Changes v Melbourne

[port_adelaide_1870]

Yes. That's why I feel sorry for him. Looks talented but Neade, Amon, S. Gray, Mitchell, Colquhoun, Impey etc.

I don't get your problem... Neade, Colquhoun, S.Gray and Mitchell all probably won't play this weekend.

Amon, Impey and Snelling all in the team at once would be fine

 

[mic59]

Also how on earth does Oshea get promoted...I have watched the last 3 maggies games and mates and I could not stop laughing at his poor form..If he could have been dropped he would have

I don't get to all the games but I went to Port v Adelaide at Alberton and O'Shea was our best. Cleared the ball from defence plenty of times and gavehis man a complete thrashing. I was at the Eagles game too and he was not all that bad in the first half but dropped off in the second half.

 

[FallingLiefs]

heights not as big a problem as weight is. players like Impey, height isn't a huge factor his weight/power ratio is out of this world.

note Sam Mitchell - 83kg. Lachie Neale - 80kg.

I wouldn't draft anyone that projects to be under 80kg.

 

[TeeKray]

My mate just told me he thinks OShea is in...I suppose his outstanding form at sanfl would warrant????

So Ken dropped you for O'Shea?

 

[Lagooner]

Happy Melt Day everyone!

It looks like Lobbe is back in the mix and with our pathetic effort on the weekend I'd expect to see a few more changes too.

Any chance for a debut this week? Palmer? Bonner?

 

[PowerBaz]

Hardly a melt day, shifting deck chairs day, season cooked again too early. I dislike how far we came whilst the mob down the rd have walked straight past us, sums up attitude of this group.

 

[Lagooner]

Hardly a melt day, shifting deck chairs day, season cooked again too early. I dislike how far we came whilst the mob down the rd have walked straight past us, sums up attitude of this group.

Respectfully disagree.

If Butcher gets dropped for Lobbe I'm gonna Chernobyl this mothergoosing thread.

 

[El_Scorcho]

Respectfully disagree.

If Butcher gets dropped for Lobbe I'm gonna Chernobyl this mothergoosing thread.

^

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

 

[1954]

I had lunch at the club on Monday, and while I was waiting at the bar to buy a beer there were 4 or 5 players having coffees made by the bar staff.

Admittedly 2 of them were Mitchell and Neade, White and ( I think the Hoon who was sitting with his back to me), were others.

I was standing fairly close to Cam O'Shea who was about 2 metres to my right.
I am only a Collinwood 6 footer ( 182 cm and about 83 kegs ), and if Cam is 10 plus cm taller than me ( as advertised ) I would be very surprised, he is also built like a yard of pump water.

Mitchell was the only player in that group that I would describe as having an AFL body, but as we all know he doesn't have an AFL skillset.

I expect at least 2 of the above will be promoted to the Power line up against the Dees.

 

[Steve Dore]

Hardly a melt day ........

You're new here aren't you?

 

[RossFC]

Life won't be fair if Butcher is dropped for Lobbe, gets delisted, then Lobbe spends next year in the 2nds on big money.

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

id rather see Lobbe play than butcher. at least Lobbe has had a few seasons where we thought he could make it. Butcher is a dead man walking so what is the point.

EDIT - and im no Lobbe fan.

 

[mightypowerrrr]

Hinkley basically confirmed Lobbe will play on radio today

lobbe's game in the sanfl further proves he rucks well lonesome.

we should hopefully let lobbe go against gawn for most of the game and let Trengrove give him a chopout.

Also the dees have Hogan and Watts so Trengrove's experience down back is needed.

 

[Byrons Firen]

I don't get to all the games but I went to Port v Adelaide at Alberton and O'Shea was our best. Cleared the ball from defence plenty of times and gavehis man a complete thrashing. I was at the Eagles game too and he was not all that bad in the first half but dropped off in the second half.

His decision making under pressure is Cam's achilles heel. That Carlton game was wtf stuff. Mind you he's not alone.
Our ability to turn a slice of rare roast beef into a shit sandwich makes us excruitiating to watch at times.
Ken give us long suffering tragics something to get excited about. Debut somebody...............anybody.

 

[mic59]

His decision making under pressure is Cam's achilles heel. That Carlton game was wtf stuff. Mind you he's not alone.
Our ability to turn a slice of rare roast beef into a shit sandwich makes us excruitiating to watch at times.
Ken give us long suffering tragics something to get excited about. Debut somebody...............anybody.

True he has been frustrating and inconsistent. My post was put up more for correction of fact as the poster I replied to said O'Shea's performance had been laughable in the past 3 Maggies games and I saw the two at Alberton, one where he was our best and one where he was not the worst on the ground.

 

[Dylan8]

Bass just said there's a reasonable chance Lobbe will come in to support Jacko this week (on EON radio)

 

[DazzaTys]

This is bollocks, where are the white board rumours? There's certainly not enough teeth baring rabies salivating going on at the moment. Is it that nothing can surprise us any more or we are resigned to the fact that we just suck?

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

This is bollocks, where are the white board rumours? There's certainly not enough teeth baring rabies salivating going on at the moment. Is it that nothing can surprise us any more or we are resigned to the fact that we just suck?

That better? [emoji23][emoji6]

 

[Winganeen]

Ken on the whiteboard....

 

[OneGreatClub]

Ken on the whiteboard....

View attachment 275559

Or..pray for us

 

[Lagooner]

That better? [emoji23][emoji6]

All I see is the #11 baby!

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Wow really Ken? Lobbe has been completed turd in the SANFL this year, wtf.

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

Wow really Ken? Lobbe has been completed turd in the SANFL this year, wtf.

its all about supply and demand

 

[John the Butcher]

Ten says
In: PALMER Lobbe
Out: BUTCHER

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

**** off.