat06]

I swear in the last quarter when then was 10 points in it he stopped and watched a crows players waltz past him did not bother to tackle bump or anything he need to go NOW

When Galluci ran through him smh

 

[JEagle]

- FMac is a WAFL player. He is not up to it at AFL level.
- Sheed must come back in. The people who disagree here are wrong. He is a ball winner in the contest. Can butcher it at times and needs games to warm up. The lesson for the match committee is to always bring him back through the wafl. Min or 2 games to get momentum, then to seniors.
- Waterman looked tired. Needs a spell at some stage soon.
- NN came back from the knee in amazing fashion. Was always going to drop off with some crap form at some stage.
- Jetta should be dropped. He is lazy. It's that simple
We know what he can do, but everything he is, doesn't make up for what he isn't. Zero urgency in his game.
- Bring in Venables. Don't worry about low numbers at WAFL level. Kid is an AFL player.

 

[flamingEMBERS]

Has Barrass been training?

 

[EdCurnowRules]

Please explain how Cripps gets dropped and who coming in is better?

Id bet my left testicle you dont have anything valid to explain this call.

Is yours smaller and performs worse than the other..2? No bet

 

[Obeanie1]

Which makes me ask the question is he medically fit or has he just lost his mojo since being suspended. There's something wrong as he doesn't seem right.

Noticed Nics thumb was heavily strapped. May effect his tackling and marks but not the drop off in running and jumping. That likely is knee come back related

 

[WCE Wizard]

What happens if the one ruck should get injured? With our present injuries can't afford to go in with just 1 ruck IMO. Either Vardy comes in & gives Nic a spell or we persevere with both Nic & Lycett for the time being.

One thing is for sure we cannot play Lycett, Vardy and Nic. Too top heavy, we are forgetting that JD and JK are so mobile at ground level

 

[WCE Wizard]

- FMac is a WAFL player. He is not up to it at AFL level.
- Sheed must come back in. The people who disagree here are wrong. He is a ball winner in the contest. Can butcher it at times and needs games to warm up. The lesson for the match committee is to always bring him back through the wafl. Min or 2 games to get momentum, then to seniors.
- Waterman looked tired. Needs a spell at some stage soon.
- NN came back from the knee in amazing fashion. Was always going to drop off with some crap form at some stage.
- Jetta should be dropped. He is lazy. It's that simple
We know what he can do, but everything he is, doesn't make up for what he isn't. Zero urgency in his game.
- Bring in Venables. Don't worry about low numbers at WAFL level. Kid is an AFL player.

I agree with all of this yes PLEASE. Based on this would you say

Out Jetta, Waterman, NN, Mcinnes, Hutchings
In Vennbles, Vardy, Barras, Lecca, Sheed

 

[WCE Wizard]

Has Barrass been training?

I hope he is he not playing robs us of critical structure down back, allows us to play Gov forward and Yeo in the middle

 

[WCE Wizard]

^ exactly. He cant do any ******* worse than mcinnes

I can do better than Mcinnes or even a stationery tree

 

[WCE Wizard]

IN Kennedy, Petruccelle, Sheed, Vardy, Venables
OUT Mcinnes, Cripps, Masten, Hutchings, Waterman,

Agreed would we be too top heavy with JK, Vardy, Lycett and Nic Nat. Would you bring in Barras instead so he can play down back?

 

[WCE Wizard]

I'd bring in Lecras and hopefully Barrass.

Ryan could be dropped, Rioli has seemed to play worse since Ryan has come back (although his could be coincidental due to JD and JK missing).

I wouldn't bring in Sheed into a team containing Redden and Hutchings, plus I'm keen to see Ainsworth deliver, he's quality moving through traffic and didn't panic like some senior boys. He also is not afraid to bust a gut trying to tackle.

To be fair the forwards were starved of opportunities i mean 34 inside 50's and also robbed of structure but yes we need alot more from the small guys. They need to look at Cripps he worked his backside off. If Ryan, Cripps and Rioli, Waterman all chipped in with 2 goals each we would have won easily

 

[Chris_6678]

Wc released a statement about liam ryan and a traffic incident with police

 

[Boohemian]

Wc released a statement about liam ryan and a traffic incident with police

http://www.westcoasteagles.com.au/news/2018-07-02/club-statement-liam-ryan

 

[Feeling Groovy]

Wc released a statement about liam ryan and a traffic incident with police

Hope its just an accident and no more to it. The last thing we need is a scandal and him having issues and a club suspension etc.

 

[Ochre]

Burn it all down

 

[campaigner___]

I have reliable sauces that have told me:

• Barrass is 75% chance of returning this week.
• Kennedy and Darling are essentially already ruled out- neither have intention of playing this week.
• Lecras will be playing this week.

That being said, I think Mallen finally comes in for McInnes. Vardy may be replacing NN due to "soreness". Sheed for Ainsworth.

 

[Obeanie1]

I would bring Vardy in as he can take a grab , can kick a goal and also do some forward ruck work, he will at least draw a decent KPD and he certainly offers more to the side than McInnes.

Oh and Jetta has to go he sets a bad example and quite frankly at times looks like he doesn't give a shit.
His attitude and production this last month has been bitterly disappointing.
If players don't put in and look pedestrian and just spectate while on the ground then its time to **** them off.

Agree with Jetta. We would be so much better with the Melbourne Jetta in defence. At least he is hard at it and tackles.

What would be interesting is if Gaff went to the Dees as a FA and we enticed their Jetta over as a FA what the net compo would be?

If it netted us a 2nd rounder in the low 30's woyld Jetta plus 32 be better than a single pick around 18ish?

Then again the AFL rarely do us any favours

 

[Boohemian]

I have reliable sauces that have told me:

• Barrass is 75% chance of returning this week.
• Kennedy and Darling are essentially already ruled out- neither have intention of playing this week.
• Lecras will be playing this week.

That being said, I think Mallen finally comes in for McInnes. Vardy may be replacing NN due to "soreness". Sheed for Ainsworth.

Ya sauces know the dealio on Liam Ryan?

 

[Luuuc]

http://www.westcoasteagles.com.au/news/2018-07-02/club-statement-liam-ryan

Closest he has come to making physical contact with another human in the last few days. Positive signs.

 

[campaigner___]

Ya sauces know the dealio on Liam Ryan?

Nope
Hopefully no alcohol involved...

 

[WCE Wizard]

I have reliable sauces that have told me:

• Barrass is 75% chance of returning this week.
• Kennedy and Darling are essentially already ruled out- neither have intention of playing this week.
• Lecras will be playing this week.

That being said, I think Mallen finally comes in for McInnes. Vardy may be replacing NN due to "soreness". Sheed for Ainsworth.

Yeah i agree Darling and JK wont play Barras and Lecca make a big difference to our structure

 

[Chris_6678]

I have reliable sauces that have told me:

• Barrass is 75% chance of returning this week.
• Kennedy and Darling are essentially already ruled out- neither have intention of playing this week.
• Lecras will be playing this week.

That being said, I think Mallen finally comes in for McInnes. Vardy may be replacing NN due to "soreness". Sheed for Ainsworth.

When are jk and darling due back?

 

[WCE Wizard]

When are jk and darling due back?

JK Collingwood, Darling against the Dogs